5 ms·
> Multiple studies of where basic income was tried in the real world found it to reduce work. Isn't that a good outcome? Humans get more leisure time.
by rwmj 5y ago
> Multiple studies of where basic income was tried in the real world found it to reduce work.
Isn't that a good outcome? Humans get more leisure time.
- caskstrength 5y agoNot for the other group who will have products of their labor "redistributed" to pay for other's leisure time?
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoGettting rid of serfdom, debt prisons and endentured servitude all reduced work and caused products of labour to be redistributed. Who said that current distribution of products of labour between Amazok and their workers is optimal?
- caskstrength 5y agoWe all fantasize Bezos and Musk should pay for it, but in reality it will be yet another tax on middle class (e.g. run-of-the-mill senior developer from high CoL area, so from Amazon engineer to (would be ex) Amazon warehouse worker).
- notahacker 5y agoWould be even broader than that (run-of-the-mill junior dev in high CoL ara to lower middle class homeowner that fancies early retirement)
- ryan93 5y agoIf we are getting rid of serfdom why has no one suggested this money goes to third world workers?
- Dylan16807 5y agoIf those people aren't getting paid a very high wage, they can reduce their working hours too. If they are getting paid a very high wage, then they already had the leverage needed to reduce their working hours, and they were choosing not to. They'll still make plenty of money.
- caskstrength 5y ago> They'll still make plenty of money. How much is "plenty" and who gets to decide? What if they live in high CoL area? You propose they should sponsor someone else's leisure time instead of buying a house for their family, for example?
- Dylan16807 5y agoThat's basically a normal tax question at that point.
- caskstrength 5y agoWell, yeah, this is exactly what I've been saying in this thread: Any realistic UBI program will be payed by taxes on middle class.
- Dylan16807 5y agoSo go use those arguments you already mentioned, about redistribution and buying houses, against current taxes. You can even use the same complaints about freeloaders. You made it sound like this caused new objections, rather than being one more bout of business as usual tax griping.
- caskstrength 5y agoYou seem to be upset with my arguments for some reason. However, if you read some other comments here and multitude of previous UBI-related discussions, you will see that there are a lot of people who (naively) assume that UBI will be somehow financed by taxes on corporations (from one of the comments: "Really, you'd just want to tax corporations over a certain size that are both highly automated (i.e. high revenue per employee), and have lopsided compensation structures (which could be measured by CEO to median worker pay)."). However, if you want to get a good approximation how modern politicians structure similar programs, then just look at California health care tax proposal (aka "Let's make healthcare free for ourselves and get tech-bros pay for it!").
- loceng 5y agoYou mean for the machine's labour - progressively more and more as more and more is automated, and where people with their UBI are paying into the system (consumers aren't a fuel leak, they're the largest cog in the wheel) and workers will be getting paid adequately on top of the UBI they'll be getting too? A concept missed by most is that the buying power of "$1,000"/month grows exponentially as more and more gets automated.
- caskstrength 5y ago> You mean for the machine's labour - progressively more and more as more and more is automated How do you propose to finance UBI? All proposals that I've seen assume middle class to pay (for example, "everyone pays percentage of their income and then everyone gets fixed amount of money at the end of the period"), not nebulous machine-automation overlords. > A concept missed by most is that the buying power of "$1,000"/month grows exponentially as more and more gets automated. I don't observe housing getting exponentially cheaper "as more and more gets automated". In fact, I believe landlords would capture non-trivial amount of any potential UBI program.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChrisLomont 5y agoA lowering of work means a lowering of goods means society, including those not working, get less. Sure, more leisure time is good, but mostly only so if mankind still gets the goods and services they are used to. UBI would not do that. When national productivity drops a few percent, it's a recession, and people notice the lack of goods and services. People can already work less. But people also like goods and services.
- loceng 5y agoDoes your thinking here work if including automation into the equation? Why didn't society then collapse when automation began - like textile/garment/fabric manufacturing, etc? You also seem to be ignoring the other side of productivity - if it drops it's arguably, in part at least, that less people are buying - so there's no funds/fuel for the local system. If UBI had to be spent locally and only on "local" goods - within the ststem - then there's no leak, and instead of fueling China and letting the tank run dry locally - you force fuel to be spent locally. This is why major, credible think tanks estimate an immediate 13%+ increase in GDP with implementing a $1,000/month UBI.
- ChrisLomont 5y ago>Does your thinking here work if including automation into the equation? Yes, I am more of a technologist than anything. Automation is not free, and if a thing can be efficiently automated it is already or will be as soon as it's efficient. Automation gains in the past have not freed large swaths of workers, simply because as more goods are available people want higher quality of life, absorbing any gains. If you want to live like someone in 1950 you could on a much lower salary than people get now, but people now want bigger houses, more cars, more goods, more entertainment, more of everything. If you think automation will free us all, work on figuring out why all the massive automation gains did not already free large amounts of people from work. >If UBI had to be spent locally and only on "local" goods - within the ststem - then there's no leak This completely fails. Consider how good your life would be if you could only have goods you made. Not nice. Then make it people within a mile of you. Better, but still crap. Make it a US state. Better again, but not really anywhere near first world standards. If you want a first world standard of living, you need goods from around the planet and skilled people from around the planet trading and making and innovating. Buy local simply lowers your quality of life (and everyone, since you'll soon lower the # of specialists that can exist by serving large populations). >This is why major, credible think tanks estimate an immediate 13%+ increase in GDP with implementing a $1,000/month UBI. And others have reached the opposite conclusion. Most importantly, the evidence from real world trials is consistent with a smaller, not larger, economy.