5 ms·
No Way to Be Human: We now occupy a nearly natureless world
- nudpiedo 5y agoEven if I do not agree completely with the article I think it should be worth pointing that human beings are specially strong in self-domesticating themselves. For example at shoes, clothing, drinking milk, society, culture, language, agriculture, use of fire etc Our own artificial environment gave shape to ourselves. And most likely that’s unstoppable.
- amelius 5y ago> The first house with a roof appeared only 5,000 years ago. Is that true?
- kwhitefoot 5y agoSeems unlikely. There were ziggurats in Mesopotamia earlier than that. Hard to imagine people with that much power not having a roof over their heads. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ziggurat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ziggurat
- vidanay 5y agoAdditionally, the pyramids at Giza are ~4600 years old and there is evidence of hundreds of houses in the vicinity. It seems dubious that they went from "no roofs" to the great pyramids in only ~400 years.
- cabalamat 5y agoIt's nonsense. Çatalhöyük had houses 9500 years ago (and there are other settlements of similar age or older). The people there would be unlikely to build houses with strong stone walls and neglect to build a roof.
- devilbunny 5y agoAgreed. I can't imagine that people with even stone tools wouldn't figure out "hey, staying dry is nice" and make at least primitive roofs. A simple thatched or broad-leaf roof (e.g., palm/banana leaves) is not exactly hard technology to figure out.
- jimmyed 5y ago> After the two young ospreys were gone, I found that I was shaking, and in tears. The crying trope has become ubiquitous to signal emotion these days. Why isn't it possible to strongly feel something without the crying meme?
- leeroyjenkins11 5y agoI agree. The shaking and the crying is so over used. It seems like emotion has to be visible and violent for people to believe it's strong. I garentee that the feelings of brotherhood between him and the bird went one way. This was written by someone who walks in nature, but doesn't take part in it. Like being when I archery hunt, I'm more part of nature than someone standing on their deck feeling the brotherhood of an osprey. The CNS questions sound like something people who regularly spend time in nature would never say. Except for hipsters who want to be outdoorsy and go on a shopping spree in REI
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kerneloftruth 5y agoOften they'll phrase it as "I'm literally shaking".
- wmeredith 5y agoPretty my family alone murders a dozen+ chickens a month.
- ramphastidae 5y agoThis is completely unsubstantiated but I think Americans watch so much television that they learn the majority of their behaviors from actors and producers who exaggerate everything for the screen.
- elzbardico 5y agoYou're right. And it is so cheap, so vulgar, how can most people not see it?
- _moof 5y ago> Seldom do we go outside on a clear night, away from the lights of the city, and gaze at the dark starry sky, or take walks in the woods unaccompanied by our digital devices. I am so, so, so tired of people who live in cities acting like other human beings don't exist. There's a whole world out there, folks, and it continues to exist even after your vacation is over.
- d33 5y agoI'm not sure I understood your point, especially in relation to what you quote. Could you rephrase that?
- _moof 5y agoThe "we" in that statement fails to account for the millions of people who do, in fact, do these things regularly. This failure to imagine that there are vast numbers of people whose lives are different from the author's is something I see frequently, and it's irritating.
- vba616 5y agoI doubt it's a failure to imagine other lives. I think it's probably deliberately appealing to people who are miserable and feel helpless to change their lives by, say, leaving their city for a rural life. Not that it's helping them, but it's addressing them. The reasons why it's impossible to move to a rural area and be done with it are left unstated.
- prawn 5y agoSentence prior started “Many of us…” I’d say the “we” is referring to those people.
- _moof 5y agoThat's fair. I suppose the source of my irritation isn't just that one sentence; it's more holistic. And it's borne out of experiences living in rural areas that people from nearby cities treat like their own personal playgrounds. I just don't have much patience left for an article bemoaning the lack of "nature" when "nature" is still very much there, and its apparent disappearance is the result of deliberate choices, not some irresistible force. Anyway, I'm going to put down the screen and go outside and look at the dark starry sky now.
- aaron695 5y ago
- prescriptivist 5y agoThere is a strangeness to this piece that I can't quite get a handle on. For one thing, it is a transcendentalist tribute, the contours of which are predictable: an intellectual living in Boston owns a vacation home in Maine. They go up there a few times a year to fill up their nature reserves, then import those back into their circles in academia/literature/media at the end of summer. That's been a cottage industry for a couple of hundred years now (Emerson, Thoreau, et al.) That's not a big deal, I live in Maine, and this kind of mining is good for the economy. What bothers me is the piece feels compelled to cite studies such as an Oberlin "nature scale" (which seems insane) and various surveys and other studies to provide an academic backing to their run-of-the-mill transcendentalism. This approach to naturalism seems to denude whatever point they are trying to make. As if we need experts to confirm our nature to love nature? Who is this written for?
- i000 5y agoGreat thoughtful comment. I think you answer your question yourself. It is defensively written for the modern intellectual who wishes their beliefs to have a flair of objectivity. Perhaps another question is, why it is not enough for the author to trust they intuition when it comes to well-being?
- prescriptivist 5y ago> why it is not enough for the author to trust they intuition when it comes to well-being? Good question. I found the section where the author experiences the mind-meld with an Osprey to be the only charming part of the piece. It's an unguarded moment in a guarded essay. It's also downright bizarre but endearing and an experience anyone could have to an encounter in the woods. It's very human. Shame that it's encased in all that objectivity, indeed.
- stathibus 5y agoI'd call myself an Alan Lightman fan (Einstein's Dreams is a lovely book) but I think he missed on this one.
- 5y ago
- nickpp 5y agoI wonder if these writers are simply projecting. I go hiking, camping, fishing, skiing, diving - I love nature. Yet I also love living and working in the city, away from all the mud and hard work, in high-rise clean buildings with sterile offices and lots of tech. It doesn't have to be either/or, I can enjoy both and choose when I go for one of the other. I hear people looking way back and saying that it was better. But my grandmother was rising at 4am to feed the farm animals then work the rest of the day in the field. She also had only two surviving siblings out of 14 or 15 in total. Her words to my father and me were always: study and study well because without that life is damn hard and always lacking.
- vagrantJin 5y agoI agree that we live mediated lives but thats just a by product of excess. Living close to nature is not as fun as OP makes it out. Thats why we left that to the animals. That being said, being too disconnected from nature might create problems we can't yet see.
- elzbardico 5y agoWe are part of the nature. Whether our actions are conductive to a healthy eco-system or not, whether we maintain an environment that keeps the biodiversity in order to keep life viable for the future are the questions. But this cult of a past forgotten pristine nature, this misanthropist vision that every one of our interventions in the nature which we are as much a part of as a beaver or an ant is just religious, superstitious garbage.
- ryeights 5y ago>We are part of the nature. In semantics only. We all know what is generally meant by the term ‘nature’—wilderness, parts of the Earth relatively undisturbed by man’s industrialization. If we built a planet-destroying nuclear device and used it to turn Earth into dust, would that still be nature to you?