3 ms·
There remain benefits: - Hospital capacity is limited, staff burnout is real, and delayed treatments for non-Covid conditions are occurring. Given Omicron's t
by dredmorbius 5y ago
There remain benefits:
- Hospital capacity is limited, staff burnout is real, and delayed treatments for non-Covid conditions are occurring. Given Omicron's tremendously fast spread, slowing spread even slightly helps.
- Infection isn't an all-or-nothing strategy. Innoculum, that is, the amount of virus you're exposed to, matters, and a smaller innoculum may reduce severity of symptoms.
- There remain many individuals who are immunocompromised or who have multiple risk factors for Covid.
- Though Omicron's severity is lower, it is not zero. Looking at South Africa, it appears that net total deaths are about 1/3 of previous Covid waves. South Africa's peak was early enough that we're probably seeing peak mortality about now.
- Further mutation of Covid is likely, and the more cases and more variants of virus are spread, the more likely those become. We've seen variants with greater severity (Delta) and greater infectiousness (Omicron). A variant combining those traits would be highly unfortunate.
There are countries which are likely to see major Omicron outbreaks. I've been watching India's new daily cases double every 3 days since January 4, growing from 59k cases then to 533k on 13 January, pretty much precisely as I'd projected. (I was, and am, very much hoping for that trend to break. Given India's pretty clear testing and data reporting issues, hitting a numeric target may not be especially significant. But the point remains that in a country of 1.4 billions, even with a relatively low incident fatality rate, India could be looking at 20--80 million deaths. More if healthcare services are overwhelmed.
Access to, and proper protocols for masks, could help.
- robbrown451 5y ago"Though Omicron's severity is lower, it is not zero. " There isn't a zero risk of any number of more dangerous things. This is no longer high risk, at all, for reasonably healthy people who are vaccinated and boosted. (those who aren't are foolish) I'm willing to wait out the surge, but after that, I am hoping those in my community (bay area.... which doesn't have overcrowding of hospitals because of high vaccination rate) are ready to get rid of the masks and get on with normal life.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMy point is that at a population level, the multiple of reduced severity * vastly greater infectiousness appears to be a net higher overall impact in terms of hospitalisations and deaths. This is especially the case for countries which have to date managed to contain earlier Covid variants. Australia comes to mind. Or China. Masking to slow spread seems highly apposite.
- colechristensen 5y agoThe point is it’s too late, the peak already happened. You can’t slow the spread because the peak infection rate is already here and population dynamics are going to limit it now. Good times for advice like this for masking were a month ago and a year ago. It is time to admit defeat and act like it’s too late for those kinds of growth mitigations.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere are places which have not yet peaked, or have not yet started. In the US, a few (mostly east-coast) states have peaked. West, central, and mountain, and south, not so much. Given limited services and long distances in rural states, masking would be highly advisible. (Numerous highly-advisable actions have, of course, been soundly rejected.) Both the practice and empirical data on its efficacy would be useful in parts of the world Omicron has not yet hit. I do agree the advice would have been far more useful 4--6 weeks ago. Call your local Timelord.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nradov 5y agoWastewater monitoring data shows that the peak was probably a few days ago in the SF Bay Area. Other areas may lead or lag by a few days. https://covid19.sccgov.org/dashboard-wastewater https://covid19.sccgov.org/dashboard-wastewater