4 ms·
If those people aren't getting paid a very high wage, they can reduce their working hours too. If they are getting paid a very high wage, then they already had
by Dylan16807 5y ago
If those people aren't getting paid a very high wage, they can reduce their working hours too.
If they are getting paid a very high wage, then they already had the leverage needed to reduce their working hours, and they were choosing not to. They'll still make plenty of money.
- caskstrength 5y ago> They'll still make plenty of money. How much is "plenty" and who gets to decide? What if they live in high CoL area? You propose they should sponsor someone else's leisure time instead of buying a house for their family, for example?
- Dylan16807 5y agoThat's basically a normal tax question at that point.
- caskstrength 5y agoWell, yeah, this is exactly what I've been saying in this thread: Any realistic UBI program will be payed by taxes on middle class.
- Dylan16807 5y agoSo go use those arguments you already mentioned, about redistribution and buying houses, against current taxes. You can even use the same complaints about freeloaders. You made it sound like this caused new objections, rather than being one more bout of business as usual tax griping.
- caskstrength 5y agoYou seem to be upset with my arguments for some reason. However, if you read some other comments here and multitude of previous UBI-related discussions, you will see that there are a lot of people who (naively) assume that UBI will be somehow financed by taxes on corporations (from one of the comments: "Really, you'd just want to tax corporations over a certain size that are both highly automated (i.e. high revenue per employee), and have lopsided compensation structures (which could be measured by CEO to median worker pay)."). However, if you want to get a good approximation how modern politicians structure similar programs, then just look at California health care tax proposal (aka "Let's make healthcare free for ourselves and get tech-bros pay for it!").
- Dylan16807 5y agoI'm not upset, I just think that particular argument doesn't support keeping the status quo. And because of that, I don't find it very convincing as an argument against making a change. And I would prefer not to get into the details of who gets taxed or how to optimally structure a tax today.
- loceng 5y agoAnd I'm not totally sure my visualization in my head is correct, but if everyone is getting $1,000 per month with a high quality of life provided with that, an additional $1,000 per month is weighted much more purchase power wise than in today's model.
- renewiltord 5y agoThat’s the interesting thing. Some people want to be lifetime wage slaves: they will work till they die at a low earnings level. Others would like to make five times as much with five times as much work. Proportionality is what they value. The problem, apparently, is that you want to force the latter into the former lifestyle. To that, I say no. In fact, you’re not going to get that world.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> The problem, apparently, is that you want to force the latter into the former lifestyle. No I don't. If I was in charge then for step one I wouldn't change the amount of money those people make at all, I'd try to claw back any productivity gains from the last few decades that aren't going to workers and see how much UBI that can turn into. If I did want to tax someone with 5x income more, it wouldn't be that much more.
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>I'd try to claw back any productivity gains from the last few decades If productivity gains come from capital, not from labor, then trying to take that from rewarding capital will also hurt labor. Over the past few decades a significant amount of productivity gains are from capital investment. Your average worker isn't simply turning out 2x or 3x the goods with the same effort. They have been given a productivity multiplier tool paid for by investment before they set foot on the job. When it often takes significant tooling and tech investment from an employer to increase productivity, if that stops, we're back to much earlier productivity and level of goods. Next, over the past few decades, there has been (in the US, likely others) legislation benefiting workers that has a cost to employers, which has also taken up some wage growth, by giving workers other benefits. BLS tracks such things under terms like total cost of employment and total remuneration. If you look at these over historical periods, you can see more places that workers are better off today than in decades past, without it showing up in wages. There are reasonable causes not all productivity gains are immediately given as wages - not all gains come from workers.
- 5y ago