7 ms·
PUBG Game maker says Apple, Google selling rip-offs in new lawsuit
- dleslie 5y agoIt's sort of commonly accepted in the Game Industry that there exists an insurmountable proliferation of asset rips on mobile stores, and that there is an apparent total acceptance and tolerance of them by Google and Apple. So I'm not surprised to see such a lawsuit. > According to Krafton, Apple and Google have distributed hundreds of millions of copies of the Free Fire games. The complaint says Garena generated more than $100 million in revenue from Free Fire sales in the U.S. in the first three months of 2021. Right right, that's unexpected. Edit: I meant 'expected'. > Krafton also named Google's YouTube as a defendant for allegedly hosting videos of Free Fire gameplay, as well as a Chinese film that Krafton says is a live-action dramatization of its game. But this? This is something interesting. Last I heard of someone going after YouTube videos of gameplay was the raucous Nintendo made a few years back when they were sending DMCA takedowns to Streamers and YouTubers who featured gameplay of first-party Nintendo games. I don't recall those ever really going anywhere in court? Going after a film maker for making a live-action dramatization of a game that features asset rips of another game seems ... A bit of a stretch. Presumably, the live-action dramatization includes no copyrighted assets and doesn't infringe upon any protected trademarks; and so is Krafton alleging that the live-action film features facsimiles of virtual assets that violate copyright?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Presumably, the live-action dramatization includes no copyrighted assets A derivative work of a derivative work is still a derivative work, and if the first derivative is unlicensed and thus a copyright violation...
- keleftheriou 5y agoI think you mean ‘expected’, instead of ‘unexpected’ there?
- dleslie 5y agoYes, sorry.
- charcircuit 5y agoUploading / streaming gameplay in most cases is copyright infringement that is ignored by the rightsholders. Only a very small number of games' licenses give you permission to do so and usually you aren't allowed to do so for commercial use (think pay wall), but they do allow things like ads as an exception.
- bydlocoder 5y agoIt's interesting how there exists a huge market based on what is in fact copyright infringement. And the biggest player on this market is a legit publicly traded company. Thankfully, game developers understand that it doesn't make sense to try and shut down Twitch and/or individual streamers.
- gpm 5y agoI suspect this is a largely incorrect legal take as far as US law goes, though if you have a court case supporting you I'm open to being proven wrong. My not at all a lawyer reading is that streaming video games is almost always a classic example of fair use and thus not copyright infringement in the first place. Fair use is evaluated as a balancing act of 4 factors, and streaming is very favorable under 3 of them: It's transformative, adding something new to the original work and not superseding it at all (factor 1), it reproduces a small fraction of the whole of the work - only renders of the final work not the models behind it, none of the code, only the fraction of the artwork that is interacted with and even then only in one of many possible renderings of it (factor 3), it doesn't compete with the original work in the market place (factor 4). The only thing that really ways against it is that the original work was very artistic in nature (not something like a recording of JFK getting shot, mainly of interest for it's factual content... actual example from a court case).
- charcircuit 5y ago>It's transformative, adding something new to the original work and not superseding it at all A let's play is not transformative. You are literally experiencing the game as it was meant to be experienced. Similarly it's not transformative to put a song on in the background of a stream. (Video game music is copyrighted too ;)) For it to be transformative the game needs to be transformed into something else. >it reproduces a small fraction of the whole of the work - only renders of the final work not the models behind it, none of the code, only the fraction of the artwork that is interacted with and even then only in one of many possible renderings of it There are plenty of let's plays which play through a whole game. In terms of fair use you could for example illustrate what a boss looks like when talking about it by showing a screenshot of a game. Using your idea of what partial means you could watch a whole movie. It's not like by watching a movie you get access to the raw audio and video clips, or the projet files used to edit it. You don't get the 3D models they used to make CGI. >it doesn't compete with the original work in the market place For some linear story based games you could make the point that it does compte because you can experience the whole story without needing to purchase the original.
- keleftheriou 5y ago> Krafton said it asked Garena, Apple, and Google to stop selling the Free Fire games in December to no avail.
- spullara 5y agoIf they directly stole copyrighted assets you could just send a DMCA request to have it taken down. They didn't do that so this is all probably frivolous.
- halpert 5y agoBut what about the profit that has already been made? Apple is taking 30% after all.
- spullara 5y agoIf they aren't copyright infringing, then the profit is theirs. I don't think that any assets were directly stolen, and these games just look and play like PUBG.
- bagels 5y agoThat's only one remedy available, this is another one.
- chrisdotbiz 5y agoSay goodbye to that free App Store promotion. Honestly PUBG was all the App Store was pushing when they pulled Fortnite.
- PinkMilkshake 5y agoThis isn't the first time they've tried this. They attempted a copyright lawsuit against Epic for Fortnite when it came out. I don't recall all the details but I remember them implying that they owned the battle royal concept. https://www.theverge.com/2018/6/27/17509114/pubg-fortnite-lawsuit-copyright-dropped https://www.theverge.com/2018/6/27/17509114/pubg-fortnite-la...
- GekkePrutser 5y agoWouldn't this fall under software patents? Not sure about the US but it's not a thing in Europe. I don't think copyright applies unless code was actually copied. But IANAL.
- dralley 5y agoYeah but Fortnite wasn't copying the design of entire maps. https://i.ytimg.com/vi/mdKpGBRrAcA/sddefault.jpg https://i.ytimg.com/vi/mdKpGBRrAcA/sddefault.jpg
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoThe pro-IP crowd has officially become self-parody if you guys are passing that around as a "copy."
- asadlionpk 5y agoHow is that a copy? I don't see it.
- rasz 5y agoThey are both islands, duh! Nobody came up with this concept before!!7! other than all the things PUBG copied when its creator pivoted from copying Zombie games (in DayZ).
- Jon_Lowtek 5y agothe island map is a direct homage to the -korean- japanese novel/movie "Battle Royal" https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/57/Battle_royale_novel_map.JPG https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/5/57/Battle_royale... note that the original had no smaller island connected by two bridges, a detail which Garenas version inherited from PlayerUnknowns.
- jwitthuhn 5y agoInteresting that this appears to be about copying specific game mechanics, not something like game assets or code. Based on the screenshots they provide on page 43+ it does look like Free Fire is pretty clearly aping PUBG's aesthetic and mechanics, but I'm not sure that is copyright infringement. https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/dwvkrkjdlpm/IP%20PUBG%20COPYRIGHT%20complaint-min.pdf https://fingfx.thomsonreuters.com/gfx/legaldocs/dwvkrkjdlpm/... Interested to see where this goes.
- ksec 5y agoYes, this is different than bringing other Battle Royale like games to court. It clearly is a rip off. And Google and Apple clearly benefited from it. And this is interesting because Apple likes to compare it's App Store and Games Distribution to console. ( To the point they included PS5 and Xbox as direct competitor in their recent quarterly report ) Which is only true on the surface, but in reality console maker have much stricter guidelines in releasing games where something like this wouldn't have happened.
- fastball 5y agoBeing a "rip off" is not disallowed by our legal system though.
- dathinab 5y agoIt can be illegal depending on some factors. Like there are things like design patents or even "normal" parents which might be violated. Some countries also have laws which make a rip off by itself illegal if it's too similar (oversimplified).
- nekcihc 5y agoNone of that applies to software - they are not Gucci bags.
- 5y ago
- superkuh 5y agoEpic sells the most obvious rip-off of PUBG. Fortnite's battle royale mode was a direct copy and directly inspired by PUBG making a wildly popular game in Epic's engine. Epic then used their position in the market ($$$$$$$) to effectively buy out PUBG's playerbase. It's not even controversial that they did this. But I guess it's all just history now. I do wonder why they're going after Apple and Google's app stores when a case against Epic and it's app store behavior is far more clear.
- bydlocoder 5y agoIt's common practice in game industry, each successful breakthrough game spawns clones of various quality. Doom spawned tons of first-person shooters, WarCraft spawned tons of real-time strategies etc.
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoYep and if the IP-warriors had their way there would be no Halo, no Everquest/Wow, etc. Its just incredible how these people back the most corrupt corporation's laziest IP theft claims and jump to defend them and mock everyone else as a "rip off." Heck, even your example of Warfcraft wouldn't have happened because by the pro-IP crowd's standards, it would have been a "rip-off" of Dune II. I remember when the tech community fought overly broad IP claims and patents, now its just pro-IP shills left and right. Its incredible how far we've fallen.
- bydlocoder 5y agoHeh, one of the most successful modern games wouldn't exist if game mechanics could be patented or copyrighted. Dune 2 -> WarCraft -> WarCraft 3 -> DOTA -> League of Legends. Come to think of it, the only time Blizzard invented the whole genre was with Diablo. All their other (incredibly successful) games were refinements of prior work by other game developers.
- Jon_Lowtek 5y agoThe people involved with Diablo are surprisingly honest about their initial pitch being take Moria, Nethack, and Rogue, and bring them into the 1990s with fantastic graphics and sound. ^^ Ask them again and they talk about Telengard and Legend of Zelda, ask again and they call out MUD and D&D. Their strategy resolved around naming many inspirations, thereby removing the idea that they copied a specific one. I truly wish our culture would not favor deniability due to fear of litigation over honesty and giving respect and credit.
- bydlocoder 5y agoThat's new. I always thought clones of successful games is widely accepted practice in game industry, game mechanics can't be copyrighted or patented. Pretty weird to go after Apple and Google with such a frivolous lawsuit, their legal teams will tear Krafton apart.
- scotty79 5y agoIf it sold then customers want it. I don't understand how can you deny customers from having a product just because you feel you are owed everlasting profit.
- Shadonototra 5y agohttps://twitter.com/timsweeneyepic/status/1019852527007944704 https://twitter.com/timsweeneyepic/status/101985252700794470... They fuel it, they empower it, and they depend on it, the market is all about manipulating an audience, for that, as long as you have money, you are free and welcome to do it Liars and manipulators, that's what majority of asian companies are, specially in the smartphone app market US/EU ones aren't clean as well, but they have to play by the same rules otherwise they get shadowed Thanks Apple/Google for empowering such behaviors, and thanks to all of us for not standing up against it, and thanks to our politicians for keeping quiet
- p1necone 5y agoThe entire game industry is built on "rip-offs". Can you imagine the gaming landscape if nobody was allowed to clone Doom, or Street Fighter 2, or Dune 2/Command & Conquer. Clone it once, it's a "rip-off". Clone it 10 times in slightly different ways it's a whole new genre (as we have seen with Battle Royales). Blocking developers from building games that copy mechanics, even seemingly verbatim is dangerous territory - I don't think anyone wins in the long term from getting any stricter with IP rights on video games. /However/ imo a line should still be drawn at outright stealing assets - which I believe the creators of Garena Free Fire have actually done in the past, hopefully this lawsuit sticks with that and doesn't attempt to create a stricter precedent. EDIT: I should probably include Warcraft in the early RTS list - seems like Dune 2 set up the conventions of the genre, but I'm not sure whether Warcraft or the first Command & Conquer did more work in popularizing it. Likewise I know Doom wasn't the very first first person shooter, but it definitely popularized the genre to the point that making "clones" was more profitable.
- dleslie 5y agoThey're alleging art and other asset rips, which is very different from copying gameplay or themes.
- p1necone 5y agoAre they? The article says "game structure and in-game items, equipment, and locations" which doesn't sound like actual asset rips, although I wouldn't be surprised if the reporting on this was innacurate. Do you have other info about the content of the lawsuit?
- dleslie 5y agoI just took a look at the complaint, and looks like I was wrong! They claimed such things were copied, and so I assumed an actual ripping; as that's common. But in the complaint it appears that they mean a more traditional copying by recreating a facsimile. That's greyer. It'll be up to the court to decide if it's flagrant enough of a duplicate to warrant damages.
- ultimape 5y agoPubg itself is a ripoff of minecraft hunger games.
- Jon_Lowtek 5y agoThe Minecraft Hunger Games (later rebranded as Minecraft Survival Games) started in 2012 when that movie was hype and it hit the game streamer scene, cross-polinating the Arma2 modding and streamer scene into creating the "Survivor GameZ" in closed groups, which as legend says, PlayerUnknown couldn't join due to not being a streamer. So he made the "Battle Royal" mod in 2013 as a free for all. It was quite obviously influenced strongly by the movie of the same name. All one big happy family back then. Those were easier times, when it wasn't about "hundreds of millions of paying customers".