3 ms·

>Bad parenting causes schizophrenia Do you have a study or textbook that discusses this? I'm interested in reading more

newbamboo 5y ago
Quick google points to this: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23800431/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23800431/ It’s gotten “debunked” like so much else. Debunked means you aren’t allowed to talk about something. Bad parenting causes mental health problems, even though the factcheckers say otherwise.
- netizen-936824 5y ago
  This is the old, and silly, nature vs nurture debate. Its debunked because we now know that its a combination of genetics and environment (such bad parenting) that can bring about issues Such that someone generally needs to have the genetic predisposition for <mental_health_issue> in order for the bad parenting to surface it. In some cases the genetic predisposition is stronger such that we need less (or more) environmental influence to being about <issue> While it's not entirely incorrect to say that <environmental_factor> (such as parenting or cannabis) can bring about <issue>, its also misleading because we don't get the full picture of cause and effect And as such we have people who go around on the internet claiming they know the ~one true cause~ because they read some mischaracterized study reported on by <media_institution> Never listen to media institutions about singular scientific studies, the reporting is almost always entirely trash
wwwwewwww 5y ago
They do not. It's an old myth - the society used to blame schizophrenia on bad parents, especially mothers. This has no grounds in medical research.
- smorgusofborg 5y ago
  And now it is bad drugs.. AFAIK the argument against most environmental factors was that schizophrenia frequency seems similar globally after accounting for ways societies handle cases. Given the ethical limitations on this kind of research, I think a research group that wants to talk about probable causation really needs a cross cultural method to randomly sample and demonstrate active case prevalence changes and to run that sampling over many years.
therealcamino 5y ago
You could find textbooks from the 50's maybe. It's been discredited for a long time.
astura 5y ago
It's the old "Refrigerator mother theory" that's been largely discredited. Back from when autism was known as "childhood schizophrenia." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory

Quick google points to this: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23800431/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23800431/ It’s gotten “debunked” like so much else. Debunked means you aren’t allowed to talk about something. Bad parenting causes mental health problems, even though the factcheckers say otherwise.

netizen-936824 5y ago
This is the old, and silly, nature vs nurture debate. Its debunked because we now know that its a combination of genetics and environment (such bad parenting) that can bring about issues Such that someone generally needs to have the genetic predisposition for <mental_health_issue> in order for the bad parenting to surface it. In some cases the genetic predisposition is stronger such that we need less (or more) environmental influence to being about <issue> While it's not entirely incorrect to say that <environmental_factor> (such as parenting or cannabis) can bring about <issue>, its also misleading because we don't get the full picture of cause and effect And as such we have people who go around on the internet claiming they know the ~one true cause~ because they read some mischaracterized study reported on by <media_institution> Never listen to media institutions about singular scientific studies, the reporting is almost always entirely trash

wwwwewwww 5y ago

They do not. It's an old myth - the society used to blame schizophrenia on bad parents, especially mothers. This has no grounds in medical research.

smorgusofborg 5y ago
And now it is bad drugs.. AFAIK the argument against most environmental factors was that schizophrenia frequency seems similar globally after accounting for ways societies handle cases. Given the ethical limitations on this kind of research, I think a research group that wants to talk about probable causation really needs a cross cultural method to randomly sample and demonstrate active case prevalence changes and to run that sampling over many years.

therealcamino 5y ago

You could find textbooks from the 50's maybe. It's been discredited for a long time.

astura 5y ago

It's the old "Refrigerator mother theory" that's been largely discredited. Back from when autism was known as "childhood schizophrenia." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator_mother_theory