9 ms·
I always interpret new licenses through the lens of Debian's Free Software Guidelines.[0] I don't think this would be accepted as it limits usage. Besides that
by kstrauser 5y ago
I always interpret new licenses through the lens of Debian's Free Software Guidelines.[0] I don't think this would be accepted as it limits usage.
Besides that, the definition of a "small business" is terrible. A company is only eligible to use the software if they meet all of these conditions:
- had fewer than 100 total individuals working as employees and independent contractors at all times during the last tax year
- earned less than 1,000,000 USD (2019) total revenue in the last tax year
- received less than 1,000,000 USD (2019) total debt, equity, and other investment in the last five tax years, counting investment in predecessor companies that reorganized into, merged with, or spun out your company
1M USD in revenue is shockingly easy to cross. It also means that businesses in high cost of living areas will be excluded before ones in cheaper areas, even if they're otherwise identical.
It's an interesting idea, but I think it's a non-starter.
[0] https://people.debian.org/~bap/dfsg-faq.html https://people.debian.org/~bap/dfsg-faq.html
- echelon 5y agoI really like this license, but this stuck out to me too. The thresholds are wide apart, and like you say, easy to cross when still "poor". 100 total individuals is huge (you have HR and lawyers), but you can do $1M revenue (imagine it sans profit!) with a team of one or two. This doesn't allow for YoY inflation. $1M today won't be the same tomorrow. The license should expect to issue new versions frequently to keep up with the economic landscape. It'd also be nice if authors could customize their thresholds, but I suppose that gets into the complexity of Creative Commons. (Remember that? Where the heck did that disappear to? - you never hear about it anymore.)
- ForHackernews 5y ago> but you can do $1M revenue (imagine it sans profit!) Perhaps because you are paying for software that eats into your profit margins?
- JeffRosenberg 5y ago> This doesn't allow for YoY inflation. $1M today won't be the same tomorrow. The license should expect to issue new versions frequently to keep up with the economic landscape. That's addressed at the bottom of the definition of a small business: > Adjust these dollar figures for inflation according to the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics’ consumer price index for all urban consumers, United States city average, for all items, not seasonally adjusted, with 1982–1984=100 reference base.
- kstrauser 5y agoIt does actually account for inflation, at least for US users: > Adjust these dollar figures for inflation according to the United States Bureau of Labor Statistics’ consumer price index for all urban consumers, United States city average, for all items, not seasonally adjusted, with 1982–1984=100 reference base. If you're in a country with hyperinflation, sucks to be you. And that still doesn't account for the massive COL differences between, say, Mississippi and Hawaii (which is about 2.2x, according to https://usabynumbers.com/states-ranked-by-cost-of-living/ https://usabynumbers.com/states-ranked-by-cost-of-living/).
- derobert 5y agoThe amounts are in US dollars, so any local hyperinflation won't matter. Your local currency will be worth far fewer dollars. I didn't see if it says how to convert, as there are often multiple exchange rates, e.g., an official one that can't actually be used, a underground/black market one, and purchasing-power parity (PPP). I don't think use outside the rich, developed nations has really been considered.
- kemitchell 5y agoHave you seen a contract or other set of legal terms that does a good job of adjusting for inflation internationally?
- cmroanirgo 5y agoAlthough I know of many small businesses that would be very happy with $1M pa, there does seem to be an imbalance with the number of employees. You simply can't pay 100 people a salary and stay under $1M. Maybe 12 people, or $10M would be a better balance.
- kstrauser 5y agoYou're right. And even then, that $10M goes a lot further in Afghanistan than Switzerland.
- ralmidani 5y agoSomeone could hire an army of programmers in a lower COL area/country.
- HexDecOctBin 5y ago> You simply can't pay 100 people a salary and stay under $1M. Maybe 12 people, or $10M would be a better balance. As someone from a third-world country, I don't know whether to laugh or cry. I suspect that other than the hyper-inflated salaries in silicon valley, these metrics will be more than fair everywhere else.
- d3ckard 5y agoNope, one million is 10k a year per employee. That’s low even in Poland and definitely well, well below Polish IT, and Europe in general makes a fraction of SV salaries. Those numbers are a bad match.
- lostmsu 5y agoPoland is not a third world country though.
- micromacrofoot 5y agook now try India
- matkoniecz 5y ago
- 0xbadcafebee 5y agoNot to mention in companies that just acquire other companies, the parent company has a lot of revenue, but the sub-companies can be chronically cash-strapped. In big companies (and conglomerates) any given product does not draw from the total financial resources of the entire organization and its various revenue streams. A single megacorp product can have a 250K budget and generate 500K revenue, but they're not gonna get any more money for their product development just because the megacorp makes more money outside that product. And that revenue is probably just gonna get stolen by the megacorp to use somewhere else, the money doesn't go back into improving the first product. And what's the purpose of this license? Is it to generate revenue for the developer? If so, you want your terms to invite more liberal use by larger companies, as they may start using your project in more and more of their products which will net you more and more revenue. If it's too expensive for one of their products, it's too expensive for all of them. The best way to get a large company "hooked" on your project is to provide an initial term of free use, like 6 or 16 months, and to track use remotely via metrics gathering ("checking for upgradeable versions on start-up"). Once they've used it for free long enough, you go and ask (politely) for your money. If you price right, it'll be cheaper for them to pay you than to remove your project.
- Closi 5y agoI think someone wanting to use this licence may take a view of "megacorps should pay for my work regardless of their sub-company internal wooden-dollars accounting, so they shouldn't get out of using my open source efforts to make their rich stakeholders richer, although I don't mind helping some small indie team kickstart their business (and if they end up growing big, they will pay me anyway!)." Also the need for these style of licenses is shown by what happens when, for instance, AWS decides to just copy an open source project (that was put on a permissive open source license with the best of intentions) and then AWS just directly compete with the original maintainers/authors company.
- jabl 5y ago> I always interpret new licenses through the lens of Debian's Free Software Guidelines.[0] I don't think this would be accepted as it limits usage. This license doesn't claim it's an open source license. Apples and oranges.
- kstrauser 5y agoPerhaps, but what’s the point of discussing non-open source licenses here? Yet Another Commercial License isn’t interesting, even one that basically works out to be shareware.
- jabl 5y ago> Perhaps, but what’s the point of discussing non-open source licenses here? I guess that's up to discussion participants and moderators to decide, not you (or me) individually. If you're not interested, nobody is forcing you to participate in the discussion.
- lupire 5y agoThis is a software business website, not an open source website.
- tptacek 5y agoBecause lots of people here run commercial software businesses (our original name was "Startup News"). We discuss this for the same reason we discuss pricing pages and user metrics. Interesting articles about yet another commercial license are per se on topic for HN.
- kstrauser 5y agoIt's not that I thought it was off-topic, just that it seemed unusual to me. What's more common is when an existing product changes its license, and then HN is all over discussing the implications.
- quadrifoliate 5y agoGiven that this is a website run by a startup accelerator, articles about commercial licenses are arguably more on topic than ones about open source licenses. Successful commercial products with GPLed code are few and far in between.
- post-it 5y agoYou could have 100 part-time employees and contractors and be under $1M total revenue. Not common, but some kind of tutoring agency maybe. It doesn't hurt to cover all bases. The author thought of three qualities that would define a large business and AND'ed their negations to define a small business. It doesn't really matter if #2 almost always implies #1.
- jgeada 5y agoHow's that my problem? I don't owe you a profit! More, we don't owe you anything, the obligation at best runs the other direction. Users of open software are making use of work of others frequently without payment or any similar contribution to that work. At a certain scale, and that point can be defined in arbitrarily, your ability to free ride on the work of others ends. I don't how that is a controversial point.
- post-it 5y agoDid you reply to the wrong comment? I don't understand your response.
- mwcampbell 5y agoI think we need to be much more willing to consider software that's released with source available, but under a license that doesn't comply with the DFSG. (And yes, such software should be called something other than "open source".) Those guidelines aren't sacred, and neither is Stallman's definition of free software. Ever since I read _Hackers_ by Steven Levy a few years ago, I've been much less sympathetic toward Stallman, and the MIT AI Lab hackers in general. If you've read _Hackers_, recall that Stallman also strenuously opposed passwords. Well, it's absolutely clear now that restricting access to computers with passwords (or something equivalent) is absolutely necessary to defend against bad actors. So we should be open to the possibility that, while widespread sharing of source code is good, some kind of restriction on the usage of that code is necessary to protect the developers from freeloaders. I'm sure we haven't arrived at the best way to do this yet, but we won't get there if we immediately reject all attempts because they don't meet a definition of freedom that's perhaps too absolute for the real world.
- oliwarner 5y agoSeems like a strange attack against (eg) GPL. Stallman is completely odd, but GPL's aim has nothing to do with developers and everything to do with users: Let users know and control the software they're running on their computers. This is a real world issue, even if you don't think you need it. This does have varied ramifications for developers, but all designed to prevent a downstream removing rights for a user to access the code running. And that's great, irrespective of your or my views on the chap who instigated it all.
- alexvoda 5y agoThe way I see it, Stallman is an end user freedom maximalist with end user roughly meaning person sitting in front of a computer using software. Thinking like this, any obstacle blocking a user from complete control of the computation on the computer is evil. This of course completely disregards the notion of computers having owners. Unfortunately, we are currently way way in the other direction, with owners being deprived of control over owned devices by manufacturers and vendors.
- ralmidani 5y agoThe problem with absolutism: it ignores how trivial it is to copy and deploy a lot of modern programs. Condemning licenses which protect against juggernauts like Amazon leaves no middle ground between free software and proprietary software.
- kemitchell 5y agoLike most definitions in legal terms, the definition of "small business" in the license is functional and context-specific. It needn't be a good dictionary definition of "small business" for use elsewhere. Functionally, each of the prongs of Big Time's definition works as an independent tripwire. Cross one, the license no longer covers your business and you need to reach out for a deal. This approach, based on revenue, headcount, and capital, isn't unique to Big Time. It comes up in laws and regulations, as well. With all that in mind, I don't think it's important for the figures, read together, to add up to a single, consistent picture of any one hypothetical business. I don't think they need to be convincingly proportional. Rather, each needs to prevent "end runs" around the others. If you're running accounting losses but paying lots of people, you need to make a deal. If you're three founders in a garage who haven't even tried to charge any customers yet, but just raised $3m in venture capital, you need to do a deal.
- Closi 5y agoPeople are just questioning it because it seems like one of the 'tripwires' is a significantly higher barrier. Like if I said "I will give you £100 if you either give me a high-five, or if you punch yourself in the face until you bleed", they are independent tripwires but you might ask why the second was included.
- torstenvl 5y agoI'm not an accountant but my understanding of "revenue" as a figure is not impacted by accounting losses. Wouldn't you have to be running the entire company on debt for this to be possible? And if so, what is the point of trying to get money from them?
- dugmartin 5y agoI think the author is very confused between revenue and profit. A convenience store sitting on Any Steet, USA does around $1,600,000 in revenue per year (https://www.statista.com/statistics/308780/in-store-sales-per-convenience-store-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/308780/in-store-sales-pe...). But they have a 2% profit margin, much like grocery stores, so that $1.6M really means $32k.
- kemitchell 5y agoThe choice between revenue and profit was well considered. Revenue does not account for expenses. But neither does it yield to Hollywood Accounting and the like. The purpose of the small business definition in the license is to isolate and waive through truly fledgling businesses. The assumption is very much that the licensor will also offer paid terms. So falling outside the free license isn't the end. It's just a redirection to a negotiation, with assurances of fairness and nondiscrimination.
- torstenvl 5y agoThat's what jumped out at me as well. If you have 99 full time employees and $999,999.00 in total revenue, you are violating labor laws somewhere, guaranteed.
- ryukoposting 5y agoI think the easiest solution to this problem is to scratch the $1,000,000 thresholds entirely. Just say that any corporation based in Delaware has to pay for a license, and everyone else can use it for free.
- Doctor_Fegg 5y agoAmazon EU SarL likes your suggestion.
- bux93 5y agoInteresting to contrast with this is the EU's definitions of small and medium enterprises. https://ec.europa.eu/growth/smes/sme-definition_en https://ec.europa.eu/growth/smes/sme-definition_en A headcount lower than 50, turnover or balance sheet under 10 million qualifies you as a small business.
- user-the-name 5y ago> I always interpret new licenses through the lens of Debian's Free Software Guidelines. Why?