7 ms·
I strongly disagree. Google wants us to use its services because at its core is a bunch of engineers that simply want to make the world better.
by breck 15y ago
I strongly disagree. Google wants us to use its services because at its core is a bunch of engineers that simply want to make the world better.
- jey 15y agoWhat Google "wants" as an entity is different from what the individual component humans want. (i.e. the agent 'Google' is distinct from the agents that it is composed of)
- abraham 15y agoGoogle is strongly guided by the agents that shepherd it.
- blub 15y agoYou mean agents like Eric Schmidt, that declare online privacy as dead?
- abraham 15y agoOnline privacy never existed. If it is online it can be leaked, stolen, or shared.
- vladd 15y agoAre you aware that several Googlers resigned after a petition signed by 10% of the entire engineering workforce was ignored by management? See https://plus.google.com/100010618263697835406/posts/azTW8hvw7fx#100010618263697835406/posts/azTW8hvw7fx https://plus.google.com/100010618263697835406/posts/azTW8hvw... for details.
- jrockway 15y agoWould your complaint sound strange if it was worded, "Are you aware that several Googlers resigned after a petition ignored by 90% of the workforce was ignored by management?" Ultimately, some policy on some random social networking site nobody uses is not much of a big deal. If you don't like the policy, don't use Google+. Easy.
- abraham 15y ago"It seems that the G+ team is currently overwhelmed with technical issues of the current system -- that, combined with Vic's attitude, means that nymwars is not going to be addressed anytime soon. If engineers can scrape together 20% time to implement possible solutions and manage to convince decision-makers to let them roll out changes, we might see something." It sounds less like it was ignored and more like it isn't a priority for a resource stretched team.
- danssig 15y agoPeople still believe in a benevolent google after the App Engine scandal? Let me ask you something; what would Google have to do before you finally believe they're just a publicly traded company?
- abraham 15y agoThe App Engine pricing issues are anything but a scandal.
- danssig 15y agoReally? Getting a bunch of developers locked into a platform and then raising prices sometimes 100 times more than it was? What would they have to do for it to be a scandal for you? If Apple suddenly came out and said "right, from today on we want 75% of your sales instead of 30%" would you have the same reaction?
- abraham 15y agoTerrible comparison. A dick move maybe but not a scandal. Google App Engine: * Not the dominant hosting platform. Not even close to being the dominant. * Maybe a million dollar product. Certainly not a billion dollar product. * In beta/preview until just now with developers knowing pricing had not been set or could be changed. * Optimizing your application properly can negate most if not all of the pricing increase. * Open source alternative framework available if you want to keep using the same APIs. Apple App Store: * Dominant market position with only the Android Market coming close. * Billion dollar product. * Existed as fully launched for several years. * Set percentage. You can't change it other then making your app free. * No open source alternative that supports the same APIs. Beta/preview products can and will change.
- throwaway32 15y agothe first motivation of any for profit corporation, especially one as large and successful as Google, is profit. That is their entire reason for existence, don't fool yourself into believing otherwise.
- joelhaus 15y agoThere is a lot of truth in this, but what impresses me most about Google is the way they have aligned their business model with their users interests and how that has enabled them to sacrifice short-term gains for long-term profits... it's a very Buffett-esque strategy that is difficult to pull-off.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jorangreef 15y agoMany people try to earn profit, but the best way to earn profit is to seek to serve. Profit is a result, not a goal. Service is a goal, the result of which is profit. Get your motivation right and the methods will follow.
- haberman 15y agoPeople like to say this, maybe believing it fulfills some deep-seated need for cynicism, or makes the speaker feel wise and worldly. But what is your actual argument in support of this? Just saying it does not make it true. If profit is the only motivation for decisions at Google, why did it pull out of China? I'm sure you're cynical and wise about that too, but here's what I can tell you. I saw Sergey up on stage saying the same things he said in this interview (http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/03/22/interview-sergey-brin-on-googles-china-gambit/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/03/22/interview-sergey-br...) and he got fiery and emotional about it. This is a guy who grew up in the Soviet Union until he was 6 and for him it is a very personal and ideological issue. This corporations-as-profit-seeking-automata meme is old and tired. At the end of the day it's people who make decisions, and just as in every aspect of life people can have complex motivations for the decisions that they make.
- nutjob123 15y agoI can't tell if this is sarcastic or not.
- sbochins 15y agoI saw a documentary about advertising agencies. They interviewed someone working at the marketing division of nike. She said her job was to get people to play sports. That of course is not true. Her job is to get people to buy shoes. I think your comment is misguided as well. Google really just wants people to click on ads.
- icandoitbetter 15y agoYes, Google wants to make more money. No question about it. But why are you so eager to reject any other possible motivation just because profit-making is involved? There is satisfaction in making the world a better place; why wouldn't Sergey & Larry want to get that satisfaction?
- nazar 15y agoExactly! I can't agree more on that. I can get a job which will give me trise as much as I make now with my startup+freelance jobs. But that wouldnt give me satisfaction. I suppose even seeing how people react on what you're up to on scale that Google operates has to be cool.
- sbochins 15y agoI was responding to this: "I strongly disagree. Google wants us to use its services because at its core is a bunch of engineers that simply want to make the world better." I don't doubt that the people working at google want to make the world better and work on cool software. I don't think that is the primary motivation of google as a company.
- danssig 15y agoWow, wtff? I don't understand how people can get so up in arms about Apple fanboys so long as google has fanboys like this. Are you serious or trolling? I would expect if someone had such an ignorant/naive opinion they would at least be smart enough to not let other people know. Here's what I see from google: Search - a product that helps them sell ads Gmail - a product that helps them sell ads Google App engine - A platform where they used the hype of MapReduce et al to get people to join and then ramped up pricing drastically after a lot of people had been on the service (a service for which switching away almost certainly means a big rewrite) for years Android - phone OS to help them sell ads. I'm not seeing a lot of "make the world better" in there. Unless you mean "for Google executives".