11 ms·
A fuel spill from the U.S. Navy poisons the water of thousands in Hawaiʻi
- encryptluks2 5y agoAnd this is where people will learn that even if the US government contaminated the water supply of the entire US or accidentally detonated a nuclear bomb of Manhattan killing millions, the response will be... we had a systematic failure, sorry for your loss, we'll try to do better next time.
- hammock 5y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted.. this comment seems to have a ring of truth. You could even apply it to the coronavirus
- dukeofdoom 5y agoHawaii needs its independence back
- cronix 5y agoHow long do you think that would last given the prime strategic location? Do you think any other countries would like a large base 1/2 way between Asia and the US mainland? It's sure a lot easier to take over an existing stable island than build your own, which China has been doing. https://www.newsweek.com/china-south-china-sea-islands-build-military-territory-expand-575161 https://www.newsweek.com/china-south-china-sea-islands-build...
- sudosysgen 5y agoLol, there is zero chance that China can take Hawaii. This is meaningless fearmongering. The Chinese are going to have a hell of a tough time if they tried to invade Taiwan, 200km away (but they might succeed), what makes you think Hawaii, 10,000km away would be feasible? Also, before taking Hawaii, they'd have to take Guam, which they don't even remotely plan to. Absolute bollocks. The Chinese are never going to be economically or militarily dominant enough to pull it off. For the US to do it, they had to get in a position where they were >40% of the global economy. Even if every Chinese citizen was three times richer and that the average American didn't get any richer, they still wouldn't get to that kind of dominant position.
- cronix 5y agoI'm sure once upon a time no one in their right mind considered Japan attacking Pearl Harbor a realistic possibility (as in "zero chance" to use your words), yet it happened. Doesn't have to be China at all - I just used it as an example of a country currently building artificial islands for military purposes and how taking an island with no military presence (US has left, remember) would be easier than building your own. It's a very strategic location. If the US left it, I don't think you can say with a high degree of confidence that someone else wouldn't be interested in taking it over. It's a relatively small place in the middle of a big ocean that is totally dependent on the outside for survival. Again, it doesn't have to be China. And I'm not advocating for the US keeping Hawaii. Just pointing out a simple realistic possibility that if the US left Hawaii, like the OP I was replying to suggested, that likely someone else will take it for themselves. > Also, before taking Hawaii, they'd have to take Guam, Why would the US Territory of Guam come into play if the US gave up Hawaii and it was no longer a part of the US to defend?
- sudosysgen 5y ago> I'm sure once upon a time no one in their right mind considered Japan attacking Pearl Harbor a realistic possibility (as in "zero chance" to use your words), yet it happened. Doesn't have to be China at all - I just used it as an example of a country currently building artificial islands for military purposes and how taking an island with no military presence (US has left, remember) would be easier than building your own. It's a very strategic location. The attack on Pearl Harbor only worked because they managed to do it in secret. It would have been suicidal and a disaster otherwise. The US overestimated it's intelligence capabilities, but they were right to think it was an improbable attack. Nowadays this wouldn't work. China's islands are very close to it's territory, and were preceded by 50 years of claims in that area. > Again, it doesn't have to be China Who else? > Why would the US Territory of Guam come into play if the US gave up Hawaii and it was no longer a part of the US to defend? For multiple reasons. Firstly, it's going to be impossible for the Chinese to actually hold Hawaii if Guam and it's related island chain is under US control and operational militarily. Fully impossible. Second, if the Chinese indeed managed to fully take Hawaii, Guam becomes completely indefensible. So the US is essentially obliged not to let Hawaii come into Chinese hands or it's entire military position crumbles. Thirdly, an invasion would be obvious and Guam is in a really good position to deny it.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoHmm...I remember this same logic being used before. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNqozQ8uaV8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNqozQ8uaV8 Just because someone else would steel it, does not mean it belongs to you. What is this...kindergarten level morality.
- cronix 5y ago> What is this...kindergarten level morality. It could be because I didn't make that claim of keeping it because someone else might take it. I only pointed out that someone will likely want it absent a US presence due to its strategic location.
- CyanBird 5y agoAhh yes, the classic hackernews with its US jingoism, "if we weren't an imperial power, then others would take our imperial holdings!!" Right...
- bpodgursky 5y agoHawaii would not vote for independence, so this is a dumb hypothetical.
- thr0wawayf00 5y ago> There is a perspective [in Hawaiʻi] that we are reliant on the military for our jobs, economy, and security, so the state has not questioned the assertions of the military in a lot of ways, including with regards to Red Hill. . . . I’m hoping that recent events have demonstrated to our legislators that the navy can’t be trusted with our water, this foundation of our lives. They have promised us time and again that they are somehow able to think of everything to protect us and this irreplaceable water source, yet they have failed time and again to do just that. Military protection at the expense of essential services is some of the more sobering irony I've seen. What's the point of having the biggest, baddest military in the world if they make your community uninhabitable in the process?
- bpodgursky 5y agoCalling Honolulu uninhabitable is kind of silly. Pearl Harbor is an enormous base. Incidents like this tell basically nothing about the base rate of military vs business vs residential environmental accidents. And it's not about "military protection" as much as "the US military pumps ridiculous amounts of money into the local area".
- thr0wawayf00 5y agoI don't think it's that silly since there's a very real risk to water supply contamination. As we saw in Flint, MI, apathy absolutely allows mass degradation of important infrastructure to the point of failure. But we accept it because it's not happening in our community.
- juanani 5y ago
- micromacrofoot 5y agoBased on its historical role as a pacific garrison, the military likely cares more about it being theirs rather than it being habitable at all.
- AniseAbyss 5y ago
- sam_goody 5y agoMeanwhile, the FSO Safer is sitting off the coast of Yemen, ready to kill everything in the Red Sea, contaminate hundreds of miles of ocean (with oil) and land (with poisonous fumes), and stop much of the world's shipping. It is already slowly leaking, but could explode any minute. People forget that these theoretical disasters can become reality.
- p0cc 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FSO_Safer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FSO_Safer This is a disaster waiting to happen. If it spilled, it would disrupt the Suez Canal and jeopardize the livelihoods of 1.7 million people who depend on fish.
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoUgh.... this is tragic. The legacy of the US's impact on Hawai'ians is already bad, and there's still resentment towards the way non-native people treat the island and its people. Of all the things to destroy, the beaches and the water.... not only are they basically sacred, they're also the lifeblood of tourism (which the military couldn't care less about, but it's pretty damn significant to the local economy)
- xbar 5y agoEvery US Navy base is a toxic waste catastrophe, even the ones that have long been closed. Systemic problems in waste management on military base land stem from defense budgets that go to fun, sexy projects and toxic waste cleanup budgets that are for civilian sites only. Expect all 20th century Navy bases to pollute indefinitely. Hawai'i particularly sad because everyone knows what a loss it is. The death of places like the San Francisco Bay ecosystems are less visible.
- mistrial9 5y ago> the San Francisco Bay ecosystems pointers?
- edoceo 5y agoTry searching about Suisun Bay and NAS Alameda. They've had some significant pollution issues.
- Spooky23 5y agoAlmost every military base and aerospace contractor. A nearby high school is going to be a superfund site soon because after WW2, some jackass decided to just dump toxic chemicals, and the underground plume is migrating faster than the remediation efforts. If you look at a map of pollution sites, it’s pretty easy to see where defense related stuff was active 1940-1980. Look around Stanford, the old Grumman facilities on Long Island and Burlington, MA.
- Spooky23 5y ago
- iqanq 5y ago
- hoppyhoppy2 5y ago"Hawaiʻi" is the correct Hawaiian spelling, FYI, and is used by, for example, hawaii.gov, hawaii.edu, and nps.gov/havo
- mistrial9 5y agofamous english language novel "Hawaii" (just checked it) is a novel by James Michener published in 1959, the year that Hawaii became the 50th U.S. state. It has been translated into 32 languages. The editors probably do know about the 'okina variation, too.
- iqanq 5y agoBut we are speaking English here. If we were talking about the Austrian city we would say Vienna, not Wien.
- SonicScrub 5y ago"Hawaii" is not just an English translation of "Hawaiʻi". The Gvoernment officially refers to the state of Hawaii as "Hawaii", and the largest island in the archipelago as "Hawaiʻi", as you can see through this National Parks document detailing the naming conventions: https://irma.nps.gov/DataStore/DownloadFile/575333#:~:text=The%20name%20of%20the%20state,same%20name%20is%20Hawai'i https://irma.nps.gov/DataStore/DownloadFile/575333#:~:text=T.... > The name of the state, Hawaii, is not written with an ‘okina between the two "i", because our Statehood Act in 1959 used the spelling "Hawaii." An Act of Congress is required to "correct" the name of the state to Hawai‘i. Thus, the name of the state is Hawaii, while the name of the island of the same name is Hawai‘i.
- iqanq 5y agoThe Government of Austria also refers to the city of Vienna as Wien but we are not going to say Wien here.
- DantesKite 5y agoWhy I always recommend reverse osmosis water filters. Failing infrastructure and systemic human error are abundant.
- resoluteteeth 5y agoNote that reverse osmosis can't remove some chemicals so it's not necessarily a replacement for the government doing its job.
- DantesKite 5y agoReally? Which chemicals can it not remove? If true, I might be better off getting a distiller then.
- drjasonharrison 5y agohttps://extensionpublications.unl.edu/assets/html/g1490/build/g1490.htm#target2 https://extensionpublications.unl.edu/assets/html/g1490/buil...
- DantesKite 5y agoThat’s interesting. I didn’t realize some solvents got through the RO filter but other filters can manage it better. > AC filters remove chlorine and certain pesticides and organic solvents that the RO membrane is not as effective in removing It seems like as long as you have a complete water filtration system, you’ll cover most bases.
- nate_meurer 5y agoThat's going to get expensive. Also not that distillation is useless for volatile organics, and can actually increase the concentration of lighter chemicals like benzene.
- 5y ago
- ZhongDongLong 5y agoOne time I emailed the Hawaii Department of Public Health and asked for latest PFAS measurements. They sent me an excel sheet (fron 2013?) with information about tested sites. With the curious omission of measured levels. It was explained as "levels are too low to be required for disclosure" Hmmmm...
- burlesona 5y agoSummary at the top: > This well, the Red Hill shaft, is one of three that provides water to residents on the Joint Base Pearl Harbor and Hickam (JBPHH) on the island of Oʻahu. For weeks, families living on the base registered complaints of a gasoline smell and taste in their water and illnesses ranging from vomiting to headaches, stomach pain, burning skin, and diarrhea. Initially, the navy dismissed residents’ concerns, but later admitted the water was unsafe for consumption and relocated more than 3,000 families to hotels. Because the navy shares an aquifer with the Board of Water Supply, officials worry that contamination in navy water wells could affect the city of Honolulu’s drinking water as well. So: the people currently affected all live on the navy base. But the concern (not yet proven) is that this spill may affect the city water supply. Certainly concerning... do we know how to clean an aquifer if it becomes contaminated like this?
- giantg2 5y agoNot that I'm aware of. I guess they'll probably end up with special filtration or a desalination plant before they could ever clean an aquifer.
- warner25 5y agoThis is essentially right. I'll add the caveat that the Navy's water system apparently reaches many houses and businesses that you wouldn't call "on the navy base." Watching that unfold was painful, like when a network goes down and the operators clearly don't know their own network. This includes housing neighborhoods for other military service members (i.e. Army, Coast Guard) who work elsewhere, run by a different property manager, and neighborhoods that were transferred back to the civilian community 10-20 years ago. As mentioned in my other comment, what's most scary is that there's still no solid theory of what happened and when. We aren't sure of the chemicals, the amounts, the timeline, or the mechanism by which the chemicals got into the water. The story keeps changing, and never really adds up. So it does seem quite possible that the whole aquifer is at risk. The city plans to avoid drawing from this portion of the aquifer for several years now.
- philips 5y agoThe leak rate of fueling stations and tanks is rather alarming. Oregon DEQ reports a 3% yearly rate which includes tanks, dispensers, and piping.[1] It seems any petroleum fueling infrastructure needs to be moved far far away from ground or surface water infrastructure. I started a site at postpump.org to encourage land use updates to do this-- many municipalities have done it already. It is a tragedy this keeps happening and the I am sure the federal government likes to play by different rules. Hopefully one day we can stop storing tens of thousands of gallons of petroleum right next to fresh water sources. [1]: https://www.postpump.org/reports/ https://www.postpump.org/reports/
- dotancohen 5y ago
- jimrandomh 5y agoI think it's well past time to make reverse-osmosis filters standard equipment for every residential kitchen sink. Water pollution is bad and we should still try to prevent it, but, given the actual rates of water pollution observed, the cost-benefit is completely overwhelming.
- azinman2 5y agoWhich also takes out minerals and fluoride which you do want. It also is a big expense, and in many parts of the world, the municipal water is tasked with doing this kind of quality assurance for you.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoMinerals in water are unnecessary. Fluoride is better obtained by brushing ones teeth.
- xahrepap 5y agoThere was an even near me a couple years ago: https://kutv.com/news/local/sandy-estimates-600-homes-affected-by-water-contamination-says-to-flush-water-systems https://kutv.com/news/local/sandy-estimates-600-homes-affect... And a follow up a year later: https://kutv.com/amp/news/local/exclusive-cause-of-sandys-water-contamination-not-what-city-leaders-originally-said https://kutv.com/amp/news/local/exclusive-cause-of-sandys-wa... This is of course cherry-picked. And having a million smaller deployments is harder than one big centralized one. But the anecdote here is that even in a well-off, large suburb like Sandy, the infrastructure that is meant to “protect” the residents actually poisoned them. It’s hard to say, IMO, that municipal run water on its own it guaranteed to be safe.
- azinman2 5y agoObviously accidents happen. But I’d bet 100x over on municipalities (at least in areas I’d want to live in) over ordinary people any day. In places like Cambridge MA, NYC and SF the water is checked multiple times a day for a wide variety of contaminants using industrial processes unavailable to consumers. Similarly, they have the techniques, resources, knowledge, and scale to do filtration not feasible for ordinary people. Just looking at the wide variety of masks out there for Covid and their usage, assuming ordinary people would be willing to pay for top RO equipment and maintain it seems like a leap too far (most would just get a Brita and call it a day). It’s also unreasonable — we pay taxes in order to solve societal problems at societal scale using specialized knowledge and standards that few can replicate. If there are cases where municipal water supplies are contaminated and it’s unknown for a while, then we need to address that by either changing federal laws, changing funding sources, or otherwise fix such issues for all.
- WalterBright 5y agoIf the US Navy was a profit seeking company, this spill never would have happened.
- jonathanlb 5y agoForgot a sarcasm tag there? Or did you forget about the Exxon, BP, and Union Carbide spills?
- WalterBright 5y agoJust pointing out that whenever a profit seeking company has a disaster, or pollutes, etc., it's blamed on profit seeking. As if something magical happens without profits. Just what does one blame government disasters on?
- jonathanlb 5y ago> it's blamed on profit seeking Quite the strawman there. Both private and public disasters can be attributed to either willful negligence, incompetence, or some combination of the two. In all cases there needs to be accountability via strong oversight and enforcement mechanisms.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Quite the strawman there. Is it? I see it constantly on HackerNews posts, and it gets no pushback.
- z3ncyberpunk 5y ago
- the_only_law 5y ago> Just what does one blame government disasters on? Generally, incompetence through complacency or lack of motivation or something like that. Though I’m sure you weren’t actually looking for an answer.
- gregors 5y agoI've been following this story for over a month now. What strikes me is that the state has been asking for the tanks to be drained for while now with the Navy pushing back saying it isn't necessary. I do think they have recently stated the tanks will be drained into a nearby stream. Here's a local news station's story on it, that might shine a human picture on what's happening https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvtbPAJ2hiQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvtbPAJ2hiQ
- mistrial9 5y agowow - ten seconds in and there is a woman with cancer in bed crying.. If anyone has been close to that, it is really upsetting. I can't tell which is more extreme, a Navy that won't answer, or news drama with a closeup of a dying woman crying. Is this situation harder on the people subjected to this news, or the people whom it is trying to sway.. In my opinion, please know that what the dot-mil says in public may or may not have anything to do with their internal reasoning. The responsible parties internal discussion is shielded, and that leads to all sorts of results. There are hundreds of reasons, real or imagined, that might lead to "stalling" .. and don't forget, stalling is addictive, and accumulates!
- warner25 5y agoMy family is one of those 3,000+ immersed in this event. It was surreal seeing it on the front page of HN earlier today. We haven't touched the water in our house for about six weeks now, spending lots of time going back and forth between our house and hotels and laundromats and fast food places for daily needs, while trying to figure out what to do next. We're discarding most of our kitchen items and appliances that touched the water, and trying to move elsewhere. At first, I figured that this was no big deal. We've dealt with water quality issues before in various places, using bottled water or boiling for a couple days, or just running the water until there was no visible sediment. I realized that this was more serious when other residents started reporting symptoms consistent with things that my family had experienced over the preceding weeks and months. The symptoms were mysterious and generally low-level, the kind that you would mention to your spouse but then write-off, rather than taking a sick day to see a doctor until they persist for a month. So we know that we were exposed to something nasty that we couldn't see, taste, or smell until it reached some peak around Thanksgiving. What's most disconcerting is that we really have no idea how long we were exposed, to what chemicals, and in what amounts. I don't think we'll ever know, since rigorous sampling and testing and monitoring didn't start until after the Navy facilities folks started drawing water from a different well and flushing the pipes. Furthermore, there has been a pattern of Navy officials telling a story that everything is fine, and being evasive about the details, and then revising the story and releasing not-so-fine details later as a result of public outcry. Repeat several times. I don't even know what the working version of the official story is at this point. The Navy, Army (which also has many affected residents), and Hawaii Department of Health have issued starkly different guidance, forcing the Environmental Protection Agency to step in and mediate. I actually considered submitting something on this to HN a few weeks ago, hoping to get opinions on the situation from some disinterested experts that hang out here. How bad might this be for us? Does any version of the story make sense? The financial costs to the government will be staggering. Affected residents are getting paid for months of hotels, meals, and incidentals. We're submitting claims for damaged property items. The Navy has acquired dozens of huge filtration devices and flown them here overnight along with contractors to do remediation and consultants to inject expertise. All of this was over Christmas and the peak tourist season in Hawaii, plus COVID supply chain issues, at the highest possible prices.
- supperburg 5y agoLiterally moments before reading this I was debating about using tap water instead of running to the store for bottled water to take my pills in my hotel on the island that this article is about. I’m here on vacation. I drank the tap water with hesitation and was pleased to find that it didn’t taste weird at all. After probably about a liter of it I am feeling fine. I am available to do more experiments if anyone wants.