4 ms·
Apple dropped built-in noise cancellation on the iPhone 13
- Snoozus 5y agoWell, did it ever work?
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe article says that yes, it worked on previous models.
- suifbwish 5y agoThen the guy who knew how it worked left?
- sudosysgen 5y agoProbably not. It's not rocket science. There's even open-source implementations [1, 2] that can do it for you. Basically you take two microphones, one close to the mouth and one farther away, and try to compute the difference. I have no idea why it's not there. I'm quite baffled, actually. [1]: https://github.com/wangwei2009/coherence https://github.com/wangwei2009/coherence [2]: https://github.com/SIP-Lab/iOS-TwoExternalMics https://github.com/SIP-Lab/iOS-TwoExternalMics
- tinus_hn 5y agoMight just as well be it still works on this one but can’t be turned off, and support just has wrong information.
- 1123581321 5y agoStrange regression. There is a decent noise cancellation feature on the AirPods Pro, that's a first class feature instead of being buried in accessibility. It's unclear to me how much of the processing for that happens on the AirPods instead of the phone. I'm not saying that APP are a substitute for improving hearing ability on the handset (old term alert!) itself.
- sudosysgen 5y agoProbably all of the processing is being made in the headphones itself, latency makes it difficult to do on the phone.
- j-kent 5y agoI've used the noise cancelling feature on my Airpod Pros on both iPhone and Android, so I'd assume that the processing is handled by the headphones themselves.
- brirec 5y agoThe noise cancellation works even without a device connected, so it most certainly is done on the headphones themselves.
- jmrm 5y agoThis doesn't seems to have any sense to me. Removing that feature won't give any hardware advantage, because if they remove the camera microphone, then the audio in videos will be worsr, and won't be any software advantage, because it's pretty improbable that affect any other part of software in any way. Some people could say "that is done to force users to buy AirPods", but what happens to those people (like me) who use their phone without any headphones? And I won't buy any of them because I don't feel comfortable using the phone in that way. If this ends to be true, and not that noise cancellation is on by default and you can't turn it off (a thing that can be true for an Apple product), it would be Apple laughing to their customers and not anything else.
- vineyardmike 5y agoPeople seem baffled its gone for no reason, but I have long suspected the feature caused audio artifacts. When I would FaceTime friends, if I had the phone leaning against something, portrait oriented (so charging port towards table) I would occasionally get terrible artifacts in the call. I assume it had to do with some audio filtering thing causing feedback. It was def a software issue because it showed up one day multiple devices (me and friends and partner) after a major version update. So, maybe they took it out because the sound quality was impacted too much.
- moistly 5y agoPossibly a patent issue?
- Tagbert 5y agoThe feature still appears on iPhone 12 with current software
- _kulang 5y agoI thought this was found to be a software bug At the very least it’s a software removal. I hope it’s restored