5 ms·
This is a really bad measure of inflation for monetary policy This is a supply shock. This kind of inflation should not heavily impact your monetary policy. T
by panick21_ 5y ago
This is a really bad measure of inflation for monetary policy This is a supply shock. This kind of inflation should not heavily impact your monetary policy.
This exactly why fixed inflation targeting is a bad idea and Market Monetarist advocated NGDP Level targeting and New Keynesians simply want the Central bank to do that correctly manually.
Consumer Price Level measures might be useful for other things, but not at input for your central banking function.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Consumer Price Level measures might be useful for other things, but not at input for your central banking function. It's not about being useful, but about the fact that the mob is growing more unhappy every day because their buying power is dwindling, which in turns makes elected politicians quake in their boots. And as much as everyone would like to claim or even in some case believe that central banks are independent entities, this is a complete pipe dream, they are - at the very least - subject to influence peddling like everyone else.
- hanoz 5y ago> supply shock The supply shock you need to be worried about is the shocking oversupply of new dollars competing for the same resources.
- lumost 5y agoThe major lesson of the Fed’s QE policy has been that QE does not put dollars into the economy evenly. Certain asset classes and professions get first crack at the newly printed dollars, and over time firms and industries specifically designed to capture printed money evolve e.g. wework. It’s not a surprise that we’ll hear tons of information saying that printing money isn’t a bad thing, or that it isn’t the cause of any current monetary outcomes.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI thought the guy that led Wework captured Saudi Arabian oil money via a Japanese VC.
- bko 5y agoThere was plenty of money that went to individuals as well and I imagine that's driving retail stocks and now consumer prices. 68% of unemployed workers who received benefits were eligible for payments that are greater than their lost earnings: > As a result, though, many people may now be eligible for substantially more money while unemployed than they made while they were working. A new analysis by Peter Ganong, Pascal Noel and Joseph Vavra, economists at the University of Chicago, uses government data from 2019 to estimate that 68 percent of unemployed workers who can receive benefits are eligible for payments that are greater than their lost earnings. They also found that the estimated median replacement rate — the share of a worker’s original weekly salary that is being replaced by unemployment benefits — is 134 percent, or more than one-third above their original wage. A substantial minority of those workers, particularly in low-wage professions like food service and janitorial work, may end up receiving more than 150 percent of their previous weekly salary. https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-getting-more-money-from-unemployment-than-they-were-from-their-jobs/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/many-americans-are-gett...
- lumost 5y agoI suspect these amounts are ultimately a pittance compared to the 20% annual price gain in housing. A common theme of those choosing to no longer work is that housing makes many jobs cost prohibitive to do.
- topkai22 5y agoNot sure I get the argument here— federal enhanced unemployment benefits have been over since September, so there is no longer a monetary benefit to remaining on unemployment in almost all cases. Are you arguing people aren’t relocating or something to that effect?
- lumost 5y agoMy argument is that government spending on unemployment insurance and direct payments to individuals is tiny relative to money printed by the Fed and stashed in assets via QE
- cplusplusfellow 5y agoIt’s similar to the idea that central planning doesn’t allocate resources most appropriately for everyone to benefit.
- Ericson2314 5y agoConsumer spending has gone down. Too many dollars cannot be the problem if they aren't being spent! You might say "oh, well the rich are bidding up gas and food prices, poor people can't afford and ummmm drive and eat less". It sounds silly and it should but even if that were happening, and was the sole causal factor, it would mean the food and gas markets were not clearing, and that is clearly also not happening. And even if that were happening the sellers would be being irrational. For surely they would lower prices after the rich were fed and gassed up so they could sell the remainder of their goods, and make more money. (the profit rate would go down but the total profits would go up.) No matter how you cut it, the Monetarist story is false and ridiculous given the evidence.
- javert 5y agoOverprinting money causes massive economic distortion. For instance, the rich who get the money first are buying up all the houses, turning the US into a nation of renters. Another example--the federal government enables "easy money" as higher education loans, which has enabled universities to massively overcharge for mostly low quality education.
- Ericson2314 5y agoYes inequality is inefficient. The monitarists' conception of inflation is a temporary distortion where all the money stock and flows pick up. What you are describing is a spacial distortion where certain people / goods get unfair treatment. The latter is indeed quite dubious, but it's not the same as the former! Conventional monetary policy is lame and fairly ineffective, but I have seen claims that raising rates is better at destimulating than lowering is at stimulating. What a tough nuance to convey!
- topkai22 5y ago> … turning the US into a nation of renters. The data doesn’t seem to support this, at least not yet. The owner occupancy of units has been increasing since 2016 and increased after 2020. The increase in housing prices has been extraordinary, but seems in large part due to people who actually intend to live in that housing. See: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EOWNOCCUSQ176N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/EOWNOCCUSQ176N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N
- panick21_ 5y agoI didn't make any argument about actual policy. I simply pointed out that people should over-react to CPI based inflation measures.
- nickff 5y agoThe prices of most of the (inflation measure) inputs have been increasing, with different delays and magnitudes; it's not just one or two of the inputs. At what point do you acknowledge that there has been a general increase in the price level? If you agree that there has been an increase, when do you think it counts as 'inflation'? Inflation originally meant 'an increase in the money supply' (what we now call m1), which is what we've seen over the past two years. When the governments enacted their responses to COVID, many predicted 'inflation', and some denied it would happen. Does this count? What would 'count'?
- RhodesianHunter 5y agoThe big numbers ARE driven by only one or two inputs though. Without used cars and housing, the supply of which took a huge hit for Covid related reasons, the print would be much lower.
- lumost 5y agoPerhaps we should also swap rent increases for living with additional roommates, clearly consumers are choosing more communal living situations and we can thus discount rent price increases as well. Just like we took home prices out of CPI /s If we get to choose which categories get excluded from CPI after every bad report it ceases to be a good metric.
- sokoloff 5y agoCPI is a survey-based methodology and captures how people actually spend their money. If something becomes rare and expensive and people curtail their consumption of it, that is itself a useful signal. If something becomes common and inexpensive and people buy a lot more of it as a result, also a useful signal. Home purchase price was taken out of CPI-U in 1983 (and CPI-W in 1985) and replaced with an owner-equivalent rent measure that gets at the cost of consumption of shelter (the service that housing provides). Tl;dr: Housing expenses were not removed; house purchases were (and replaced with a rent-equivalent measure).
- partiallypro 5y agoIf it's -only- a supply shock, then prices would eventually come down, right? Well, we are finding that to be less and less true. So something else is going on beneath the surface.
- ksdale 5y agoOr there's still a massive pandemic happening and supplies of everything are still very shocked.
- partiallypro 5y agoThen in 4-5 years prices would revert, unless it's not just a supply shock and is instead monetarily lead. Prices haven't gone up as much in other countries. The US has one of the highest inflation rates coming out of the pandemic.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoAs I understand it we're still dealing with supply issues and will be for a long while still. Chips are still incredibly hard to source and that naturally affects a giant range of consumer products.
- panick21_ 5y ago> If it's -only- a supply shock, then prices would eventually come down, right? Not necessarily. > Well, we are finding that to be less and less true. So something else is going on beneath the surface. That's fine. We have ways to do monetary policy while accepting whatever else is going on. If you target NGDP Levels your demand function already balances supply and demand correctly by itself.
- partiallypro 5y agoIf prices are up 30%-100% in some instances, and stay up 50% despite the supply chain recovery, then it's not only because of the supply chain. The US has one of the highest inflation rates coming out of the pandemic. Japan essentially has had no inflation. >That's fine. We have ways to do monetary policy while accepting whatever else is going on. That assuming you think the Fed won't make a major policy mistake or hasn't already. You act like monetary policy is simple, it's not. I think MMTers have ruined a lot of people's perception on the complexity of monetary policy.
- BenoitEssiambre 5y agoNote that the Market Monetarists have been increasingly vocal recently about central banks overdoing it (after a decade of criticizing for under stimulating). NGDP seems to also be overshooting.
- panick21_ 5y agoYes, they tend to be right. A stable long term trend in NGDP fixes pretty much all of these issues. Inflation and Real growth can figure themselves out independently. If there is a supply shock, you will have lower real growth but monetary policy will not react to that because its a real signal. Market Monetarists were very active training to tell people that the Fed in 2008 were actually deflationary. That I think is what eventually will be the consequences, just like it is with the Central Bank.
- listless 5y agoI tend to think you are right here and that worries me. Because if we cannot get back to “normal”, inflation is going to keep rising. At some point the virus is going to kill the economy, too.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThere is a lot of propagation delay where a few key bottlenecks radiate out though industries that have transitive inputs in those bottlenecks. I'd think that the root supply issues were easing over last year, so much of what we are seeing is still an echo what's already come. If omicron blows through as fast as it arose, I'd say things are looking up. Still team transitory.
- panick21_ 5y agoI strongly disagree. The central bank is always in control, they can not be, not in control. If they are not hitting targets its just bad leadership. So never fall into the trap of thinking the central bank has not 'teeth'. They could hit almost any target they wanted. The only thing that needs to change is the mind of people on the control board.