5 ms·
White House will meet execs from Apple, Amazon, IBM to discuss software security
- notananthem 5y agoI love how Microsoft is a footnote but they put Amazon in the headline.. for software security.
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- olliej 5y agoBut no one from Apache, and no one from any of the other major OSS projects
- dariusj18 5y agoPeople form Apple and IBM are members of the Apache Software Foundation. Thought I am not sure if executive level has any members.
- cbsks 5y agoDid you find the full list of attendees? I haven’t been able to
- mikeyouse 5y agoIt's coming out in drips and drabs; https://twitter.com/cra/status/1481677285325422592 https://twitter.com/cra/status/1481677285325422592 "ASF was represented by the current President, a board member, and the VP Security" "from LF it was the @theopenssf leadership led by @brianbehlendorf"
- ghaff 5y agoApache is apparently included. https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/13/22881813/white-house-tech-summit-apple-google-meta-amazon-open-source-security https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/13/22881813/white-house-tech... Someone on twitter said Linux Foundation as well.
- mikeyouse 5y agoIt's in that verge article; "The summit will also include the Apache Software Foundation — the owner and maintainer of the Log4j library — and Oracle, owner of the Java software platform on which the Log4j library runs. GitHub and the Linux Open Source Foundation will also be represented." Which makes sense -- they host the Open Source Security Foundation (https://openssf.org/ https://openssf.org/) which is meant to be working on exactly this type of problem.
- mikesabbagh 5y agoWhen I hear this, I start thinking, are they getting called because of too much security?
- pvarangot 5y agoNot to this meeting. This meeting is the circus act where the government subtly (or sometimes not so subtly) tells them they are really worried about security and they are thinking about enacting draconian laws where they are basically responsible each time a user get phished, and where they have to pay hefty fines to the government each time there's a data leaks. Then there's the meetings that are not advertised where they ask them to make the devices less secure so that the government can spy on everyone. This has been going on for more than five years already. Of course the consequences of this are that everyone that has any power to decide anything on any of this companies treats the federal government as bunch of senile deranged lunatics so the only possible way to work with them is try to make them feel they are still relevant and not upset them.
- commandlinefan 5y agoWhat in God's name would any execs from those or any other company realistically be able to share about software security?
- dekhn 5y agoGiven that the first two represent an enormous amount of the overall compute use (mac computers, aws cloud machines) and their surface areas are directly related to our national defense, I think they'd be able to share a fair amount.
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoNo argument that they have the experience and knowledge within their organizations. I think OP was expressing doubt that "execs" will be informed enough to deliver actionable insights.
- dekhn 5y agoOP would be wrong, then. The execs those companies send will be a combination of politically brilliant and technically knowledgeable. I've worked with a wide range of execs across several fields now and many of them are truly exceptional people with deeper understanding of their business's low level details than you'd expect.
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoOP may be wrong or may not be. It is certainly not a rule that all executives are as you describe and there is no shortage of anecdotes to oppose yours.
- adhesive_wombat 5y agoI think the point was that executives won't have enough technical knowledge to be able to say much about it except in extremely vague terms like "we take security seriously". In fact, actually having too much of a clue is a probably more of a liability when you're summoned to a meeting at the White House, as you might say something they'll hold you to.
- ape4 5y agoI would hope there is more government - industry communication than this.
- kerneloftruth 5y agoThe White House seems laser focused on issues that are not that important to most people. Yes, "cyber security" is always relevant -- but what is accomplished by a high-profile photo op meeting like this? What does the White House/Executive branch really have to offer? Next week, is there going to be a high-profile meeting with cereal makers to discuss nutrition? I mean, that's important too I guess...
- darkwizard42 5y agoNormally my response here would be, "the government is doing a lot of things and focus here doesn't mean no focus on the other issues" but lately I'm wondering what they are actually doing about the meaningful "everyday" problems (in quotes because cyber security is an every day/all day problem, but doesn't feel like the forefront of the issues the average American faces today). For instance, pushing for big tech anti-trust legislation when cable companies and telcos are just sitting around providing awful service and regularly breaking their promises for coverage and quality. No focus on improving housing affordability or pressure on state/local governments on solutions. Everyone just turns up their nose until the housing demand squeezes their backyard supply. Generally very frustrating to see and I don't have confidence that either party is equipped to solve this so I'm not optimistic about post-2022 elections.
- buscoquadnary 5y agoCyber Security I would argue falls under a national defense issue, as a foreign power being able to take control of Industrial and Control systems would likely cause the issue to jump to the top of many Americans concerns if their power or water shut off. Generally I agree with you and am critical of a lot of the cirucs around it but, this is one of the areas I would argue the White House as Commander in Chief should actually be involved in.
- newaccount2021 5y ago
- mikewarot 5y agoI predict the principle of least privilege will appear in the conversation zero times, along with zero instances of seL4, microkernels. Also absent will be any suggestion that the NSA be directed to actually help secure our nations computers in a meaningful way. It is up to us to fix things. We need to get familiar with microkernels, confused deputies, and all the other lessons that go along with the topic. If we continue insisting that everything will be fine if we just rewrite it in Rust, or make updates smoother, we'll lose the war for general purpose computing. [Edit] I believe it is completely possible to have usable and secure computing, but only if we use capability based security, which Windows and Linux don't, and can never support.
- lazyeye 5y agoI predict it will be "we'll do what we can about security, now what can you do about further opening up immigration...". Apparently this was their primary concern when they had that meeting with Trump.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- buscoquadnary 5y agoHonestly I am really concerned that eventually open computing and the days of a couple of college kids in a garage building a product that turns into a multi-million dollar success, are going to disappear under the guise of security. I know security is important and I do want companies to do better, but where do we end up if we eventually require that all software that can be run has to be signed by some authority that has vetted it, and you can't run XYZ on your machine because it hasn't gone through the right clearance hoops etc, etc, and I understand that won't be the purpose. But my journey started when I had an old HP that had windows ME on it that barely worked so I ripped it off and installed Ubuntu because I heard from a family friend it would run better, doing that eventually led to a successful long career in computing. I think now about how easy it would now be to move from "you have to disable UEFI Secure Boot option" I went through to get Linux on my latest laptop to "This hardware security chip has detected an unsigned OS attempting to load and will now terminate." I worry as we continue to lock down things in the name of "security" and make them mandatory, as often happens once the government gets involved will eventually lead to crushing the hacking spirit and kill the joy of computing. On the other hand maybe I am just waxing nostalgic about a pass that never existed that is telling kids to get off my lawn and about how everyone wore an onion on their belt.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoBecause I'm sure this is going to lead to security for the people and definitely for sure not pushes for more avenues for mass surveillance...
- LegitShady 5y agoWhen these people get together I cannot imagine anything good for regular people coming from it.
- dang 5y agoOk, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here. Especially not dyspeptic ones. It makes for worse discussion.
- Syonyk 5y agoPredictions: - If it's even mentioned (hopefully, given log4j topics), nobody will concretely commit to anything that would look like "funding those open source projects we all use internally, rely on, and just assume will be fine." Or putting serious resources to fuzzing, analyzing, and generally beating the hell out of packages like that, committing any fixes back upstream. - Nobody will be willing to consider that the reason we're in this spot is because we've spent all our effort on complexity and new features instead of actually locking down and making bulletproof a smaller set of features. To borrow from Apple's recent issues as discussed in Project Zero's writings [0], I'm sure your support for an obscure Xerox compression algorithm was used never, or nearly so, in practice (in text messages!). However, your inclusion of it allowed a nice entry point for some absolutely nasty software. Perhaps, instead of supporting every format under the sun you can find, you can support the common ones only, and lock those down. No, instead, we can convert our facial expressions into animated animals and send them to people (I'm not sure I want to know how many weird corner cases that code has). - Nothing will change, ransomware will continue, reporters trying to shine light on questionable countries will continue having their phones/laptops/watches/etc hacked to hell and back, and we'll continue stumbling forward in the complexity canyon that swallows everything that gets near it. We could make major security improvements if we were willing to say, "Let's focus on the 20% of the features that make up 80% of the use, and turn the rest off by default." Simplify the software drastically, which then means we can simplify the hardware because performance isn't as critical. But the tech industry's internal structures are absolutely opposed to this - you're promoted for shipping new features, not maintaining things, and not doing weird low level security analysis and fuzzing. I'm pretty damned pessimistic about the state of computer security, if it's not obvious. [0]: https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2021/12/a-deep-dive-into-nso-zero-click.html https://googleprojectzero.blogspot.com/2021/12/a-deep-dive-i...
- mikeyouse 5y agoJust to try and clean up the attendee list since each article has a slightly different list: Apache Software Foundation (ASF was represented by the current President, a board member, and the VP Security https://twitter.com/abayer/status/1481676645891256320 https://twitter.com/abayer/status/1481676645891256320) Linux Foundation (LF it was the @theopenssf leadership led by @brianbehlendorf https://twitter.com/cra/status/1481677285325422592 https://twitter.com/cra/status/1481677285325422592) Akamai Alphabet Amazon Apple Cloudflare GitHub IBM Meta Oracle VMWare "Feds attending include representatives from the departments of Commerce, Defense, Energy and Homeland Security, as well as agencies like the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, the National Science Foundation, the Office of the National Cyber Director and the Office of Science and Technology Policy."
- sys_64738 5y agoIBM?
- gnabgib 5y agoStrange title, especially the cherry picked companies (by Reuters, not OP). Full list from the article: Alphabet/Google Amazon Apple DHS DoD IBM Meta/Facebook Microsoft Oracle So all the major clouds, all the major desktop OS companies, all the major mobile OS companies. "from major tech companies" seems more reasonable.