9 ms·
Arxiv.org reaches a milestone and a reckoning
- adamnemecek 5y agoI legit don’t get how come there isn’t some government funded publication platform. No other endeavor has as much bang for buck. Arxiv needs $2.5m a year https://arxiv.org/about/reports-financials https://arxiv.org/about/reports-financials which is chump change.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 5y agoI also don't understand how there can so much money to throw at startups and not one person to "adpot-a-highway" for a year.
- zarzavat 5y agoMuch of the money for startups comes ultimately from pension funds. They have a fiduciary duty to make sure the money is invested in something that is expected to make a return.
- ahelwer 5y agoBecause you cannot rely on the rich to fund common goods through voluntary donations. It is not a good idea and never will be. Other than some medical research, charity has never solved a single social ill.
- leephillips 5y agoHas any social ill been eliminated by any other means?
- mananaysiempre 5y agoThe introductory econ course I once took mentioned the (apparently classic) lighthouse study[1], though now that I did a web search it doesn’t seem that unequivocal. Many 19th century projects were funded through public participation (the Eiffel Tower and the Statue of Liberty come to mind), even if the social value of some of them was questionable (though I think some railroads were built this way too?). Before that, I seem to remember that the Netherlands was made habitable (from essentially a coastal swamp) largely through private enterprise. In more recent times, the late engineer turned entrepreneur Dmitrij Zimin funded a significant portion of the Russian hard sciences in the 2000s and 2010s (after Soros grants got some of the people through the Soviet collapse in the 1990s and then ceased), though the problem is still far from solved. It is peculiar that the model of fundraising via newspaper ads and a couple of wealthy donors (including in some cases the national government, yes) doesn’t seem to have survived past the world wars, but to say that private funding never resulted in any social good is preposterous. Something has happened in the last century or so, but it’s trickier than that. [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/724895 https://www.jstor.org/stable/724895
- consp 5y ago> largely through private enterprise Calling a hoogheemraadschap a private enterprise is calling a government one. If it acts like a government it is one even if it is not benefitting everyone equally (still no difference though).
- eecc 5y agoIsn’t it essentially a Corporation in its original definition where they were established for a given purpose (not just “maximize shareholder value” but rather something like “build and maintain some infrastructure” or whatnot)
- telxosser 5y agoYou can just visit Pittsburgh to see how preposterous this is. The city is practically unimaginable culturally without Andrew Carnegie's wealth.
- WHA8m 5y agoDiscard the last sentence. You're talking in absolute terms and that's leading nowhere. It's been some time, but this is what came to my mind immediately: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuggerei https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuggerei That you can not rely on the rich to put their money in good use with the general public in mind is right. Does it happen? Yes. Does it happen often? Definitely not.
- astrange 5y agoThe anti-charity people get around their absolutism by inventing "mutual aid", which is what they call charity when they like it. (similar thing in education involved deciding "equality" was bad, so they invented "equity", which is the same thing except they like it.)
- demygale 5y agoMutual aid is decentralized charity, the aid comes from the community instead of a NGO.
- astrange 5y agoI don't think normal people define "charity" only to mean "charity that doesn't work" though. Giving to a local food bank is charity to most people. And, like, GiveWell/GiveDirectly are NGOs that are actually effective.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thrwn_frthr_awy 5y agoRight! And that’s really my point–there are so many people in tech with money and an ego that I’m surprised this isn’t done more. Pineapple person in the most recent memorable example.
- WHA8m 5y agoYes, I think we're on the same page here. Your main point was, that you can not rely on the rich to use their money to benefit others and I totally agree.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thrwn_frthr_awy 5y agoA lot very confident statements there. > Other than some medical research, charity has never solved a single social ill. This is very broad and incorrect statement that I suggest you research more before stating as fact. Maybe start with libraries in the 19th and 20th century if you don’t know where to start.
- manquer 5y agoArxiv is a indirect threat to publications. Publications lobby the government and also influence university grants and other bodies. We still don't have a proper open /free tax filing too from the IRS or tax computed by IRS only for us to verify/confirm as in some of other countries, primarily because intuit (and others) lobbied to make sure the government would never develop one (encoded in law no less), so it is not that surprising that a community benefiting project that threatens some big business revenues has no government funding available.
- onion2k 5y agoArxiv is a indirect threat to publications. It's incredibly annoying that publications try to continue to exist in order to act as a gatekeeper to exclusive papers. If journals added real value by peer-reviewing, collating, curating, offering editorial opinion etc then the fact papers are also available in the raw state somewhere else wouldn't much of a threat.
- manquer 5y agoYou don't need publications of course, both are competing to own a social network and derive their strength from users that is the threat. An online ecosystem like Arxiv can very easily supersede a journal if they want to. For example Arxiv say could deploy a public peer review process i.e. reviews, criticisms and comments on the paper could be available next to paper in Arxiv without a lot of effort technically. Similarly curation and collation could easily taken up for free by community. Any of this would upend journals in quality or throughput easily. There are no problems journals solve that online cannot do better not even exclusivity they charge so much for. After all there are enough people to moderate reddit or do various quality control tasks in StackOverflow for not much benefit, researchers who curate on Arxiv could easily be found and they may even get a job boost. Building that community and acceptance is the hard part everything else is relatively trival. -- Open Access especially for government funded research should be mandatory. Same for software, any thing government invests to develop should be open source.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoIf you mean some government should fund arXiv, specifically, then I don't disagree but would guess the government's default position of "it exists without public money, and we think that's rather excellent". If you're suggesting it as alternative for academic publishing in general, it would cost a lot more. Arxiv isn't a "publication platform" in the sense that peer-reviewed journals are. The cost of hosting and distributing PDFs is close to zero, obviously. What does cost money is the copyediting and running the peer review process. People think Elsevier are the worst people in the world (not entirely wrong) and taking in millions while exploiting the free labor of authors and reviewers. But it's relatively easy to quantify the value they do add: their financials are public and, last I checked, they have operating margins of about 30 %. Let's say we could do without their marketing and billing departments and that gets us to a margin of 50 %. That's pretty good, but it isn't quite the rip-off people sometimes suggest it is. Replacing the commercial publishers with government-funded open-access journals would be a billion-dollar endeavor, not a few million for servers and a bit of software.
- eru 5y agoPerhaps it's best for governments not to get involved in arxiv. They are heavily involved in most other aspects of academia, and the results haven't been universally pretty.
- erwincoumans 5y agoInterestingly, the peers doing the hard work (of actual reviewing) for free. Running the reviewing process can also happen through https://openreview.net https://openreview.net Not sure why we need Elsevier exactly, could you be more specific?
- tsbischof 5y agoPart of the challenge is the reputation issue. Academics want to publish where there is prestige, which means there has to be a perception of the venue as good. This typically either comes from reasonable gatekeeping and high-quality peers (e.g. arXiv) or pushing metrics (e.g. Nature Publishing Group journals). Generating an attractive journal is non-trivial and few people with the appropriate knowledge and expertise take the plunge would do so without some guarantee of profit.
- Vinnl 5y ago> Academics want to publish where there is prestige Important to note that this is not some innate "want"; their careers depend on it. It's a means to an ends, the ends being being able to keep practicing science. (Of course prestige-by-proxy will play a role as well, but it's not what's keeping the system in place.)
- mananaysiempre 5y agoFunding for government-funded archival projects tends to begin with a bang but gradually fall through the cracks due to the project becoming politically unexciting, frequently with all data just completely lost one day with no warning, so I’d be disinclined to trust any such initiative. The French government made an attempt with HAL[1], but given how INRIA just unceremoniously deleted the software repository Gforge with no backups or redirects (and broke every GCC build out there, because the GCC dependency ISL was hosted on it[2]), I’m not sure it’ll survive once the nationalistic fervor is exhausted. Besides, a country-specific repository seems to be strictly worse than a country-neutral one. On the other hand, PubMed exists. My guess is, for a preprint archive, network effects are paramount, and ArXiv was there first. It’s not directly a government project, but is still funded by US government grants and hosted by Stanford (now that the international mirror network is shut down, which does give me a slightly jittery feeling). [1] https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/ https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/ [2] https://groups.google.com/g/isl-development/c/JGaMo2VUu_8 https://groups.google.com/g/isl-development/c/JGaMo2VUu_8
- goodcanadian 5y agoThe Canadian Astronomy Data Centre is a good counter example of a successful government funded archival project: https://www.cadc-ccda.hia-iha.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/en/ https://www.cadc-ccda.hia-iha.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/en/ It probably helps that it is run under the auspices of the Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics.
- lN5uhiNxWPBi 5y agoThere is, right? In many cases around the world. Here in the UK, there is a big research evaluation exercise called the REF. The REF is important because it largely determines how the government allocates funds. In order to be eligible to be evaluated, researchers have to essentially submit their pre-prints into open access. What this has meant for the last 10+ years is that most universities participating in the REF have an e-prints server, like the arxiv. Obviously, being publically funded, universities are then using government money to pay for these costs. Now your question might be whether it's sensible for the entire country (or research councils) to operate their own e-prints server. I don't know the answer to this. All I know is that the more bureaucracy you involve, the more bullshit results.
- henrydark 5y agoThe two sites I start my day with: hacker news and arxiv.
- gmadsen 5y agosame
- onion2k 5y agoWhy have you never submitted an article you've found on Arxiv to HN? Are you not finding anything interesting there? (Based on https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=henrydark https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=henrydark ... I guess you could use a different account?)
- hasjekyll 5y agoI do a similar thing, but the papers I'm interested in are usually a bit too niche for a general audience. That's one of the things I don't like about academic papers, particularly in my field (astro), we don't tailor our abstracts and introductions to a wider audience.
- buro9 5y agoDo you read the /new submissions for particular topics? HN is a nice tidy list of top things, is there an equivalent for ArXiv?
- hasjekyll 5y agoYou can use things like arxivsorter and benty-fields for this. You give them a list of papers you've published, or authors you are interested in and then get recommendations. The recommendations can be up and down voted to improve future recommendations.
- gsvclass 5y agohttps://42papers.com https://42papers.com
- 5y ago
- HerrMonnezza 5y agoFrom the article: > But moderators frequently intervene, delaying posting by days or weeks, reclassifying papers or even outright rejecting submissions. Definitely not my experience. I haven't posted to arXiv in a while now, but I wasn't even aware a moderation queue exists -- none of my papers were delayed, reclassified, or other... EDIT: I see the article provides a few examples, but then they also provide numbers: "At arXiv, roughly 6 percent of submissions receive a hold, and about 2 percent are rejected." -- 8% of heavy-handed moderation intervention wouldn't qualify as "frequently" IMHO.
- hasjekyll 5y agoI guess it just stops arxiv from turning into vixra.org
- domenicrosati 5y agoJust anecdotally, Ive had a paper rejected once from arxiv. I am glad they did... it was not a very good one. Every other time thought has been fine
- prof-dr-ir 5y agoThe arxiv is a treasure, and such preprint servers not only streamline the academic debate but are also a necessary first step towards a future without for-profit academic publishers. The arxiv moderators are like human spam filters. And as anyone who dealt with email should know, spam filters are essential for a platform to remain useful. I think the article puts undue emphasis on the few edge cases that invariably arise with any such filtering system. And being a moderator is a thankless job indeed. The efforts of a moderator are largely focused on the absolute worst papers, and the job is therefore very different from being a referee or editor of a reasonable academic journal. So personally I would also focus elsewhere any efforts at increasing diversity in academic institutions.
- _def 5y agoI'm in no way involved in academic research, and I don't now how it works in detail, but a question that popped into my head these days was: is there a place where people can publish papers even without any association with anything? Like, if I manage to do proper research, even without any qualifications on paper, would it still be useful? Does this make any sense?
- elcomet 5y agoYou can submit your work to any conference that is double-blind and get accepted if your paper is good. You don't need to be affiliated to a university.
- tsbischof 5y agoIn principle, submission is viable at many venues. PNAS has a few mechanisms for having established authors endorse your submission, for example. The main challenge is going to be the appearance of credibility to get past the starting point, since many non-affiliated submissions tend to be unpublishable without serious rework, at least in lab-based disciplines.
- SiempreViernes 5y agoGood research is always useful, where good means something between "reliable and flawlessly explained" and "plausible and very novel". So on one end you could takes something like Newtons Principa, that synthesised a lot of the known facts and laws at the time into one single coherent framework, and on the other you can have Galileo recognising that he was seeing surface features on the moon and not just patterns on a flat disk and announcing this will some illustrations showing the principle and not what he actually saw. As to the first part of the question, if you talk of "publishing" in academia you usually mean you want your work to be know by other credible researchers in the hope they find it useful. The most reliable way to achieve that without credentials is to befriend someone respected in the field you are interested in before you send them your results, because they are more likely to have patience with any errors or confusion in your presentation that way. There are of course some places that pride themselves on being completely free from filtering, but the concept of "spam folder" along should tell you how good a chance you have of getting any serious attention in those places.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoWhat you lose on arxiv is peer review. That might sound like a feature- you get to let others know of your results faster- but if you make a mistake it will not be caught until it's out in the wild (and possibly until everyone has already cited it and based their own work on it). With peer-review you know that someone will read your work that has the background to understand it and to catch errors. So what, you'll say, independent experts can catch your mistake if they read the paper on arxiv and contact you to suggest a correction. Yes, but there's no incentive to do the hard work to correct mistakes if your paper is already on arxiv and people are already citing it (who didn't do their due dilligence). Then errors start cascading. Science is self-correcting, sure, but it's much easier to avoid errors in the first place. That's an important function of modern peer review. I'm speaking from experience, of course. Peer review has certainly helped improve my work. I didn't enjoy having to redo the work, but the end result was something I could be confident about. Also, I'm only speaking about publishing in journals, because peer review in conferences is a very different beast. In my field, of machine learning and artificial intelligence research, I'd go as far as to say that peer review in conferences is broken, getting published or not is a lottery and you're better off putting your stuff on arxiv: less hassle and more people will read it. You might even see your article posted on HN. When was the last time a paper published on a conference server was posted on HN? See?
- EGreg 5y agoWell, this is exactly why we should have more WikiNews and less Twitter. I explore these issues in far more depth here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gv5mI6ClPGc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gv5mI6ClPGc (Discussion w Noam Chomsky)
- IshKebab 5y ago> With peer-review you know that someone will read your work that has the background to understand it and to catch errors. That's overly optimistic. What you mean is "with peer-review you know that someone will at least skim your work and maybe catch errors." I agree with the rest of your points though. Zero peer review is probably not a great solution.
- 5y ago
- throwaway81523 5y agoI wonder if anyone remembers Advogato and its certification/reputation system. It claimed to be very difficult to subvert. I'm sure that was naive and it held up because nobody back then was that motivated to game it, but even today, a little human oversight could probably steady it. So I wonder if something like it could be used for arxiv, relieving some of the endorser/moderation stuff that they have now.
- raphlinus 5y agoYes, I bet you could do something interesting there, but one of the lessons is that social graphs can become very noisy, especially if people have an incentive to add edges. Don't expect a purely technical (reputation) system to solve what is a social/cultural problem.
- politician 5y agoTLDR: 6% of submissions receive a hold, 2% are rejected. The problem, the article says, is that only 13% of the moderators are women and there is not enough diversity of nationality. My opinion here, but it sounds like instead of a 92% immediate acceptance rate, the author would prefer an immediate acceptance rate closer to 100%. I’m not sure why diversity would get them there, but I am encouraged that the current moderators are able to produce 92% immediate acceptance rate. On the other hand, I am distraught by the suggestion that a highly diverse moderator base would presumably only account for a few percent reduction in holds and rejections. It’s my understanding that that should have a far more significant impact.