6 ms·
> in order to do what we want and protect our interests Letting everyone do things in their own self interest, unchecked, is rarely found in stable societies.
by nomel 5y ago
> in order to do what we want and protect our interests
Letting everyone do things in their own self interest, unchecked, is rarely found in stable societies. For example, one persons interest (getting music for free) may not align with another's (the starving artist's).
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThen stop making music for free. Find a way to get paid before you put the work in. Because after it's been made and published, it's already over. Computers exist and are networked. Data is trivially and infinitely copyable. The clock will not be rewound back to the dark ages where data was a finite product that people could buy and sell. No matter how much the music industry rages and sues, it won't change the fact that YouTube is just sending me data via HTTP and there's absolutely nothing they can do if I decide to redirect that data to my hard disk instead. It's up to them to adapt to their new reality. If they can't, that's their problem.
- Spivak 5y agoI mean eventually it’s gonna be YouTube only sends a DRM video stream and then the problem is done. Okay sure pirates will still exist but casual piracy got harder which is the point. DRM doesn’t try to put the genie back in the bottle, it only makes the path of least resistance going through legal channels.
- copperx 5y agoI'm actually surprised it hasn't happened yet. There must be some technical reason for that. Is Widevine problematic?
- spartanatreyu 5y agoIt would affect the people it's intended to be used on the least, and affect the people it's not intended to be used on the most.
- 5e92cb50239222b 5y agoYou're pretty much describing DRM in a nutshell. This limitation never stopped it in the past.
- dubiousconst281 5y agoWidevine is a joke, L3 at least. You can easily dump all video and audio frames by hooking into Chromium's CDM wrapper.
- easrng 5y agoAnd nobody cares about L2, and manufacturers have awful security and accidentally leak L1 keys all the time.
- bubblethink 5y agoThis is a good point. Yes, in theory chrome and android are big enough now that youtube could add widevine and there won't be a significant impact to their bottom line. Maybe there are still old devices that are running obsolete/frozen versions of youtube devices. Or more optimistically, there are still trace amounts of 'don't be evil' left at google.
- Aerroon 5y agoWouldn't they get sued for anticompetitive practices though? If other browsers/devices can't view the content then it seems like they would have a point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nomel 5y ago> Find a way to get paid before you put the work in. Do you have an industry/example in mind where this is the case? All of the "profit from something created" schemes that I can think of require that the something exists before it can be sold. I can't think of anything that's sold based purely on promises, without extreme risk being involved. And when this is the case, it seems there's some partial initial payment (and initial debt put on the creator of that something) to mitigate some of that risk, with complete payment after the thing is finished.
- 3np 5y agoCould also be read as “<Find a way to get paid> before you put the work in.” as opposed to “Find a way to <get paid before you put the work in.>” An employment would be one way. Demanding things on behalf of “starving artists” otherwise sounds exactly like the “starving FLOSS maintainer” who burns out because nobody will find their work. Unfortunate but it’s on them to find a sustainable business model if they want it as an income stream. A ban on general computing will not save either the artist nor the programmer.
- nomel 5y ago> An employment would be one way. How so? All employment arrangements I've been involved in paid based on time that was previously worked (like, paid monthly for previous month), with the pay being for the clear, partial, progress that is shown during that time that I worked. I've never been paid, in anywhere near full, for time I will work in the future, or progress I will make. I've never seen as employer that pays, in full, for to-be-completed work. This seems extremely risky. Do you have an example?
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Do you have an industry/example in mind where this is the case? Crowdfunding sites like Kickstarter where people treat creations as an investment. Patronage platforms like Patreon where people can support creators they like on a regular basis. Maybe that's the answer. Maybe not. I don't really know. I just know copyright is insane. > All of the "profit from something created" schemes that I can think of require that the something exists before it can be sold. That works for physical goods which are naturally scarce. Data is infinitely abundant. Supply is infinite. Price might as well be zero. The value is the labor that creates the data, not the data itself. The artists, the programmers, these people are valuable. There needs to be some way they can get paid for the act of creating rather than sales of the artificially scarce product of their labor. Because that artificial scarcity was dead the second computers were invented.
- atoav 5y agoThat's like finding users for your software before telling them why they would actually like to have it — nobody cares for your music before you release it unless your former albums have been real bangers. No record label in existence would give you any money before you prooved to them somehow that you are able to do the music you want them to finance you for. As a member of a band myself I don't care when people download our music, rather the opposite, I like it when people dig the music. And if they dig it enough, they will also buy a shirt, the vinyl, or something among those lines.
- nomel 5y ago> As a member of a band myself I don't care when people download our music I think the difference between me and some others in this thread is, I think you have the right to make that choice. I think you also have the same right to say, "I put effort into this, and I want to limit its distribution to only those that compensated me for it".
- glenda 5y agoExcept the RIAA isn’t a starving artist and the actual artists make practically nothing from streaming services - the starving artist’s needs are already compromised by large corporate interests.
- philipov 5y agoThe RIAA isn't protecting the interests of artists, either.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"Letting everyone do things in their own self interest, unchecked, is rarely found in stable societies." So far corporations has been pretty unchecked, maybe that's got something to do with political instability today.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. We, mere mortals, need to be checked but these corporations? No, they get to have hundreds of years of government-backed monopolies on numbers, they get to buy laws via lobbying, they get to spam us with advertising all day...
- 6510 5y agoEven more funny is the way the legal system was gamed so badly already and now the court must decide its own future use of youtube videos as evidence.
- inter_netuser 5y agomonopolies in numbers..?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYes. All data, all computer files, are fundamentally just numbers. Really big numbers. You can even figure out how big they are. decimal_digits = ceil(bits * log10(2)) A 10 KiB picture is a 24,661 digit number. A 2 GiB video file is a 5,171,655,946 digit number. It might take hard work and a ton of money to discover that number, but once it's known it can be trivially copied. Copyright is about creating artificial scarcity for numbers. That's how insane it is.
- jtbayly 5y agoCopyright is actually about making sure people have enough incentive to keep doing all that hard work of discovering cool new numbers.
- 2pEXgD0fZ5cF 5y ago> the starving artist The "starving" or small time artist is an excuse that is useful for corporations when they want to manipulate public opinion. No music label cares even the slightest bit about individual artists or their fair payment, they care about megahits and big sellers. If you want to support your favourite artist that isn't already a millionaire or multi-millionare paying for spotify isn't it. To actually support "starving artists" visit their shows, buy some merch (however even this isn't the case anymore for some) or look for independent artists on bandcamp (bandcamp takes 15% of a sold album). If all you do is pay for spotify or something like that you are not supporting a "starving artist" any more than someone downloading the songs, maybe even less because sharing the music on the right filesharing forums might at least lead to some of the sales (merch/concert) above. For anyone interested have a look at https://informationisbeautiful.net/2010/how-much-do-music-artists-earn-online/ https://informationisbeautiful.net/2010/how-much-do-music-ar... To add to that: Big labels hurt small time artists immensely. If you are an artist on youtube getting hit with a (false) copyright claim by a large label is a constant threat to you. It even happens to people with songs with millions of views [1]. We have reached a point where using certain chords or chord progression can get you stomped by music labels. Music labels are not in any way friends or allys to "starving artists", only to millionaire artists. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4AeoAWGJBw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4AeoAWGJBw
- mmis1000 5y agoProbably merch is most effective these days? You can download a mp3, but you are never able to download a T-shirt. But at same time, merch have higher entry gate. You are unlikely to buy a merch created for someone you don't really know. (Unless it is just good enough that you are willing to just use it like a general T-shirt...etc)
- robtherobber 5y agoPerforming has always (and should always, if you ask me) be the main avenue to make money for musicians. Music can be copied, can be covered, can be mixed etc. Chords can be guessed, copied and stolen. But the musician herself is irreplaceable. If you want to make money by making music, be sure to develop a relationship with your audience rather than police it in order to ensure you're getting paid.
- jevoten 5y agoBut they get music for free either way - Youtube and others are broadcasting it. And now they want the legal right to restrict us from recording those broadcasts, no different than stopping us from recording radio. They broadcast free of charge, and when we don't consume that broadcast in the manner they hoped, they use it to justify taking away our right to run software of our choosing. It's obscene.
- shmoopi 5y ago>Letting everyone do things in their own self interest, unchecked As in "freedom"? >is rarely found in stable societies As in most of the developed world?
- nomel 5y ago"unchecked" I'm sorry, but you don't have complete "freedom" to achieve your own self interests. I once knew someone who was very interested in a car stereo. Unfortunately for him, but fortunately for others who happened to own car stereos, that car stereo was in a car that belong to the police, and he definitely saw an even larger reduction in "freedom" after that.
- SantalBlush 5y agoIf it's truly the starving artist we're all worried about, then it should be fine to pirate an album and mail the artist a check for $25, right? Everyone here who cares about the starving artist is cool with that?