6 ms·
I the power level of these engines is difficult to comprehend. The fuel pump has thousands of horsepower. Compare this to the fuel pump on a car engine, which i
by HPsquared 5y ago
I the power level of these engines is difficult to comprehend. The fuel pump has thousands of horsepower. Compare this to the fuel pump on a car engine, which is a tiny little electric thing. The combustion power must be in the gigawatt range.
Edit: the SSME high pressure fuel pump turbine produces 63000 hp (46 MW). There's also one for the oxygen, and a pair of low pressure pumps as well. Crazy...
Edit edit: the fuel pump transfers 155 lb/sec of liquid hydrogen. If fully combusted (142 MJ/kg), that would release 10.0 GW of heat per engine.
- 7952 5y agoSaturn V at take off had an equivalent power of 166GW. If that was electricity it would be around 2x the total capacity of all the power stations in the UK.
- Kye 5y agoI wonder if anyone's experimented with using rockets to charge something like a flywheel battery or reservoir for hydro power. A 777's engine puts out tens of megawatts using a less refined fuel than rockets use. What if you hooked a rocket full of RP-1 to a pump to haul water from a river to a dam? This is probably nonsense.
- adewinter 5y agoYou should keep in mind that, sure, the rocket produces 166GW of power(which is wild!) but it does so for all of 5 minutes (or less). Whereas "all the power stations in the UK" keep on trucking, day in, day out, year after year.
- 7952 5y agoA 777 engine is actually far more fuel efficient than a rocket engine. Take a look at specific impulse [0] for different engine types. A rocket is optimised to be very light and to use its own oxygen supply. A normal jet engine can be heavier and use the air as an oxidizer. Much more efficient for power production in a CCGT.
- pfdietz 5y agoRocket engines are actually very efficient, especially in vacuum. Very high expansion ratios can be achieved that converts almost all the heat into jet kinetic energy.
- HPsquared 5y agoTo nit-pick, that's comparing heat production with electrical power. If we assume the power stations are 50% thermally efficient (which is a bit optimistic) the power in "heat" terms of the power grid would then be about the same as the Saturn V.
- pfdietz 5y agoRocket engines are extremely efficient. Especially in vacuum, they can convert almost all the heat into kinetic energy of the exhaust jet. They're the most efficient heat engines we have.
- post_break 5y agoReminds me of fuel injectors of funny cars. Watch it go from just idling, to full throttle. Then remember there's 8 of them on the engine. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGTbQuhhluY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGTbQuhhluY
- jcims 5y agoTop Fuel copypasta - https://wediditforlove.com/techtalk21.html https://wediditforlove.com/techtalk21.html
- refurb 5y agoI got to stand next to one of these dragsters during a launch and suffice to say it was rocket like.
- post_break 5y agoI got pretty close to the jet powered big rig in norwalk. It blew the flags off the sign and then the sign eventually fell over. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBdvooWanJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBdvooWanJw Seems like it happens often.
- skykooler 5y agoThis is why electric turbopumps (like those used on RocketLab's Electron rocket) don't scale up to larger rockets well - the power draw is just infeasible to support with current battery technology.
- Robotbeat 5y agoNot quite. Electric pumps scale just fine (that is, linearly), but turbopumps scale better. It's hard to build a very small turbopump but not much harder to build a larger one, and turbopumps improve in efficiency as they get larger. BTW, the largest electropump (4 times that of RocketLab’s Rutherford electropump engine) for a rocket engine is the electropump for the 100kN (10 ton) thrust rocket engine for the reusable crewed suborbital Spica space rocket by the volunteer-run Copenhagen Suborbitals group, which more people ought to know about: https://twitter.com/CopSub/status/1468280164404666373?s=20 https://twitter.com/CopSub/status/1468280164404666373?s=20
- sephamorr 5y agoThe major issue is the energy storage, not the power plant itself. The penalty of the battery mass scales far worse than a tank holding very energy dense rocket propellant.
- Robotbeat 5y agoAgain, the energy storage scales just fine: linearly. Rocket propellant tends to scale better than linear, but it is not in every case better than lithium ion batteries! For example, the R7/Soyuz rocket family is the most-launched orbital rocket ever, and it uses a hydrogen peroxide gas generator to drive the turbopump. That has a concentration of 82.5% peroxide. Pure peroxide has a heat of decomposition of 2.84MJ/kg, and turbine that is typically 30% efficient (actually, it might be much less than that… I think the V-2 turbine was only like 10% efficient, maybe worse… so 30% is optimistic) gives you a usable energy density of only 700kJ/kg, or about 194Wh/kg. The best lithium batteries available are about twice that, up to 400-500Wh/kg (with those in the lab even better still), and electric motors can have 90-95% efficiency. And gas generators using main propellants are better, certainly, but less than you might think because they have to haul all their oxidizer with them (unlike aircraft) and are also usually run very far from stoichiometric (maybe just 0.3 O:F ratio compared to a stoichiometric 3.4) to keep the temperature down. So unless you have a pretty high temperature turbine, you might not beat peroxide by much! So the easiest gas generators have worse energy density (keep in mind RocketLab does stage off batteries if necessary…), and the next easiest, while better, aren’t MASSIVELY better without careful efficiency improvements. The real efficiencies come when you use like an expander cycle or a staged combustion cycle or you feed the gas generator exhaust back into the nozzle like Merlin Vacuum or F-1. And those are all much more complicated. A level of complication that is not worth it for small rockets but is for larger. So it’s really not about electric scaling poorly (electric scales just fine) but about the greater complexity of better engine cycles being worth it at larger scales.
- beerandt 5y agoAnd then on top of it all, throttling ability. People don't grasp what an unbelievably complex engineering problem that is. It's at least an addition of difficulty at the same magnitude as building a steady-state 63000 hp turbine pump in the first place. Mechanically implementing it in the inherently steady-state design rocket of most rocket cycles. Having variable controls able to work at those pressures. Testing structural dynamics for a range of harmonic conditions instead of one. And do all of that with materials that need to tolerate temperatures going from cryogenic to white hot, without allowing thermal expansion to affect the mechanical tolerances of parts running at thousands of RPMs. And now you have varying flow rates and negative pressures in the lines coming from the external tanks, so have to design such that cryogenic liquids (that normally would require immense positive pressure to keep liquid) don't spontaneously boil or cavitate or cause a shock-like wave (think water hammer turning off your bath faucet) under changing negative pressures. It's really difficult even for seasoned engineers to grasp the scale of difficulty involved.
- LeifCarrotson 5y agoAppreciation of engineers for the difficulty of an assignment like this seems bimodal. On the one hand, you have https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/ responses: > You're trying to predict the behavior of <complicated system>? Just model it as a <simple object>, and then add some secondary terms to account for <complications I just thought of>. Easy, right? So, why does <your field> need a whole journal, anyway? Just pressurize the tanks, and meter the flow with some valves. Easy, right? They move to the other side of the distribution after a little more thought, when they they realize it's simply infeasible to put thousands of horsepower in a pump that size, and declare the whole endeavor completely nonsensical and impossible. Ran through this on a recent project involving an automated sewing machine. At first, it seems ludicrous that you could tie knots thousands of times per second. Oh wait, it's a single motor and old cam-driven tech from the 1800s, available off the shelf for a couple hundred dollars?
- avmich 5y agoThey also move to the "simple" side as well. The phrase "the rocket science is not a rocket science" has reasons to exist.
- kragen 5y agoYeah, it's pretty amazing. Doing this in a controlled fashion is the hard part; a largish wooden building on fire can also dissipate 10 GW. A .22 LR rifle bullet might acquire 200 J in 2 ms, which means the firing gun is producing 100 kW mechanical, plus probably another 300 kW thermal. So another way of thinking of this is that an engine dissipating 10 GW is equivalent to something like 25000 handguns firing at once, without ever stopping.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoThe turbopumps on the Saturn V first stage make about the same power as an aircraft carrier, over 200MW. Civilian electric power plants that make this much power are called "medium sized" and can power about 100,000 homes. That's not the power output of the rocket (which someone quoted below). That's the power required to move the fuel and oxidizer into the rocket engines. Pumping the same amount of liquid can move a 100,000 ton floating city across the ocean at 40mph.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoI shouldn't say the same amount of liquid, rather the same effort to pump water. As I understand it, a huge factor in the power requirement of the pumps is raising the pressure to the required level which is very high (combustion chamber pressure might be hundreds of atmospheres).