7 ms·
>They simulated the reward structure of different forms of social security in an experiment. ‘We got people to do a task on a computer,’ says De Kwaadsteniet. ‘
by gruez 5y ago
>They simulated the reward structure of different forms of social security in an experiment. ‘We got people to do a task on a computer,’ says De Kwaadsteniet. ‘In multiple rounds, which represented the months they had to work, they did a boring task in which they had to put points on a bar. The more of these they did, the more money they earned.’
"short term experiments done in a lab" seems to be psychology's equivalent of "in vitro" (aka. in a test tube). I'm not really sure how you can draw any conclusions about someone's lifetime behavior, using a experiment that looks at the behavior of people sitting at a few hours at a computer.
- kevingadd 5y agoThere have already been real world basic income experiments with similar outcomes
- HPsquared 5y agoThey have the same problem: the participants know it's only an experiment. They know it's temporary.
- alkonaut 5y agoIf someone seriously wanted to run an experiment/trial it would need to be on the scale of a medium sized city and a decade before I’d be willing to draw any conclusions at all.
- pc86 5y agoThe fact that properly done experiments have the same outcome doesn't mean that these "let's go to the psych department from 1-4 this afternoon to get a $50 gift card" pseudo-experiments hold any real value.
- CaptainNegative 5y agoIf you're referring to longer-term experiments, do they show actual statistical significance? One of the two I've read through, the UBC experiment, showed a similar outcome but was only significant at the p≈0.13 or p≈0.24 level, depending on the precise statement of the null hypothesis, which is not particularly enthralling. The Stockton one I recall showing something similar but don't have the precise numbers for.
- missedthecue 5y agoIf I'm receiving $1000 a month for a six month program run by a university research group, which states very clearly that the program will end after six months, I'm not going to go quit my job. That's the problem with these "studies". They are completely different from a permanent government program. They can't tell you the impact on inflation, the impact on the labor market, or if it is affordable over the long term.
- fma 5y ago20+ year year old permanent program https://www.wired.com/story/free-money-the-surprising-effects-of-a-basic-income-supplied-by-government/ https://www.wired.com/story/free-money-the-surprising-effect...
- KerryJones 5y agoPaywalled, anyone have another link?
- sintaxi 5y agoAgain, inflation isn't accounted for.
- Aunche 5y agoObviously, receiving free money is better than not receiving free money. There's nothing surprising about that. The question is where this money will come from. You can't support universal basic income from casinos or oil wealth, both of which have major negative externalities to boot.
- missedthecue 5y agoThis is functionally no different than dividends paid by a company to its shareholders (although this Casino enjoys a local state-sanctioned monopoly, and the shareholder is the tribe council, so it is slightly different, but economically similar). UBI on the other hand is done by taxing ourselves to pay ourselves, or worse, printing to pay ourselves.
- faet 5y ago
- KerryJones 5y agoCan you show some of these? My research has shown the opposite
- quotemstr 5y agoYep. Meaningless. Yet the paper will be blasted from one end of the earth to the other by people who care more about their agenda than the universe's frequently unhappy truths. Probably the same people who said that increasing the money supply wouldn't cause inflation because MMT or some other tendentious garbage.
- onion2k 5y agoMeaningless. It's not meaningless. It's not enough to prove that basic income will have a long term positive impact, but it is enough to show further experimentation on a larger, more long term scale is worthwhile. It's decidedly unreasonable, not to mention unscientific, to dismiss something because you don't like it.
- quotemstr 5y agoWe've done that experiment. The results are self-evident. This isn't suggestive, valid science. It's the equivalent of setting up a "scientific" contraption that purports to be a perpetual motion machine. You can create a pretty convincing fake perpetual motion machine, but because we have a broader theory of mechanics, we know perpetual motion is impossible, that the purported machine must be cheating somehow (even if it's not immediately obvious), and that to give funding for further study based on that machine's existence would be absolutely stupid.
- mhh__ 5y agoWhich experiment? You mean the welfare queen concept?
- klyrs 5y ago> We've done that experiment. The results are self-evident. Do you mean the Alaska Permanent Fund, or something else?
- ashtonkem 5y agoThat’s exactly what I assumed. I think it would be a pretty hard argument to say that Alaskans are lazy because of their permanent fund.