3 ms·
Well, unless people get a viable theory explaining why the thing that is 80% of the Universe is missing on an entire galaxy, it challenges dark matter theories
by marcosdumay 5y ago
Well, unless people get a viable theory explaining why the thing that is 80% of the Universe is missing on an entire galaxy, it challenges dark matter theories too.
They are just some not very well known bodies that may challenge all of our assumptions, or may fall in line with our theories once we get to know more about them. What is well, the best you can expect from new observations.
- ericbarrett 5y agoIn fact it's evidence for dark matter, as we can now point to areas of space where we see it and areas where we don't; and baryons and leptons in those spaces behave as expected in the presence or absence of something with mass that doesn't otherwise interact, which is all that "dark matter" is as a broad theory.
- Koshkin 5y agoA galaxy is small compared to the Universe, so why would it be difficult to imagine that some of the galaxies were formed in regions devoid of dark matter?
- marcosdumay 5y agoBecause cosmology has a lot of evidence that the clusters of mater we have around were created by gravity alone, and gravity acts the same way on normal matter and dark matter. And if you expect a difference on particle genesis at the beginning of the Universe, it would be a major kind of anisotropy that is against much more than just the cosmology theories. Why is it so hard to accept that we may have no good theory for explaining a galaxy without dark matter?
- Koshkin 5y agoDark matter is not required for the formation of a galaxy, so amongst trillions of galaxies there may be some that have none inside them?
- vba616 5y agoBy "challenges dark matter theories" do you mean "challenges the theory that there is dark matter" or "challenges theories of how dark matter originated and is distributed"?
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, those come together, don't they. Postulating dark matter without any coherent behavior is easy, but useless. It has to behave like something.
- 8note 5y agoA useful prediction for dark matter theories is that there can exist galaxies that don't have much dark matter. It doesn't have to behave like visible matter to behave in a specified manner. It's defined by interacting with gravity and not electromagnetism.