13 ms·
You people are just vectors of disease to me
- prohobo 5y agoI thought tenure was supposed to protect you from getting fired over bs? This intro was engaging and informative, which is exactly what professors should be doing during lectures. For me the obvious take-away here is: post-secondary education is a dying institution, and is losing relevance precisely because they don't allow professors and students to have real opinions or discussions. There should be no controversy here. Eccentric professor is eccentric - how awful!
- cardanome 5y agoAs a German, I am super shocked that this a even a controversy. Here a tenured prof can do basically whatever the hell they want (as long it is not criminal like holocaust denial obviously). Science does need a certain degree freedom to flourish and a bit of eccentricity can help make the classes more lively. A prof can not swear in front of his adult students? He is forced to teach in person during a deadly pandemic and people are even angry for him complaining about it? Insanity.
- psyc 5y agoAs an American, I wouldn't have been able to predict that anything in that video would elicit a complaint, let alone be deemed suspension-worthy. Perhaps I'm out of touch with ... something I'd rather not be in touch with.
- UncleMeat 5y agoNo. Tenure is supposed to protect you from getting fired for controversial but sound research or methods. Tenured faculty can and should get fired for acting like assholes. If a professor took a shit on their desk at the beginning of each class period and then left, assigning students all 0s for grades then they'd be rightly fired regardless of tenure. Students are paying thousands of dollars per course and tenure should not prevent them from receiving an education. The question here is whether this is eccentricity for the sake of learning or eccentricity that inhibits learning.
- ianai 5y agoThe only eyebrow raising thing is the suggestion he already assigned random course grades. Absolutely the rest of it doesn’t offend me one bit. I hope the admin lets him teach remote though if he’d like. Edit-but then I went to a college where this wouldn’t have batted any eyes. Graduating with even a C average would be respectable. Any other college in the surrounding area would consider that an A average student. And in his heyday one of my math professors would hand out truck driver applications to his calculus students with their graded tests because math and engineering definitely aren’t their fields.
- sAbakumoff 5y agoThis professor is not wrong. With Omicron the majority of people are walking biohazards and you better stay away from anyone who wasn't tested negative a couple of hours ago.
- pawsforthought 5y agoLet’s put this in perspective, walking biohazards for the professor, sure, and I wholeheartedly support his tirade. The students to each other, not so much, but he’s right that they shouldn’t go to his class.
- alexvoda 5y agoWhy do they not allow him to teach remotely? Have all the students in the classroom and have him appear on a projector screen and interact with the class that way. This would solve the Covid exposure risk for him. It would solve the various other issues the students suffer due to lockdown. It only requires someone to setup the equipment.
- t-writescode 5y agoIt'd probably just be a TA turning on a video if the college is, at all, set up for modern learning. It's actually a really good solution and I'm surprised they haven't done it - ... Banning it kinda sounds like a college being a bad college for the professors. (You can be prestigious and also bad, in fact, it seems like the industries people desperately want to work tend to have the worst work cultures, so it wouldn't surprise me, e.g. zoos (basically zero pay) or the game industry)
- necovek 5y agoThat would completely defeat the purpose of helmet during classes!
- coldtea 5y agoOn the other hand, this is life. You can die from 100 other ways, and in his age, he could die any moment anyway. At some point you soldier up and don't fuss like a baby over any danger.
- waffle_maniac 5y agoIs the risk 1 out 100 for vaccinated?
- Gibbon1 5y agoSaw a table that showed vaxxed and boosted 80 year olds have a lower death rate from covid than unvaxxed 25 year olds. Other hand I think about 1 in 50 people over 75 have died from covid in the US.
- coldtea 5y ago>Saw a table that showed vaxxed and boosted 80 year olds have a lower death rate from covid than unvaxxed 25 year olds. Sounds totally unsupported from all I've read. Have a source?
- microtherion 5y agoAlberta is publishing some very detailed tables which suggest that the death rates may be comparable, though they don't directly support the above claim: https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm#vaccine-outcomes https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm... (i.e. boosted 70-79 is lower than unvaxxed 12-29, though death rates rise steeply in 80+).
- ya_throw 5y agoCould you share that table? Here's that data for the UK (in section 4): https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsdeathsandmarriages/deaths/bulletins/deathsinvolvingcovid19byvaccinationstatusengland/deathsoccurringbetween1januaryand31october2021 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/birthsde... Maybe the unvaxxed 25 year olds where you live are spectacularly unhealthy.
- torstenvl 5y agoThe table in question is here: https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm#vaccine-outcomes https://www.alberta.ca/stats/covid-19-alberta-statistics.htm... It doesn't seem to hold for deaths, but 80+yos with a booster have lower hospitalization and ICU rates than 12-29yos with no vaccination. Tables 6 and 8.
- ralferoo 5y agoWatching the actual video puts a lot of it into context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrOzY86YcEM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrOzY86YcEM It's hard to know how serious all this is, because he keeps switching between outrageous comments and then a serious voice explaining the point he's making, and why the students should think about the issue. It might well get him fired before the end of his final year, but I suspect this will end up being a video that gets referred to a lot over the years as a great way of challenging students' viewpoints.
- fileeditview 5y agoI am still not sure if his performance is serious or satirical.
- simonh 5y agoYou're not sure if he seriously just arrived from Rigel 7?
- beebmam 5y agoThis is delightful. Thank you so much for the link. I especially loved the part about plagiarism. Incredible
- yskchu 5y agoSo many outrageous things in that video... Tenure or not, is he seriously going give his students random final grades even before the first day of class (as he put it, "predestination")? Surely the school won't allow him to do this
- ricardobeat 5y agoThe "don't come to class" part doesn't appear to be satire, yet the whole class showed up. Goes to prove his point on 50 selfish… kids who don’t give a sh* whether grandpa lives or dies.
- Hnrobert42 5y agoI don’t know that it does prove his point. Just because he asserted that if/then, doesn’t make it true.
- t-writescode 5y agoIf you were told by your professor: * everything you need to succeed in this class is in the syllabus * I'm required to be here, you're not * If you wouldn't want to get your grandfather sick, I'm as old as your grandfather, treat me like him * I'm wearing this ridiculous mask to protect me from you * I will not be answering any questions in class * I will not be tracking your attendance, while other professors might What do you think he was saying? And how would you interpret people still choosing to physically show up to his class?
- tokai 5y ago>What do you think he was saying? I rather get paid without having to work and taking any risk of illness, than doing my job and providing the students with the teaching they have paid for?
- daenney 5y agoThe man is retiring at 75. He's done his job plenty. Him not wanting to risk his life when there are alternatives available through which he can still teach seems plenty reasonable.
- tokai 5y agoHe can go for early retirement, a year of unpaid vacation, or sick leave (for his anxiety that makes it impossible to work clearly). He has a work dispute and he is taking it out on his students, instead of solving that dispute or walking away.
- podgaj 5y ago
- t-writescode 5y agoI hope you saw the part where he was retiring at the end of this year? I don't know if you remember, since time has stopped, but before Omicron, it felt like we had defeated covid. Vaccinated people basically weren't getting sick from it anymore, everything was good - and then everyone got sick. He probably thought it was safe and over. Evidence: we're hearing about his rage now, implying there wasn't that rage during the Fall semester. You're welcome to hate on him all you like, though, it's a free country.
- podgaj 5y ago[flagged]
- SkipperCat 5y agoThe only difference is that the Nazis call Jews "disease vectors" based on their religion, not their action. And that is prima facia racism. He's referring to people's actions, not their ethnicity, religion, gender etc. There's a lot of people now claiming to be suffering Nazi-esque oppression because they have to show proof of vaccination at places like bars, sporting events and other mass gatherings. They have a choice to go or not go to a bar. They have a choice to get vaccinated or not. Jews in the 1940 did not have that choice and that is the crux of the difference. Plus, comparing denial of dinning service against death camp is super cringe. Please don't take this as a slam against what you wrote, I agree with what you're saying. I'm just sick of people protesting vaccine card mandates and wearing Jewish stars on their jacket.
- podgaj 5y agoI think dehumanizing people is harmful regardless of the reason. And I agree, the holocaust equivalencies are just as harmful.
- 5y ago
- Mizza 5y agoThis guy rocks. I thoroughly look forward to aging into an cantankerous old coot who doesn't give a shit about anything and can't keep his mouth shut about the insanity all around.
- bobsmooth 5y agoI feel so bad for college aged kids right now.
- edmcnulty101 5y agoWhy aren't college professors allowed to work remotely!? Unless he's running a chem lab that's insane to me.
- yosito 5y agoSomeone needs to have some harsh words with the administrators who aren't allowing this guy to work remotely.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mrfusion 5y agoI can't put this into words, much like the author of the account of Jesus healing the Leper. But I think he was onto something deeper than what a literal interpretation might suggest. There is something worth non 0 value of living in a society who accepts you despite being sick or 'dirty', and is willing to take the risk of having those who are tainted amongst them. I feel that's an attitude that comes from a place of strength not weakness. But being scared of the air is certainly not something Jesus would have been.
- alexvoda 5y agoWhy would you be scared of anything when you are God? Fear of disease is a normal biological response present in many other animals. The fact that we manage to overcome this fear through social conditioning is laudable because in several cases, the fear is worse than the disease. But in this age, that should not be the approach we take, because we have a far better alternative available. We have a growing arsenal of tools to make use of the best approach: genocide against the diseases. We did it against small pox. We can do it again.
- gadflyinyoureye 5y agoThe covid pandemic proved two things about our policy management, under both administrations in the US. First, regardless of what tools are in our arsenal, we the people, will only be allowed to use whatever tool those in power allow. Trump bashed vaccines. He pushed monoclonal antibodies. Biden won't allow the use of traditional vaccinations such as Covaxin. “We have enough vaccines, the best vaccines available, in the United States,” Fauci, the chief medical advisor to President Joe Biden, said in response to a question about Covaxin during his Thursday interview with Adrienne Bankert on NewsNation’s “Morning in America.” https://www.newsnationnow.com/health/coronavirus/vaccine/covaxin-india-covid-vaccine/ https://www.newsnationnow.com/health/coronavirus/vaccine/cov.... Many of those who refuse to be vaccinated do so because they don't trust the vaccine tech. Even if they are wrong in that mRNA is safe (the point of this post is not to debate that; please don't get caught up on that detail), we have a perfectly good weapon in Covixan, but we're not allowed to use it because the orthodox leading society won't allow us. This causes those in the unclean camp to take an already defense posture to new levels. Second, the general public is anti-science and pick their side no matter what. For example, we can't wipe out Covid like we did Polio or Smallpox for the simple scientific reason that Covid has animal reserves in which it may escape and mutate. Further we can't have adult conversations around policy. Under Trump any one discussing anything other that an absolutely open economy was vilified. Under Biden anyone saying that the evidence does not support individuals under 40, especially males, getting the double shot or boosted, is immediately going to be downvoted on whatever social media on which they comment. The fact that a male under 40 is 4x more likely to suffer heart damage from the shot than the disease, the fact that the same individual has little chance of hospitalization or death from the disease, the fact that those with mRNA vaccines still spread Delta at meaningful rate, the fact that Omicron rips through both populations are to be ignored because nuance is too much. It is too hard. The current orthodox view, regardless of the bent, of a particular social media rules the day. All others, the heterodox, are nothing more than a vector of disease, either of the mind as the right says or the body as the left says. As to the issue raised below about needing citation of heart damage, I suggest those that actually care, please watch videos from Vinay Prasad MD MPH, https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUibd0E2kdF9N9e-EmIbUew https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCUibd0E2kdF9N9e-EmIbUew. He is not an anti-vaxer. To the claim about heart damage, see his analysis here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NR_ZVzrTeYk&t=601s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NR_ZVzrTeYk&t=601s. As to our ability to eradicate Covid, I don't think the science actually supports the view. https://www.quantamagazine.org/will-we-ever-eradicate-covid-19-20211130/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/will-we-ever-eradicate-covid-.... If we hold to the idea that we can eradicate it and that the only thing preventing us from doing so is the anti-vaxxers, we're going to get into a religious war where both side devalue the lives of their enemies. This is how rhetorical vitriol turns into physical violence. I hope we can steer clear of that. In general, the orthodox overestimate the chances of hospitalization relative to reality, https://news.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/354938/adults-estimates-covid-hospitalization-risk.aspx https://news.gallup.com/opinion/gallup/354938/adults-estimat.... Since they are leading the policy charge, their warped view is making it all but impossible to discuss things rationally.
- znpy 5y agoCan you really blame him? He's 74 and retiring at the end of this year, he lives in a state that does not mandate wearing a mask (nor a vaccination) and he's forced (along with the students) to go back to in-person teaching despite covid still circulating and the latest, more contagious covid variant emerging. Now he's quite colorful in his choosing of words, but then again, so are many showpeople that a lot of people like and follow (think of John Oliver for example) and I don't see that much of a difference. NGL, I'd choose different words but I fundamentally agree with his underlying point: keep social distancing.
- mikewarot 5y agoIn real life, the response was predictable - “I was shocked and appalled by this video. It is profane, offensive and disturbing and in no way reflects our university or its values,” President David Eisler said Thursday.[1] In a better, more adult, timeline, as suggested by one of the replies on Metafilter[2], the response would have continued "He went on to explain that the University reserves the right to kill off as many of its old professors as it deems expedient and requires them all to meet their deaths quietly and without fuss. "It's difficult enough to keep being paid more than any of these people without needing to meet their accusing eyes in the staffroom as well", Eisler said." If the latter had happened, I'd be quite interested to see what remote courses I could attend at such a fine institution. Alas, we're on the worst timeline. 1 - https://apnews.com/article/education-michigan-big-rapids-d1840defbfb96b4e6910dd52a2eef19b https://apnews.com/article/education-michigan-big-rapids-d18... 2 - https://www.metafilter.com/194004/You-people-are-just-vectors-of-disease-to-me#8195513 https://www.metafilter.com/194004/You-people-are-just-vector...
- xtiansimon 5y agoAh, Mr. Smith I presume?
- d--b 5y agoDon't watch it, it's a waste of time. The video is neither particularly funny nor infuriating nor interesting whatsoever. It's mostly an 75 year old dude who's pissed off about having to give a class during covid, which is understandable. He swears a lot. End of story
- oxymoran 5y agoThese kids are paying tens/hundreds of thousands of dollars for an education. If the job is too dangerous for grandpa, perhaps he should retire now so that these kids can actually learn AND he can be safe. Instead of, ya know, bilking an extra year of salary.
- ianai 5y agoHe really shouldn’t be fired. But I would council him to consider retirement to live his life. YOLO and all that.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoHe said he was retiring after this year. It was in the article.
- teliskr 5y agoWhile I think he is quite funny, I would be pissed if I had to pay money to take his class.
- hkchad 5y agoThis guy is the type of teacher we need more of. Great sense of humor, connecting with students and presenting material in a fun/easy to understand way. Bravo!