3 ms·
The really ridiculous thing is that we're expected to "explain it like I'm 5" to smart computer hackers who don't know biology and constantly try to poke holes
by dekhn 5y ago
The really ridiculous thing is that we're expected to "explain it like I'm 5" to smart computer hackers who don't know biology and constantly try to poke holes in mainstream science without taking the time to understand the complexity and subtlety in that field.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- netizen-936824 5y agoI feel the same way when articles pop up about some drug. Sometimes it feels like I'm beating my head against a wall.
- feoren 5y agoI'm not really sure who you're talking about here. Who is expecting you to explain things to them simply? Informative comments are always appreciated, but I'm not sure why you're taking this as some personal obligation. Who is poking holes in mainstream science? I don't really see that happening in these comments.
- dekhn 5y agoI follow a lot of threads on the site, especially ones that appear to be COVID disinformation. And I see a lot of hackers asking "well, I read this <disinformation> and it made sense to me. Can you explain why it's not true?" This is pretty common. The reason I take it as obligation is that if there aren't people fighting disinformationn, the disinformation will win, because it tends to be full of simple, seductive, but. wrong ideas that naive people fall for.
- Jimmc414 5y agoDisinformation is defined as "false information intended to mislead". Do you think that is the intention of this author?
- dekhn 5y agoWell, it's possible the author believes what they wrote in which case it would be "false information believed to be true intended to teach" but I'm pretty sure this is active misinformation. I'm not sure which particular thing public health people said that you're complaining about in the last part of the section- but I don't really think that public health leaders who communicate things which aren't 100% correct are dissemination disinformation. That's sort of a pedantic and uninteresting argument to have about the philosophical nature of information.
- Jimmc414 5y agoWell, embedded within the term disinformation is an accusation, so thank you for clarifying.
- shataraxia 5y agoit may be pedantic, but it's good to know that "disinformation" denotes intent & "misinformation" appears to be the word you're looking for
- Comevius 5y agoAs a computer science guy I did my own ELI5, found out how insertion sequences work, found the paper about HIV-1 and 2019-nCov, but it is true, it takes time to understand. Even without spending time my heuristics is that I find biases in the claim and find out how referenced it is. This one had plenty red flags, including dismissing the RaTG13 results claiming that they were just put into the database after people started questioning, the adversarial tone, presumptions and so on. Conspiracy theorists use recognizable heuristics, but their motivation is to seek attention, for which there is large competition. They want to be relevant, but who doesn't. Conspiracy theorists are not really into publishing a paper either, a blog post, video or tweet is all you get, it's not about the truth and it is easier to avoid being found out this way, though social media these days have fact checkers, so they have to fly under the radar or keep to the social circles that are not bothered by fact checkers. Knowing about biases and how to recognize them is a vital skill, should be taught in schools. Everyone needs a working bullshit meter.
- hodwik3 5y ago> dismissing the RaTG13 results claiming that they were just put into the database after people started questioning To be fair, that sequence came from the Wuhan Institute of Virology
- jesse_a_b 5y agoI just checked, and this sequence is not even complete in the RaTG13 genome. Only 7 nucleotide match. It is in the Moderna 2015 patent. 19 nucleotide match.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThis appears to be a disease among technical people. The number of people who work in something like software and have decided that they can effectively evaluate research in a completely different field is frightening.