3 ms·
Hum... All the other answers on that thread are variations of "yes, we could, here's an example of how" with the examples varying from one widely impractical id
by marcosdumay 5y ago
Hum... All the other answers on that thread are variations of "yes, we could, here's an example of how" with the examples varying from one widely impractical idea to "here is how we do something similar by accident today, we just have to control it".
If we had to overpower the Sun to communicate, we wouldn't use radio on Earth either.
- throw1234651234 5y agoHaving followed that answer for years and read quite a bit, I am fairly certain that the "yes, but" answers are wrong. It's as simple as "you can't see a flashlight when it's being flicked on and off behind a lighthouse lamp". I am very interested in the topic.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, I'd suggest a basic introduction to optics. You seem unaware of the existence of lenses and mirrors. "What kind of mirror we would need to send a signal 10 light years away" is a much more reasonable question. And one of the answers there is about it.
- throw1234651234 5y agoYou mean mirror that's out of the way of the sun and is huge, or a mirror swarm. Do elaborate how you imagine this working in practice.
- ninjanomnom 5y agoIf we had to emit light just like a flashlight vs a lighthouse, aka roughly equivalent wavelengths, you'd be right, however we only have to beat the sun in a single wavelength. An extreme uv laser is probably the easiest option there. We also only need to beat the sun's output in a single pinpoint (in cosmic scale) Also to damage the example a bit, we can easily detect a flashlight shining from behind a lighthouse. Our eyes are just logarithmic and suck at detecting smaller absolute differences like that. Isaac Arthur does a good video on this topic and talks about some of the specifics of such a beacon starting at around 14 minutes https://youtu.be/DHoOjIEcRV8?t=829 https://youtu.be/DHoOjIEcRV8?t=829