7 ms·
There are lots of conflicting opinions on this. Personally I think its fine that apple provides payment processing but not fine that it forces developers to use
by Gigachad 5y ago
There are lots of conflicting opinions on this. Personally I think its fine that apple provides payment processing but not fine that it forces developers to use their payment processor. A more fair system would allow the developer to present the devs own choice as well as the apple payments and allow the developer to explain there is a 30% charge on using apples payment processor.
- bradyo 5y agoPart of the problem is that the in-app purchase cut isn't just for payments infra, it also includes the rest of the infrastructure and value prop for the app store(s), which is otherwise only $100/year, which is nothing for huge companies. The problem is they also force users to use the official app store. tbf this is all less true on Android. I feel like a competitive market would have decoupled these costs.
- austinheap 5y agoiOS has allowed side loading for half a decade now. Companies that find $100 prohibitive have a free path that’s nearly identical to Android side loading.
- Gigachad 5y agoiOS most certainly does not have real sideloading. You can if you recompile the app with your own key every 7 days. Or you can use testflight with some very serious restrictions like not being able to monetize at all.
- austinheap 5y agoThere are endless KYC/AML requirements for entities that can transfer or emit USD. It’s completely reasonable that side loaded applications should not be entitled to use regulated payment services. Edit: Even Android will not entitle side loaded apps for Google payment processing. Android and iOS are literally identical in this regard.
- Gigachad 5y agoEither side loaded apps get allowed to use payment processors, or the App Store apps are allowed to use whatever processor they want.
- austinheap 5y agoNot a lawyer but that’s probably illegal in the states. (Also hilarious username is hilarious!)
- zamadatix 5y agoSideloading on iOS is nothing like sideloading on Android, you have to compile the app from source with your personal key and even then it's only valid on the device for 7 days.
- austinheap 5y agoThere is tooling to manage self-signed certs beyond the seven day window. Unrelated but I find it weird that “you have to compile the app” is a bad thing now.
- zamadatix 5y agoThere are ways to go past 7 days but all come with even more downsides to both the end user and company trying to get users to sideload. "You have to compile the app" is extremely related if you're a company wanting users to install your app, especially since that requires more than just knowledge to be able to do. To ask you the inverse question, in what way is any of this "nearly identical" to Android sideloading which allows indefinite sideloading via any delivery method, including installation of 3rd party stores, with no more than a click on an approval prompt from the user?
- austinheap 5y agoOptimizing for people who want to side load ~and~ cannot click the build button in Xcode seems wild to me. (No disrespect!) It’s identical though in that <when one side loads> one is <completely disconnect from the ecosystem of the device manufacturer>. Re: side loading binaries/APKs on my actual phone that’s logged into my actual bank account? Hard pass. There’s a time and place for lax security. This is what air gapping is for.
- fomine3 5y agoDon't forget that you need a Mac.
- austinheap 5y ago
- hug 5y agoCould you please explain the mechanism for a consumer sideloading apps onto an iPhone? I've never heard of this being possible.
- Gigachad 5y agoThere are several methods for doing it but they are all crippled in ways that make it impossible to actually use the system for anything but QA testing and development. You can install any app you compiled with your own key and it lasts for 7 days before requiring it to be recompiled.
- austinheap 5y agoIt does not have to be recompiled. The entitlement is akin to SSL: it has to be renewed. Automated tools can do this for you. This seven day lie/conspiracy/flat-earth is disappointing.
- kmeisthax 5y agoAltServer can do it but in my experience the Windows version of AltServer is extremely unreliable. AltStore never really auto-renewed properly for me until I put AltServer on an old MacBook Air. Furthermore, the fact that this process needs a second device to bootstrap provisioning at all[0] might be a non-starter for some. Take a week-long vacation? Well, now all your sideloaded apps stop working. A far bigger limitation for me is the three-app provisioning limit. There isn't any way to work around it[1], and if you do want to do serious sideloading you almost certainly will need to upgrade to a paid developer account. [0] Specifically iOS only allows app provisioning over USB or Wi-Fi, not locally. Locally installed software cannot actually communicate with the remote debugging daemon. You can work around this with network extensions, but you don't get to use them in dev-signed apps unless you have a paid dev account that's been approved by Apple to use them. For the record, that isn't to make sideloading harder; that's because Facebook went and shipped a spyware VPN with their enterprise cert. [1] Personal experience time: Even when jailbroken, and with AltDaemon and Immortal installed, AltStore still bumps up against the three-app limit.
- 5y ago
- Gigachad 5y agoYeah I think its fair that Apple charges whatever they want for whatever service they provide. They can charge for the App Store, they can charge for the dev tools and SDK. But that everything they charge money for, they _must_ allow alternatives to exist. If they want to charge a large fee for getting on the App Store, they must allow alternative app stores. The problem is not that they charge money, but that they use their massive user lock in to force people to pay for these services to exist in the market.
- ericmay 5y agoBut… this is not true just about anywhere. I can’t go to. Ford dealership and buy a new Chevy or go to Kroger and buy Costco brand. Or when I go to some stores they don’t allow me to use American Express. And yes you do have choices. There are plenty of other phone manufacturers out there. Can I install Ford UI on my Tesla? Do you think those companies won’t make you use their own payment processing once apps become prolific in car UIs? Can I hail Uber with the Lyft app? Why are they locking me in to only using Lyft on the Lyft app? Can I buy PlayStation games on Xbox? If you’re against all of it fine, but let’s not pretend Apple is doing anything out of the ordinary here.
- Gigachad 5y agoThe problem is not the exact thing Apple is doing, but the scale they are doing it at. If Ford and Chevy owned every single commercial plot of land on the country and if you wanted to start up a new brand, you are told you just have to buy your own unpopulated island, start a civilization, convince people to move over, and then you can open a new store selling your own product. That would be where Apple and Google sit right now.
- ericmay 5y agoAre we talking about phones or operating systems? Apple has decent market share of course but there are other companies out there. You can buy a Pixel, or any number of other phones. And even so, many of these “issues” are not problems on Android right? You can use 3rd-party app stores and so forth right? I’d also suggest.. why does the scale issue matter? I prefer that Apple enforces Apple Pay. I prefer that Apple enforced Sign In with Apple. That’s why I buy an iPhone. If those things bothered me I’d buy something else.
- sam0x17 5y agoimo the value prop of the App store can be entirely propped up by the $100/year developer subscriptions. They don't even need a profit cut. The app store infra is a joke. You could probably fund it with under $1m/yr
- heavyset_go 5y agoAgreed. Apple's profit margin on the App Store was ~80% in 2019[1], and the trend for the margin is to continue to increase over time. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-01/apple-s-app-store-had-78-profit-margin-in-2019-testimony-shows https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-01/apple-s-a...
- sam0x17 5y agoAnd that's what they admit to, AFTER all the creative accounting designed to minimize that number.
- moonchrome 5y agoApp store would be there even if they could charge no money for developers and have 0% cut - it's a prerequisite for the iPhone and they are making huge margins just in the devices, this argument that without allowing anti-competitive behaviour there would be no investment in the appstore is nonsense precisely becaus it's a first party integration. For example I have no problem if a third party store forced one payment option only, but only allowing one store and one payment option is just milking your market position/rent seeking.
- plandis 5y ago> For example I have no problem if a third party store forced one payment option only, but only allowing one store and one payment option is just milking your market position/rent seeking. See that’s _exactly_ the problem I have. I don’t want to use your shitty payments system that’s likely less secure than anything Apple is doing. Allowing a single payment source that’s not Apple would directly harm consumers from a security and privacy perspective.
- FpUser 5y ago>"I don’t want to use your shitty payments system" I do not use Apple at all. Somehow I am not feeling "harmed".
- righttoolforjob 5y agoWhat if you were economically harmed both by Google and Apple? Do you have any real alternatives left?
- FpUser 5y agoI am an exception. I use phone as a phone and offline GPS. Do not even have data plan. So yes anything that can make a call will do. Productivity: for me it is all on PC / servers. I might reconsider my attitude when / if I can have phone as a generic computing device where I can download and install whatever I need without much hassles and where I can distribute my applications without needing to sacrifice a virgin first.
- nojito 5y agoUsing the official store has too many benefits. Can you imagine being a student and being told you have to install this app from a third party store? That’s just a terrible model for user safety and security.
- Gigachad 5y agoiOS safety measures do not rely on the App Store. The whole sandboxing and permissions model is there to protect one app from accessing things it shouldn't.
- kzrdude 5y agogood example, that would certainly force them to have more competitive rates. Probably a premium, but still under competition. With how they control the app store though, how could it ever be a fair competition, there's always the risk of being unfairly treated?
- Gigachad 5y agoWe need to throw it back on the user. Apple uses this line of reasoning all the time. They justify their tracker blocking stuff on "the user clicked a button saying they wanted this". So for Apple to justify their fee they need to be able to convince the user that clicking the Apple payment option was worth the 30% fee while allowing other processors on the same playing field. Users might be ok with some extra fee for conveniences like trust and the ability to easily unsubscribe. Let the user pick and let Apple compete for those sales.
- mikl 5y agoThere’s some nuance to be had, to be sure. But I think we should be able to agree that demanding 30% of nearly everything and completely banning any sort of alternatives is extremely overbearing and ends up taking a lot of money out of the pockets of people struggling to get by.
- MBCook 5y agoAt this point, I think the way this will all end up (and would be fair) is for Apple’s payment system to remain, but you can choose to use another one. Apple’s take will probably fall in line (otherwise no one would use it). I also kind of like the idea that something like that happens, except games all caps must use Apple‘s system and pay the 30%. That’s not as fair, but might be workable. If I had my way over all of this? Do you know what I really want? No consumable in-app purchases. Period. Outlawed. One of my favorite things about the early iPhone was the incredible games that you could get. Now there’s almost none of them, the developers of practically abandoned the platform. The only ways to make money are ads and consumable in app purchases which are just complete scams. Like $1000 buckets of Smurfberries. That’ll never happen. But I wish it would, because it would bring back the great games.
- lynal 5y agoCheck out GameClub, for those old great games. They buy the rights from developers that don’t want to continue, then do the maintenance for newer versions of iOS and Android.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- not2b 5y agoA charge for payment processing should be closer to what Visa or Mastercard charges, something more in line with the cost for providing the service. They charge on the order of 1.5% to 3.5%, depending. 30% is extortionate.
- stefan_ 5y agoThe majority of those percentages is the various gimmick bonus programs that convince people they are beating the system and getting back more than they pay. In Europe, the cap for credit cards is at 0.3% and that's still making a ton of money.
- not2b 5y agoRegardless of whether the right rate is 0.3% or 3%, it is certainly not 30%.
- supreme_berry 5y ago
- explaingarlic 5y ago1.5% to 3.5% is extortionate for handling a transaction, in my uninformed opinion.
- judge2020 5y agoIf it were, many companies would come in at 0.01% and bank on all the customers that immediately switch payment systems. Or maybe there is a bunch of overhead and investment involved in doing such (personnel, equipment, fraud systems, etc), so no competitor charges a price that would mean break-even or losing money. If a company really doesn't want to use a payment processor, they're free to go back to tab-based/credit-based accounting and hope that everyone pays in cash or everyone pays with ACH. On that note, I hope FedNOW works well enough to become an alternate PoS payment method[0]. 0: https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/other20190805a.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/othe...
- wruza 5y agoDevelopers would be interested in taking 30% and not interested in even trying Apple appstore, which btw sets product quality level guidelines. As a result, user experience will suffer. Those who prefer apple as it is will seek apple-level quality but wouldn't find one, because apple format is now equal to a regular one, and there is no superapple. Apple instead implicitly suggests to just charge apple users more in IAPs and for apps, when a charge is related to some electronic type of value. Whatever price developers see fit, there is no practical limit. What you are basically trying to do is visiting a vip club (user-value wise) and then making it open to every crap dj out there, because otherwise it's "unfair". Why don't you just go to a regular one then? It is the same as this vip would turn into in a heartbeat. And where should other members who liked it go after that?
- mbesto 5y agoConsumers don't pay for: - SDK / iOS updates - Bandwidth to upload the compiled app to their phone - Support from Apple - Hosting / security of aforementioned - etc. etc. Who pays for all of the infrastructure of the App Store and the Apple SDK then?
- pier25 5y agoDevelopers have to pay $100 every year and in 2018 there were 20M registered developers. Probably closer to 25M now.
- upbeat_general 5y agoConsumers buy the phones that are advertised to support features (e.g. LIDAR) and iMessage. They pay for the OS development. Granted the SDKs would probably be much less comprehensive if there were no 3rd party apps but Apple advertises how their hardware can be used incl. by 3rd party apps and providing the libraries to access that hardware is expected by users (even if they don't think about this, most people expect Snapchat to access the camera). Bandwidth/Hosting is covered under the $100/yr but if it wasn't, they could easily charge devs for tiers of downloads. Most of the support I'd bet is on the consumer side which wouldn't apply if there were other payment processors.