5 ms·
UK schools receive 300k CO2 monitors in gov initiative to reduce COVID19 spread
- OJFord 5y agoFull (sub)title that wouldn't fit, and had `>` stripped: > UK schools have received more than 300,000 CO2 monitors as part of a government initiative to reduce COVID-19 spread in classrooms Actual title that I skipped because I thought the subtitle was more informative: > Curbing COVID-19 in schools: Imperial scientists support CO2 monitor rollout Happy to edit (while I can) if people disagree..
- AlbertoGP 5y agoThis might be one of the good things to come out of the pandemic if it stays as it would improve the kids’ attention and mental performance. The article mentions that in passing: “As well as being a good ‘proxy’ for ventilation, lower CO2 levels have been linked to improved learning outcomes and better cogitative performance.” I’d rather have fixed sensors so that they would stay, but these are portable and I imagine most will be left in a drawer after the pandemic goes away: «The portability of the CO2 monitors, supplied by the Department for Education (DfE), means schools can move them around to test different areas, starting with those they suspect may be poorly ventilated.» At least the air cleaners might stay («distributing between 7,000 and 8,000 air cleaning units.») and I hope the CO₂ monitors will keep being used once people see the difference.
- pasabagi 5y ago7 or 8 thousand air cleaning units is a bit pointless, though, given that there are over 32,000 schools. Presumably, 300,000 CO2 monitors is in the right range for one per classroom? Is ten classrooms per school a reasonable average?
- jamessb 5y ago> Is ten classrooms per school a reasonable average? That sounds low: a secondary school with no sixth-form will have students in 5 different year groups, and will typically have more than two classes per year group.
- mavhc 5y agoBut most schools are primary schools https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statistics/school-pupils-and-their-characteristics https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-sta... Headcount 8,911,853 Number of schools 24,413 Average class size 26.6 So 335000 classes that's just England, which is 83% of uk, so 402000 classes total
- iso1631 5y agoThere are 8,911,853 pupils in England alone with an average class size of 26.6 That's 335,032 classes, and thus at least 335k classrooms (add extra ones for specialist classrooms) However that number includes private schools. Remove those and you're looking at 8.3 million, with a larger class size, so potentially just 277k classes assuming 30 people per room (plus specialist classrooms like IT, Art, D+T, PE, etc)
- andylynch 5y agoIt’s not clear from the press release whether this is a UK rollout or just in England- I suspect the latter - at last count there were 302 thousand classes in English schools, so this number makes sense.
- OJFord 5y agoBut maybe they were for the ones where they're use was (particularly) not pointless? I.e. those with consistent high readings, with simple measures like opening windows not helping (or for some reason not being practical). It would make more sense to me to send 7-8k of them to say London schools than 20k to country schools. Seems a bit tough to ever make them practical without central AC though, which is not common (nor any AC) in the UK.
- pasabagi 5y agoOne interview I heard called it 'gesture politics'. Sadly, I think that assessment is on the money. It's just not plausible that there are only 7k classrooms in the UK that have bad ventilation. I think it's the deep malaise of UK politics that they just hate spending money on anything, even if it will save far more money in the future. It's why the UK has the GDP-per-capita of Japan, but mostly looks like Serbia.
- rand49an 5y agoI've visited a lot of new UK schools over the last few years and fixed CO2 monitors are in almost every classroom everywhere I visit, even pre COVID. I assume it's a DfE requirement now.
- 656565656565 5y agoGreat except they are being ignored EDIT; being downvoted for sharing what is actually happening on the ground
- Resinderate 5y agoYeah partner is a teacher and have heard the same. "Hey, the monitor is too high what should we do?", "Open the door", "It is open", "Open the windows.", "They are open.", "Okay, never mind".
- 656565656565 5y agoSeveral academies at least have rooms in constant red with doors windows opened
- raverbashing 5y agoWell if the windows and doors are open they can't do much more (there's also measurement inertia, it might be getting ventilated but it will take some time to register) Lack of ventilation plays a big role on the spread
- giantg2 5y agoThey can do more. The HVAC systems should increase air exchange, to reduce recirculation, and likely need higher output (more cfm - larger ducts, more ducts, and/or higher velocity).
- JamesMcMinn 5y agoVery few schools in the UK have a HVAC system. Some of the more modern ones perhaps, but the majority of schools in the UK are likely older than the students grandparents.
- giantg2 5y ago
- Proven 5y ago
- bloopernova 5y agoSomewhat related: I'm hooking up some sensors to my raspberry pi InfluxDB instance using Python. It's end goal is a very hobbyist project: monitoring cat litter boxes and alerting before they stink. The CO2 levels in my office at home are ~400ppm at night, but head past 900ppm during the day. I'm going to add another alert to remind us to open windows! Although our townhouse is part of a back to back block, so only has windows on one side.
- Besticle 5y agoCO2 as a proxy to air ventilation is a good start BUT doesn't show the full picture of what makes up IAQ (indoor air quality). Better (but more expensive) would be monitors that could measure PM2.5 molecules in the air like that of the airborne aerosols that transmit Covid (phlegm, spittle etc).
- yourusername 5y agoIn urban areas increased ventilation might increase PM2.5 (unless it is filtered). 30 mcg/M^3 PM2.5 might mean a lot of covid particles or the house across the street just lit their wood heater.
- Besticle 5y agoYeah measuring both PM2.5 and CO2 will help in balancing the two.
- ahaucnx 5y agoYes I agree. Often there is also the dilemma if you live in a polluted area and have purifiers in the classrooms. Opening the windows will reduce CO2 but increase PM2.5. Not opening will lead to lower PM2.5 but high CO2. Here in Asia in highly polluted areas, positive pressure systems are getting more and more popular at home as well as in classrooms[1]. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/resources/positive-pressure-systems-for-clean-air/ https://www.airgradient.com/resources/positive-pressure-syst...
- parkingrift 5y agoA recent study from the University of Bristol suggests that Covid particles become 90% less infectious within as little as five minutes. I don’t know whether the UK will get much benefit from measuring PM2.5. The CO2 monitors will alert them to open windows and that’s about all that can be done. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.01.08.22268944v1.full.pdf https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.01.08.22268944v...
- Besticle 5y ago
- giantg2 5y agoGenerally a good idea, but probably not necessary for permanent installation (or allotment since they are portable), just during HVAC design and testing. Also, if the kids are wearing masks then the cognitive benefits go out the window with CO2 concentration being above 20,000ppm. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33858372/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33858372/
- netizen-936824 5y agoSomething interesting about that study: the CO2 levels are okay for short term use Students are wearing them literally all day
- ahaucnx 5y agoWith a permanent installation you can link the sensor CO2 data with the hvac system for a demand controlled ventilation. This will allow energy savings and maintain an optimum level of CO2 in the classrooms. We often see big differences in our data comparing different classroom sizes, age of students and activities inside the classroom. So often a fixed hvac setting is not the best solution.
- giantg2 5y ago"With a permanent installation you can link the sensor CO2 data with the hvac system for a demand controlled ventilation." That may be the best greenfield solution. Yet this is not a greenfield situation. These sensors are assigned to the school, but they are not permanently installed, and they cannot control the systems. Most existing systems aren't even capable of being controlled that way.
- vertnerd 5y agoAs someone who wears a kn95 mask all day I think the results of linked study should be taken with a grain of salt. The CO2 concentrations they measured with conventional masks are effectively similar to the concentrations in exhaled air, which means they may only be measuring the concentration in the stale air sitting inside the mask between each inrush of fresh air that occurs with each inhalation. In other words, I don't care what the CO2 concentration is in my mask. I care what the average concentration is in each inhaled breath, which consists of the stale air in my mask, combined with the (presumably larger volume of) fresh air that is introduced by breathing in. I doubt the study methodology properly captured that.
- ahaucnx 5y agoI recently made built instructions [1] for a WiFi enabled CO2 monitor that can be used in schools and is a great project to built together with students. It shows the current CO2 levels with a large green, yellow red LED matrix. The kit comes with a custom PCB and 3D printable enclosure and is completely open source and open hardware. It uses the Senseair S8 NDIR sensor that we made really good experience with and can be programmed with the Arduino environment. More than happy to help any school (or anybody else) who wants to build these. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/resources/ https://www.airgradient.com/resources/
- DavideNL 5y agofyi related info: https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2021/airgradient-diy-air-quality-monitor-co2-pm25 https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2021/airgradient-diy-air-q...
- Youden 5y agoI was curious about the specific equipment they were using and found a list of spec sheets on page 11 of [0]. I'm really happy they decided to use models that all have manual fresh-air calibration. A big problem with DIY projects is that most of the sensors have a built-on, on-by-default auto calibration function, which assumes it will consistently see fresh air for ~1h per day (or other period), which isn't always the case in an environment that doesn't have commercial HVAC (like a house or small school). When the assumption is broken, the calibration is too and the data are close to useless as absolute measurements (they still have some small value as relative measurements). The assumption that a fresh air baseline will always be seen is particularly easy to break right now. It's winter, so you're less likely to open the windows and due to COVID, you may be working from home, leaving very little time for CO2 to disperse. [0]: https://www.coschools.org.uk/resources/RP24.4%20How%20to%20Use%20CO%E2%82%82%20monitors%20in%20education%20and%20childcare%20settings.pdf https://www.coschools.org.uk/resources/RP24.4%20How%20to%20U...
- ahaucnx 5y agoYes. It is important to use CO2 sensors that do not have a short automatic baseline calibration like the MH-Z19 that is popular in DIY projects but calibrates every 24h. Better use a sensor like the Senseair S8 that only calibrates every 8 days and you most likely have a weekend of low occupancy that should bring CO2 down to ambient levels.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoI haven't been able to open a window for about a month due to extreme air pollution outside, and I think my Senseair S8 is broken now. If it sees fresh air with normal CO₂ levels it goes from "normal" 1.5-2k PPM (which are really closer to 4k) to zero and then shoots up to ~65000 PPM, and stays there. It spent the last two weeks in a room with an open window and still shows 65k PPM. Does anyone know of any way to recalibrate it, except for the obvious solution of putting it in a closed box and slowly lowering the amount of CO₂ there?
- janekm 5y ago
- toyg 5y agoI wonder which schools are getting them. In some areas they're probably counterproductive, in the sense that the air outside might be less safe than the one in the classroom (without HVAC systems, this will probably be the case in pretty much all major English cities, which is why the government was forced by the courts to do something and mandated the implementation of Clean Air Zones).
- noneeeed 5y agoThe current top comment indicates that the model being used is calibratable (presumably by placing outside to work out the background rates). Of course this assumes that they will be properly calibrated by school staff.
- nmeofthestate 5y agoThe article claims the Department of Education is distributing monitors to UK schools, but the DofE doesn't operate across the UK, so perhaps the story is actually about schools in England.
- egeek 5y agoThe story seems to be about England, but the monitors are being rolled out to other areas as well by the other departments. For example, Northern Ireland [0], and Scotland [1],[2]. It's anecdotal, but the monitors have started to arrive in my kids schools here in Northern Ireland. [0] - BBC News - https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-58790302 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-58790302 [1] - Scottish Parliament Report - https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/committees/current-and-previous-committees/session-6-education-children-and-young-people-committee/correspondence/2021/learning-estate-co2-monitoring https://www.parliament.scot/chamber-and-committees/committee... [2] - Scottish COVID guidance for schools - https://education.gov.scot/media/ttkbrnde/reducing-risks-in-schools-guidance-version-7-2-05-01-21.pdf https://education.gov.scot/media/ttkbrnde/reducing-risks-in-... (edited to break up the links)
- yalogin 5y agoI haven’t been keeping up with the dynamics of covid spread, I thought covid is mostly spread by close proximity and over water particles. How much of the covid spread is attributed to transmission through air? I am curious because covid also needs enough density of viruses(forgot the term for this) to infect, wonder what happens to the density of the viruses as they go through the hvac system.
- 70rd 5y agohttps://www.wired.com/story/the-teeny-tiny-scientific-screwup-that-helped-covid-kill/ https://www.wired.com/story/the-teeny-tiny-scientific-screwu... ^Great and accessible write up on the misconceptions of aerosol transmission and droplets.
- jordanrobinson 5y agoWorth bearing in mind that regardless of the rest of your comment, that probably less than 1% of schools in the UK have a hvac system.
- chrisco255 5y agoThis is excessive cautionary crap. It won't do anything to reduce the spread. It just makes people excessively fearful of a virus they are going to contract no matter what they do. Instead of telling kids to be strong and enjoy life, they're robbing these children of their precious childhood. Fear and toxic paranoia is the worst thing you can spread.
- Daishiman 5y agoNo, this has been supported by scientists since way before this pandemic as an easy proxy for air circulation, which has been known for over a century to reduce transmission of respiratory diseases. If anything it's a wonder that it took so long.
- an9n 5y agoTreat anything out of Imperial with extreme caution - they are one of the most loathsome core participants of the Great Reset/Coronavirus conspiracy, employing deeply discredited quack 'Professor' Neil Ferguson and his truly laughable 'modelling' (Never Once Right™).
- Rickthedick 5y agoWouldnt a portable CO2 Detector and frequent inspections be more performance and cost effective?