12 ms·
The writer who made me love comics taught me to hate them (2016)
- Fricken 5y agoIf Frank Miller was the only person allowed to tell stories, I would be concerned as well.
- tptacek 5y agoYou're not being asked for that kind of concern. It's a retrospective critique of an artist, and a negative one. That's all. Criticism would be super boring if it was never negative.
- Fricken 5y agoA critique has to be insightful and relevant to be interesting. You can critique Lebron James for the Stanley cups he didn't win, and that would be just as invalid as critiquing Frank Miller for the characters he didn't portray.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 5y agoThere's nothing that appeals more to right-wing nationalists than cop-worshiping vigilantes. On the other hand, there's nothing that appeals more to middle-class liberals than vigilantes that are wracked with guilt. edit: so the result is that liberals project guilt onto the guiltless protagonists of rightist creators, or decide that the entire thing is a complex satirical statement.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoNo need to divide it along political boundaries: vigilantism is a power-fantasy for everyone that has ever been at the receiving end of someone or agency with authority over them.
- pessimizer 5y agoNow it's you who are projecting. My fantasy is a functioning civilization, not killing criminals or imagining excitedly what will happen to a child molester in prison. edit: honestly, if politics is about anything, it's law and order. The fact that "politics" has become a euphemism for discussions of race, sex, and gender and indignantly expected to be totally separated from the processes of governing is bizarre. Right-wingers fantasize about the justice they'd mete out if they weren't restrained by liberal guilt. Liberals despair about the justice that they have to mete out to protect their ideal society.
- ss108 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pawelmurias 5y ago
- cafard 5y agoThe Spartans were hardly what I'd call lovable, but it's a bit much to imagine that they were the first to have a racist state.
- ncmncm 5y ago
- enkid 5y agoRacist really isn't the right word. Sparta wouldn't have a concept of "race." It was an extreme oligarchy based on the persecution and terrorization of the Helots, 90% of the population for the benefit of the elite 10%, a system everyone was born into. But there was the possibility of being "freed" or of a Spartan to lose their citizenship, making it not equivalent to racism. It was inherently vile, deadly, and is unfairly revered in the modern day in a way that is quite disturbing, but racist is simply not the right word.
- ncmncm 5y agoLet's not even get started on the Assyrians and Neo-assyrians.
- pawelmurias 5y agoMaybe first is the wrong world but they are the ideological ancestors of the Third Reich. In Sparta your genes determined if you where either a proper person who whose only purpose was to out breed (and for a man fight) or a helot subhuman who did all the work.
- spapas82 5y agoFor me, the best Frank Miller Story is his Daredevil Born Again story arc. It has a great and very motivational story (I don't wont to tell much) and excellent drawings by D. Mazzucchelli. This story is on my top 2 comics ever along with Alan Moore's Watchmen.
- styluss 5y agogreat article. reminds me of one about Alan Moore ending up hating The Killing Joke and the Watchmen's message https://www.inverse.com/article/14967-alan-moore-now-believes-the-killing-joke-was-melodramatic-not-interesting https://www.inverse.com/article/14967-alan-moore-now-believe...
- workaccount21 5y agoSounds like she just isn't the audience Frank was writing for, which of course is a cardinal sin if you have a platform to complain about it.
- pupppet 5y agoSounds like you're not the audience the blogger was writing for. As someone who fancies female characters being written as more than a love interest or someone to be raped, and don't believe sexual ambiguity makes a villain more frightening, I'm on board with what she's writing.
- avereveard 5y agoI believe that given a pie of content from comic book targeted at young male adult the pie dedicated to action is way larger than the pie dedicated to romance - and the flatness of woman carachter has more to do with audience interests / space dedicated to romance than writers' skills. that said I too hate that non protagonist women are mostly treated as props to a story and protagonist women mostly embody male tropes in a woman body - I think there can be much more than that.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoYou may be right but it's too bad then: they have a platform and an eager audience and are wasting an opportunity to depict a mature and healthy relationship in comics.
- avereveard 5y agoI mean, they are on thin ice - can you imagine the ruckus parents would do at anything but cis? or the ruckus blogger would do if every "mature and healthy" relationship gets portrayed as necessarily cis? I see them using tropes also as a quick way out. albeit there's some interesting takes if you search around, like in the amazon "invincible" - but I guess a miniseries has more space for it, and it's for a more adult audience to begin with.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI'm 15. I read romance novels constantly. I begin to notice that the male love interests are all muscular billionaire vampire pirate bad boys with a dark side yearning to be tamed. No romance novelist ever writes a love interest who is an awkward teen boy who likes to read all day and play Magic the Gathering and video games all night. Why can't romance novelists represent me?
- di4na 5y agoThere are romance novelists that do that ! i am not a romance specialist, but i know they exist. I advise to search a bit, maybe ask your local library. Romance is a really wide genre, the biggest, with a lot of different niche. It exist. I promise you.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI'm not actually a romance novel enthusiast, I'm just parodying the article. From my point of view the article is a complaint about how Frank Miller, an author who specializes in writing edgy grimdark superhero comics for teenage boys, doesn't write the kind of character that might appeal to a 20-30 something feminist.
- majormajor 5y agoThe article's complaint about Miller's stories goes quite a bit further than that.
- ALittleLight 5y agoPlease elaborate.
- tptacek 5y agoThere's a whole thread of elaboration on this point.
- 5y ago
- hackeraccount 5y agoFrank Miller's fun. The way a lot of things are fun but I wouldn't go around pretending he's something he's not. This is one step past taking knock knock jokes seriously.
- dsr_ 5y agoNah, people are allowed to critique literature. If you enjoy it without wanting to think about it, that's your right; her right is to think about it and write about what she's thinking.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoWhen I was a teenager, I probably would have dug violent vigilantism (like I enjoyed "Mad Max" when it came out at that time). My own art back then reflected a cynical, dark, post-apocalyptic future (likely inspired by films like "A Boy and His Dog" as an example). Story time: in those days the "copy shops" were ma and pa (the way the original video rental stores were) and the nearest copy shop where I took some of my art to be "Xeroxed" was, apparently, run by a born-again Christian. When I picked up my art he felt I needed a preachin' to. "Why spend your talents making the world a darker place?" Why not make positive art?" (Or something along those lines. I think "glory of God" was in there too and was in fact the tell.) I thought at the time how boring that would be, how "non-cool", "non-art" that was. I laughed it off. Three decades later I can begin to appreciate his disappointment in younger me. The world events since (and since I got older and started paying attention) have informed me that indeed there is already too many horrific (real) things in the world. Older me now just can't enjoy, for example, a Quentin Tarantino film (no doubt teen me would have loved it though). I have no interest in Frank Miller. I don't want to live in his world, don't care even to look at it.
- at_a_remove 5y agoI say this as someone who still occasionally pulls up a YouTube video of a supercut of 300 up against the song "Tangerine Speedo" to emphasize the accidental homoeroticism of the movie, just for giggles: it's a graphic novel. Art oversimplifies to make its points, and graphic novels are no stranger to that. Perhaps they are even the best example of doing so. That it doesn't align with your personal politics at the time is not a crime. It's not even interesting. I can imagine fewer things more boring than someone going over a work with a fine-toothed comb looking for violations of their own personal Hays Code. None of them will turn that level of inspection on their ideological pets, only their "problematic faves." I dare her: do romance novels next, and do it from a men's rights perspective. I've read my fair share of them, they're all a real crapfest if you want to think of men as actual people instead of living props in the Happily Ever After each heroine is owed. But that doesn't sell clicks on Polygon.
- goto11 5y ago> I dare her: do romance novels next, and do it from a men's rights perspective. There is some weird gatekeeping in this thread. The blogger is a self-proclaimed lover of comic books writing a critique of Frank Millers work - and you demand she write about romance novels? Where is is suggested she even have any interest in that genre?
- pessimizer 5y agoIt's ok to go through 300 to laugh at homoeroticism, but not ok to discuss the points that art is trying to make when it oversimplifies? My only problem with this is the cultural critic's insistence on assigning everything they enjoy with a complex intellectual meaning and significance. It's self-praise, in the guise of analysis, used to rationalize the sheer amount of time spent consuming popular products of the culture industry.
- Aerroon 5y agoIsn't this insistence what we teach kids though? We make them read and analyze novels even when they have little context to put those ideas into. You can read too deeply into everything, even when it isn't the author's intent. On the other hand, some of the things in popular culture are what teach us about what the world is like. For example, I would wager that more people are taught what guns are like by video games and movies, than the actual physical objects themselves. This means that there is some purpose to analysing popular products from a variety of angles. It might teach us new things about the world. We probably do it from the same few (political) angles too often though.
- ginko 5y agoI'm sort of in the same boat with Frank Miller. I really liked The Dark Knight Returns because I thought it was a great deconstruction that showed the dark side of vigilantism and power fantasies visual references to Birth of a Nation and all that. I was pretty of disappointed when I found out that Miller actually wasn't ironic. Thankfully there's plenty other comic writers I still enjoy.
- inerte 5y agoAlan Moore for me. Lots of people know Watchmen is about what would "really" happens if super heroes existed, and that lived rent free in my mind for years. But 2 things really made it click. Alan saying Rorschach (who I thought was a great character) was basically Batman-in-the-real-world, which killed Batman for me. The nail on the head was this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2yZwh_gCIU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2yZwh_gCIU about Marvelmen and I don't remember if it's in the video or I read somewhere else, but it's when a super-hero that can manipulate reality, which in fact there's about a hundred of them in Marvel / DC, decides money is the root of all evil and vanishes money from the planet, and the world descends in complete chaos. And now that actually lives rent free for me, as a young men angry at the hyper-capitalism and consumption we live in, who used to occasionally think the world would be better without money, I now realize that would indeed plunge humanity into a freaking mess. I now enjoy watching Marvel and DC movies for the spectacle and action scenes, but I sorta don't enjoy most comics (at least the superhero genre) anymore. What I think it's funny is that it just took me a long time to realize this. Actual superhero writers know exactly who they're writing for, angsty 13-year boys, see for example the interview here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6dfI_2dscGE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6dfI_2dscGE
- tptacek 5y agoWhat's the thing you thought Moore was doing ironically that it turned out he was (disturbingly) doing non-ironically? That's the point being made in the parent comment: that Frank Miller is traded in the culture as someone making an ironic commentary on violence and jingoism, but is in fact non-ironically captive to it. I feel like people generally trade in the idea that Alan Moore is a creative lunatic with crazy ideas; you're getting what it says on the tin with him.
- jccalhoun 5y agoI liked Dark Knight Returns quite a bit and I've read it a few times but every time I get to the part with the woman with swastikas tattooed on her boobs I can't help but wonder what the point of that was. Strikes Back was bad. Then Holy Terror came out and it was a xenophobic caricature. Since then I haven't had much interest in anything he's done. I did see a comment from him that seems to indicate he's walked back some of his extremist views but I've moved on.
- tptacek 5y agoDid you revise your opinion of the Miller's entire oeuvre after Holy Terror? That's what happened to me with Dave Sim and Cerebus at some point; like, you see the previous work in a previous light, and it doesn't work anymore. It's like that episode of The Office where Brian Baumgartner sells James Spader on "the oatmeal raisin cookie idea" in a meeting, only to realize after later hearing about "the Big Mac idea" that "it was always just cookies. ...". That's I think one of the big critical narratives about Miller --- it was always just cookies.
- throwaway5752 5y agoYou nailed it. Scott Adams, too, to a certain degree. It's a bit of frame breaking when one finds out a creator has an outsized personality. There's a bit of projection involved in taking in art, and finding there is a great differenced between the imagined creator of a work and the actual creator forces a reinterpretation. It's unavoidable. Maybe Jane Fonda and people with Barberella posters who disagreed with her real life views, for an older example. I think it's particular painful with Frank Miller because the work becomes much less interesting than how a number of us had read it initially.
- tptacek 5y agoI think that's probably the big idea behind this critique, right? It's not that Frank Miller has bad ideas (though...) --- it's that when you realize he wasn't really kidding, he's much less interesting. His work isn't thoughtful; it's just id.
- elcapitan 5y ago> I am 20 and I'm majoring in Creative Writing, because I want to write comic books for a living. Can't wait to read those, if they're as insightful and creative as this article.
- tptacek 5y agoThe author is doing the Watchmen Jon Osterman narrative thing. She was 20 in 2006.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y agoInteresting. This is hiding at the top of the page's html: =================================================================== == lovingly brought to you by... ================================== =================================================================== ______ __ __ ______ ______ __ __ ______ /\ ___\ /\ \_\ \ /\ __ \ /\ == \ /\ \/\ \ /\ ___\ \ \ \____ \ \ __ \ \ \ \/\ \ \ \ __< \ \ \_\ \ \ \___ \ \ \_____\ \ \_\ \_\ \ \_____\ \ \_\ \_\ \ \_____\ \/\_____\ \/_____/ \/_/\/_/ \/_____/ \/_/ /_/ \/_____/ \/_____/ =================================================================== =============================== https://www.voxmedia.com/careers === =================================================================== (Found it as I was clicking to get rid of the cookie banner.)
- korse 5y agoNice catch!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dkarl 5y agoThe flip side of Poe's Law. Fifteen years ago, my father used to love rense.com and a couple of other conspiracy sites. He thought it was good fun. He thought the people running and contributing to them were just blowing off steam by poking dark fun at how stupid people could be, basically liberals doing some mean-spirited LARPing as conservatives. Knowing that some people would take them seriously just made it funnier in his mind. I never asked him later (like after 2016) if he had revised his estimate of how many people on those sites were deadly serious versus poking fun. When I first got my hands on a Frank Miller graphic novel, I had been led to believe that it was a critical examination of how people are seduced by violence, be careful when you look into the abyss, etc., but I was old enough to realize as I read it that the reason it was wildly popular was because it worked as wish fulfillment violence porn, and I couldn't see any sign that the author intended it to be read in any other way. Not that I was too good to enjoy it on that level, but after I finished it, I felt that it would be wrong to go back for more.
- coldtea 5y agoGiving the facile psyche of the day (or, for that matter, 2016 as well) and the need for facile denunciation of anything that doesn't share the ideology of the day, I knew who the comic writer would be before I opened the page. Opened it anyway to verify and wasn't dissapointed.
- tptacek 5y agoThe textbook lowbrow dismissal. Why even bother commenting? Disagree if you're going to disagree; that's a contribution.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 5y ago>The textbook lowbrow dismissal Now that's just parphrasing how I described the article - only I tied it to specifics more, and also revealed something interesting: that such a denunciation is so cliche, that I knew who the artist would be just from reading the title (which is true, I did guess it correctly and then opened it and saw that I had called it).
- tptacek 5y agoYour rebuttal here is that you saw a "facile" takedown of a comics author and thought "this can only be Frank Miller, no other comics author ever engenders facile takedowns"? I'm skeptical.
- TigeriusKirk 5y agoI too guessed it was Frank Miller. It's a pretty common opinion and has been for some time.
- coldtea 5y agoIt said "made me love comics" so I immediately thought "so that was someome prominent in the past" and then "taught me to have them" meant "ok, so he's controversial enough to warrant a 'I was triggered when I understood those comics/his personal ideas' article" - put two and two together and bingo. If it said the same about a sci-fi author, I'd have guessed someone like Heinlein (or maybe Asimov).
- theshrike79 5y agoI actively don't seek out information about the artist I like. There's exactly nothing to gain by knowing who they are and what their views on the world are. It's better to stay ignorant and enjoy their work. Example: I read the Dragons of Autumn Twilight (etc) books by Margaret Weis and Tracy Hickman in the early 90s. The book series was hugely influential on my youth. I didn't know Tracy Hickman is male until way into the current millennium.
- tedunangst 5y agoI read the annotated chronicles, which obviously reveals more about the authors' backgrounds, but thought it was interesting to see how they'd straddle the line between writing things they believed and things they didn't.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hsnewman 5y agoSo what your saying is your persuadable.
- blockwriter 5y agoThese are fair points for someone that works in the industry and wishes to engage critically with her anxiety of influence, as Harold Bloom would call it. I doubt if her critique, in itself, leads to a rhetorical basis that is any more aesthetically sound. In good time, another writer will undoubtedly point out how flimsy the reactionary storytelling of the 2020s was. At least along this one axis, I am unconvinced by this article that Miller’s lurid pulp is much different from the remedies the author suggests. The proof is in the pudding.
- tptacek 5y agoSay more! This sounds interesting. What are the remedies you perceive Polo as pushing here?
- blockwriter 5y agoI don’t perceive her as pushing remedies, but I think they are suggested. The suggestion is that the works would be better if they adhered closer to “reality” or if the psychological tension was overtly comprehended and demonstrated by the writer rather than a tacit element. Many politically conscious people are just clueing into what literary criticism has long understood, although the conclusions drawn by the bulk of good literary criticism is, in my opinion, the exact opposite of those drawn by today’s reactionaries. Essentially, I think the article discounts the merit of a regressive fantasy. Today’s comic book media complex is very involute. Characters often explicitly state these regressive elements, the sexual tension, and etc. It is novel for a while, especially when it is in vogue for a largely illiterate populace to rediscover matters of criticism that literature has always encompassed; but it is just as likely to become brittle and inbred as the big boob, prostitute, truncated demise tropes are. Like I said, these are fair points that the author makes. It is, however, just as easy to point and laugh at someone that doesn’t seem to comprehend that they have not broken out of the aesthetic cycle, that they have failed to transcend, as it is to point and laugh at the latent homoeroticism of 300. All that being said, these are comic books, and I stopped reading them when I stopped getting pimples for good reason. Now, if you will excuse me, I have to watch grown men dribble a leather ball around and act like every foul called against them is a grievous insult to blood and legacy.
- whiddershins 5y agoAfter years, this is what I’ve come to. Conflating an artist with their art is always a mistake. Great works of art transcend the artist, and frankly, the artist usually doesn’t understand the work any better than anyone else. If you ask a writer or painter or musician … especially musicians/lyricists what their work is about you will always get a disappointing answer, if the piece is any good. They don’t know what it is, where it came from, they just manifested it.
- itisit 5y ago> They don’t know what it is, where it came from, they just manifested it. I don't think this rationale is going to restore The Cosby Show's syndication glory.
- overgard 5y agoYeah, especially when the artist is super complicated. Like, I'd rather enjoy Michael Jacksons music without having to bring in the weird questions about who Michael Jackson was
- jay_kyburz 5y agoI'll always enjoy the work of H.P. Lovecraft. I don't care who he was. I think it would be a different if I was actually giving that person money. If I'm funding somebody, I want to know where my money is going.
- musicale 5y ago> If I'm funding somebody, I want to know where my money is going HP Lovecraft's estate is presumably funding the continuing elder rituals that will eventually resurrect him from his sunken tomb at R'lyeh.
- TameAntelope 5y agoIt's often disappointing, I've found, to hear an artist talk about their own work. The artist rarely, if ever, lives up to my expectations of them, as the creator of something I like. Instead, I've started to look at artists as separate people, who are capable of creating work I like, but otherwise I try to think of them as entirely separate, and hope I can come to appreciate/like them for who they are, beyond just, the "vessel" for the art I like.
- Mezzie 5y agoWhat I find interesting about this article is that the author mentions the ways in which she's disadvantaged compared to Frank Miller (she's mixed-race and female to his straight white male), but if you read between the lines, she's quite financially privileged. She's looking at college campuses at 15, her parents bought her expensive new books, she goes to college right after high school and majors in Creative Writing, she's managing a news site at 24 which usually means she's either got unpaid internships, startup help, or a writing network already. It's not the author's fault, but it'd be really nice if these types of articles started reckoning with the author's privileges and not just their marginalizations. If Frank Miller alienated her because his viewpoint over-saturates his work, how is she going to make sure her work doesn't do the same to poor mixed-race women? Or trans women? If there's an actual interest in making sure different viewpoints are represented and better stories are told (the part I personally care about), then why do articles so often get boiled down to 'pay attention to my particular identities'? I don't know, I guess I don't know what the point of the piece is.
- pawelmurias 5y agoIsn't the point of mentioning her identify to show how she viewed the comics from her particular viewpoint?
- tptacek 5y agoWell, there's a whole thread here talking about what the point of the piece is. Miller is frequently mentioned in the same breath as Alan Moore as an author famous for bringing sophisticated, adult-oriented storytelling to comics and thus broadening the genre. But a retrospective look at his work shows that much of what was read at the time as an ironic deconstruction of comic book tropes (the same sort of thing Watchmen is rightly praised for) is probably non-ironic; it's just straight-faced pulp id. That's nothing new to comics; he just happens to have done it stylishly enough to attract fresh attention. So: if Miller's work speaks mostly to young white males, then it's failed to accomplish the artistic goal he's credited for. If it's really meant for adults, that's even worse: then what you have here is something akin to Heinlein and "Starship Troopers" (perhaps substituting jingoism for fascism). That's the critique in a nutshell. If you don't care about the artistic merit of Miller's writing, then the piece is definitely not written for you. It has more or less nothing to do with privilege analysis.
- karaterobot 5y agoHating comics because you don't like Frank Miller sounds like a huge overreaction. If you don't like Frank Miller, just stop reading his comics. Or, better yet, roll your eyes at some elements of his work, admire others, learn what you can from them, and form the nuanced opinions we need in our complicated world.
- tptacek 5y agoThat's exactly what the author did here.
- wishinghand 5y agoI'm pretty sure someone else wrote the headline. That thesis never comes through in the actual article.
- TameAntelope 5y agoShe still lists Batman as her favorite comic book character on this website's bio of her. I don't think she "hates" comics, considering it's her entire job, and has been for her whole career.
- rndgermandude 5y agoThere are people who "hate" for a living, like the pundits you can see on cable news shows. I am not saying she is one - I know next to nothing about her - just that these people generally exist, and your assumption that she must not hate comics might be a little flawed.
- TameAntelope 5y agoYou put "hate" in quotes for a reason, and I think that explains where our communication disconnect lies.
- rndgermandude 5y agoI put "hate" in quotes same as the person I was replying to did in their own comment.
- Speednet 5y ago
- mcphage 5y ago> At least until comics are no longer being produced because the straight male-hating audience is actually not as big as they think it is. Having just read an article about how the author learned to love comics from a creator who hated her, it’s a shame that you don’t think straight males would be able to do the same.
- valar_m 5y ago> At least until comics are no longer being produced because the straight male-hating audience is actually not as big as they think it is. This reminds of a quote from something I read recently, about 90 seconds ago. The link to the article is at the top of the page if you're curious: You're not threatening, it seems, until you're sexually threatening to a straight guy.
- blacksqr 5y ago> "The 80-page giant comic cost 25 cents," he concludes, "but I bought it anyway." ... Miller doesn't mention who wrote, who drew, who edited the book that made him a fan For a professional comics journalist and fan of the Dark Knight detective, it's strange she brings this up as though it's some dark historical mystery. A little online research suggests that it was 80-page Giant #12, published July 1965. Her questions about who wrote, drew, edited it are answered in the link below: https://dc.fandom.com/wiki/80-Page_Giant_Vol_1_12 https://dc.fandom.com/wiki/80-Page_Giant_Vol_1_12
- nieve 5y agoHer point that you missed is that he didn't credit his inspirations, not that it's a mystery. It stands out from most comic writers and artists because talking about your inspirations is such a standard thing for people in the field.
- SLWW 5y ago> While speaking to NPR about his personal reaction to the September 11th attacks a few months later, Miller would say: "For the first time in my life I know how it feels to face an existential menace." I think that I've never heard something so white, straight, male and sheltered. He will eventually repackage the idea as simply Holy Terror, after jettisoning any reference to the superhero. I think most people felt that way after seeing the attacks. I am weary of any writer who makes it a "white, straight, male and sheltered" thing to be worried about one of the worst terror attacks on our soil. It's a human thing, and for Americans who had never served in combat, it would be the first time they ever felt a threat that real; "existential menace" means, implying the existence of a threat. Innocent lives were lost, a lot of lives, and it shook a nation. I only bring it up because of how unnecessary that seemingly flippant remark was to me. Whether or not Miller was a good guy or not doesn't mean the deaths of thousands is a proof of his race, sex, etc.; it comes off as hateful which is a real shame, I am more likely to question the author's intent. Personally i don't disagree with most of the article, I would have liked a more thorough review of what the writer is talking about when she mentions different troubling things about the comics, as i would have to read it myself to see what they are even talking about. (EDIT: i re-read the last few points and i retract that i agree with most; i think i disagree with most of her points. Sometimes i give benefit of the doubt, only to look again and realize the take is mostly vapid)
- morelisp 5y agoAn "existential menace" does not mean "the existence of threat", and 9/11 was not and did not presage any kind of existential threat. It is in fact a "sheltered" thing to think it is, and that it is uniquely so in America; minority communities in the US did and still regularly face existential threats, and suffer loss of innocent lives as a result of them.
- Doxin 5y ago> 9/11 was not and did not presage any kind of existential threat Agreed. That wasn't at all clear at the time though. You can feel an existential threat without one existing.