4 ms·
I really don’t see the point unless you’re immune compromised or at some other high risk. Omicron is the evolutionary result you wait for, better at spreading
by colechristensen 5y ago
I really don’t see the point unless you’re immune compromised or at some other high risk. Omicron is the evolutionary result you wait for, better at spreading and less health impact so it significantly outcompetes other variants (it has, something like 95% of infections). Peak omicron is coming withina master of days or already passed across the US. It’s virulence is such that you can only delay not expect to forever avoid or extinct the virus.
It’s time to admit defeat and plan for what that looks like and stop pretending like anything at this point is going to make this virus go away. It’s here, it’s going to kill about one person in a thousand of those left, and if you choose to not get vaccinated that’s your choice and if you’re not young you’re taking a significantly higher risk of death.
But unless you work in healthcare or care for the elderly you’re not going to do anything but slightly delay exposure to your neighbors because the new variant is so easily spread.
The moral issue is passed, the chance to save anyone but the most vulnerable is passed, and any efforts are only going to marginally delay the inevitable. You want to gamble and not get vaccinated, go for it.
People will be in denial about this for a long time and beating the morality drum for a long time, but in a hundred years a covid strain will still be around and people will be telling their children about how great grandpa got covid in 2020, like I just heard tell of my great grandfather getting the 1918 flu preparing to go out to WWI getting treated in a bed outside because there was no hospital space. That flu is still around this century and covid still will be next century.
Sorry, we lost, there are still going to be consequences but I can’t imagine anything changing regardless of what you do besides a matter of weeks of when you get exposed. Fauci said as much, that everyone being exposed was now more or less unavoidable.
If you disagree what long term changes do you think can be realistically achieved by doing anything whether or not it’s practical?
- ebrewste 5y agoThere are no vaccines for those under five years old. It appears it’s too much effort for everyone wear a mask until we get a vaccine for all. I used to think that this was how most people thought and behaved, but now it is confirmed clearly for me.
- alfor 5y agoWhat are the risks for kids under 5 ?
- hedgehog 5y agoIn the near term COVID isn't that likely to make them really sick but a non-negligible % of kids appear to get MIS-C or weird long-term effects like diabetes. If we can extrapolate much from adults getting the kids vaccinated will go a long way towards reducing those.
- nradov 5y agoBased on CDC data the risk of an infected child getting MIS-C is about 0.02%, and the risk of dying from MIS-C is about 0.0002%. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#mis-national-surveillance https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#mis-national-surve... https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...
- hedgehog 5y agoSure, and diabetes around 0.05%, and then the assortment of cognitive, respiratory, and cardiac symptoms that are less life threatening but more common. AAP has a reasonable overview: https://www.aap.org/en/pages/2019-novel-coronavirus-covid-19-infections/clinical-guidance/post-covid-19-conditions-in-children-and-adolescents/ https://www.aap.org/en/pages/2019-novel-coronavirus-covid-19... There's a fair amount of uncertainty but stack it up the likely negative outcomes and I wouldn't let my unvaccinated kid catch COVID if I had a reasonable way to achieve that.
- nradov 5y agoFortunately CDC data clearly shows that there is no significant risk for those under five years old. COVID-19 is less dangerous to them than other common viruses such as RSV. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd... https://emergency.cdc.gov/han/2021/han00443.asp https://emergency.cdc.gov/han/2021/han00443.asp
- chasd00 5y agoYeah I’ve stopped wearing a mask period. Omicron has made it pointless.
- HWR_14 5y agoHow does that make sense. N95s protect against all variants.
- josephcsible 5y agoGP's point was that Omicron has outcompeted the other variants, and it's not dangerous enough to need to be protected against.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 5y agoThere remain benefits: - Hospital capacity is limited, staff burnout is real, and delayed treatments for non-Covid conditions are occurring. Given Omicron's tremendously fast spread, slowing spread even slightly helps. - Infection isn't an all-or-nothing strategy. Innoculum, that is, the amount of virus you're exposed to, matters, and a smaller innoculum may reduce severity of symptoms. - There remain many individuals who are immunocompromised or who have multiple risk factors for Covid. - Though Omicron's severity is lower, it is not zero. Looking at South Africa, it appears that net total deaths are about 1/3 of previous Covid waves. South Africa's peak was early enough that we're probably seeing peak mortality about now. - Further mutation of Covid is likely, and the more cases and more variants of virus are spread, the more likely those become. We've seen variants with greater severity (Delta) and greater infectiousness (Omicron). A variant combining those traits would be highly unfortunate. There are countries which are likely to see major Omicron outbreaks. I've been watching India's new daily cases double every 3 days since January 4, growing from 59k cases then to 533k on 13 January, pretty much precisely as I'd projected. (I was, and am, very much hoping for that trend to break. Given India's pretty clear testing and data reporting issues, hitting a numeric target may not be especially significant. But the point remains that in a country of 1.4 billions, even with a relatively low incident fatality rate, India could be looking at 20--80 million deaths. More if healthcare services are overwhelmed. Access to, and proper protocols for masks, could help.
- robbrown451 5y ago"Though Omicron's severity is lower, it is not zero. " There isn't a zero risk of any number of more dangerous things. This is no longer high risk, at all, for reasonably healthy people who are vaccinated and boosted. (those who aren't are foolish) I'm willing to wait out the surge, but after that, I am hoping those in my community (bay area.... which doesn't have overcrowding of hospitals because of high vaccination rate) are ready to get rid of the masks and get on with normal life.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMy point is that at a population level, the multiple of reduced severity * vastly greater infectiousness appears to be a net higher overall impact in terms of hospitalisations and deaths. This is especially the case for countries which have to date managed to contain earlier Covid variants. Australia comes to mind. Or China. Masking to slow spread seems highly apposite.
- linsomniac 5y agoDude, honestly, going out shopping during the cold and flu season without a mask, seems a little gross. And, at least around here, it's super cold and flu and covid season right now...
- colechristensen 5y agoWhy? I’m a living organism, we get diseases. If we don’t get enough of them we often get other diseases. I’ve gone out in public my whole life in all seasons and am not disgusted by a little infection threat, it’s what being alive is. If you want to wear a mask, go ahead, you do you. But the time is quickly approaching where a government telling me I have to is going to be far beyond their legitimate purview.
- josephcsible 5y agoWe've been afraid all along that people would try to make masks a forever thing, and saying that not wearing a mask is gross is a big step in that direction.
- HWR_14 5y agoAfraid if it? I am and have been hoping wearing masks is a forever thing.
- josephcsible 5y agoI was using the exclusive "we".
- drsnow 5y agoAre you really afraid of it? Care explaining how it invokes fear?
- josephcsible 5y agoBy "afraid", I meant that we think it might happen, and think it would be bad if it does. Similar to how people can be afraid of global warming.
- cjonas 5y agoThis is spot on. I'm really hoping omicron will be the wave that finally helps achieve some level of "herd immunity". It's sad that we had the opportunity to do so via vaccination but failed to capitalize. However a variant with high transmission and low chance of severe symptoms is the next best thing
- dv_dt 5y agoThere likely is no herd immunity to be had. Omicron infects those with previous delta infections, and there are cases being studied further from South Africa of omicron cases getting reinfections of omicron. I think our best chance is faster vaccine cycles and better targeting of the sequences to impede transmission.
- tasha0663 5y agoA week or two ago they were saying Omicron might confer Delta immunity. Don't overlook that part.
- nradov 5y agoImmunity isn't a binary condition. Infection by any known SARS-CoV-2 variant will leave most recovered patients with a significant level of cellular immunity against all other variants. This won't necessarily prevent reinfection, but just like with every other coronavirus the symptoms of reinfection cases will typically be mild. The mRNA vaccines also seem to confer a significant level of durable cellular immunity against all variants, although they also don't reliably prevent infections.
- dv_dt 5y agoThat was what was said of delta, yet six months after, because of how many cases of delta were created, the next Omicron variant can reinfect previous delta patients. Just from looking at the broad waves of Covid, one should conclude that natural immunity conveyed by getting Covid does not protect us as a herd against future mutations. Because omicron is even more contagious, I might expect the next major variant in the same to faster timeframe, and that variant will have the grainy of bypass previous immunity to some degree.
- robbrown451 5y agoI don't think we lost, we developed a vaccine which reduces your chance of death by a factor of 20. (probably more than that if you are reasonably healthy) That's a win in my book. I am rapidly becoming in the "vaxxed and done" camp.... happy to get vaccinated and boosted as many times as necessary. But after two years, this is no longer an emergency situation for the vaccinated. It is simply not a big risk anymore. All kinds of things are bigger risks. I'm willing to wear a mask for a few more weeks but after that (when they say the surge will be mostly over), there is no point anymore.
- tasha0663 5y ago> the "vaxxed and done" camp.... happy to get vaccinated and boosted as many times as necessary My new year's resolution is that our institutions have until the end of the Greek alphabet to figure this out. I'll get boosters, but don't expect me to mask up for the Aleph-Tango-Susan-93 variant in 2024. Come hell or high water. I'm burying loved ones due to non-covid afflictions. If we blew it, we blew it. We can at least live while we die.
- toast0 5y agoI'm in Washington state and seeing that the hospitals are out of capacity again; national guard coming in to help and procedures deferred for a month per the governor. I don't know how it looks in other states. Whenever hospitals start deferring procedures, it's not great for health outcomes. One might hope that one outcome of this pandemic is more spare capacity in hospitals, but that's going to take a long time, if it happens. On a personal note, I don't like being sick, so if I can delay or prevent that, wearing a mask isn't awful. And I don't like large gatherings, so I'm not missing out on much by avoind those.
- nradov 5y agoYou might be able to delay it a bit. You won't be able to prevent it. The virus is here to stay and everyone will be exposed. https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646 https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646
- hedgehog 5y agoIf you get to pick it'd be way better to get sick in a couple months after the current wave has died down and there are beds, drugs, etc available for most patients.
- FridgeSeal 5y ago> It’s time to admit defeat and plan for what that looks like and stop pretending like anything at this point is going to make this virus go away. This isn’t defeat though? Winning doesn’t mean nobody gets the virus, it means we’re minimised ham and impact as much as possible, where possible. We might all get it, but there’s no reason for us all to get it at the same time and cause undue stress on our hospital system. > really don’t see the point unless you’re immune compromised or at some other high risk Because I have an active lifestyle and don’t really feel like risking chronic fatigue or lung damage unnecessarily? Because I have things I want to do, and having to sit at home isolating and being sick impacts my social life negatively? Because even if it’s not covid, I’m kinds of liking not sharing the air with that random person on public transport with some infection?
- akg_67 5y agoEven if Omicron is 10x more contagious and not serious enough to require 1/10th hospitalizations than previous variants, the load on healthcare system doesn’t become lower than previous variants. Use of Masks slow down the rate of infections enough so that healthcare system doesn’t get overloaded again and cause more deaths and sufferings of both Covid and non Covid patients alike due to system load and failure. When I read comments like yours, I am very glad that I decided to stay in Japan at the start of COVID-19 instead of returning to US. Here majority of people wear masks, irrespective of type and fit, when they leave home and take off only after returning home. Only taking off mask when absolutely needed such as eating or drinking. Wearing mask is all about reducing viral load rather than preventing infection completely. I hope for better critical thinking and logical reasoning and discourse on forums like HN. But I guess I have become too old and jaded.
- colechristensen 5y agoThe outcome we’re looking for and seem to have found right about now with a peak is the the virus sweeping though the population, literally exposing everyone, and running out of new people to infect. The peak happens when a high enough proportion of people have already been exposed it had it that the virus runs out of new people to infect. Because the growth rate for this variant is so fast, the post peak drop will be very quick. Population dynamics with exponential growth are like that. It seems like the only thing left to do is chase the impossible or just accept the situation and move on.
- nradov 5y agoWastewater monitoring data shows that the peak was probably a few days ago in the SF Bay Area. Other areas may lead or lag by a few days. https://covid19.sccgov.org/dashboard-wastewater https://covid19.sccgov.org/dashboard-wastewater
- slategruen 5y agoExactly. Finding the "most effective" mask and mandating it isn't practical anymore. I live in a developing country and there are relatively few antivaxxers here. Not a lot of people here are against mask mandates either. However, the Omicron variant still caused a huge surge in new cases. N95 is just too expensive. You could already purchase a meal for one person with the cost of an N95 here. What choice would an average person who works less than minimum wage? The approach here should be cultural. Encouraging employees to not go to work when they are sick should be normalized. Labor laws should be revised to include more sick leaves factoring in how prevalent COVID-19 has become. Public spaces should be retrofitted and redesigned to allow for a better ventilation. Controlling what mask people wear and how they wear is just too difficult to implement. Government must shift their focus away from the action of its citizens to the environment the citizens participate in.