13 ms·
Lawsuit aiming to break up Facebook group Meta can go ahead, US court rules
- remram 5y agoWhile I'm strongly in favor, in surprised Facebook+WhatsApp+Instagram is a problem while Google+Gmail+YouTube+Meet+GCP+Chrome+Android is not.
- cvak 5y agoOr exchange + office + teams + skype + windows + onedrive + github....
- rvense 5y agoTeams being part of Office 365 is a pretty obvious.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoBut it was to knee-cap Slack…
- rvense 5y agoPrecisely. They're using their success in one space to prevent others from being successful in a different space.
- csunbird 5y agoBecause, one of them bought the competition, while other just built it themselves. (well, ignoring YT)
- namelessoracle 5y agoAlphabet buys lots of companies, so im not sure what you are talking about here.
- ironman1478 5y agoAndroid was bought and Chrome was initially based on webkit.
- robocat 5y agoAndroid was built by Google. What they bought was a prototype that lacked virtually all of the functionality they needed.
- sangnoir 5y agoI heard[1] the Android team was pretty insular after being acquired: they wouldn't even let other Googlers into their building on the Google campus. So if it was the same leadership and mostly the same engineers as before acquisition, can you say Google built Android? Even if they bought a prototype, the acquired the company to execute something Google would have struggled to without the talent, so IMO divining if Google were interested in the product or the personnel is splitting hairs. 1. I have never worked at Google, I'm pulling this information from my recollection of reports & forum submissions back then.
- endisneigh 5y agoYou can argue that instagram and WhatsApp would be viable strong competition to Facebook. Gmail wouldn’t really be competitor to Google search. YouTube definitely could be though. Chrome isn’t a viable company - GCP is pretty fledgling but possible.
- rsstack 5y agoThe anti-competitive argument here isn't that Chrome would be a good competitor to Google Search, but that Google operates both products in a way that makes it all but impossible for other companies to create viable competitors to Chrome or Google Search.
- endisneigh 5y agoHow is it all but impossible for companies to create viable competitors to chrome, exactly?
- rsstack 5y agoThat "or" wasn't meant as "both" or to opine on which one it is. I personally believe the way Google operate Chrome is one of the reasons it is all but impossible to seriously compete with Google Search. But I'm not the judge.
- Natfan 5y agoTry making a web browser that supports Widevine (Google's DRM for web browsers) and see how far you get. Back in 2019, someone tried exactly this and was blocked by Google as they didn't want another web browser on the market: https://blog.samuelmaddock.com/posts/google-widevine-blocked-my-browser/ https://blog.samuelmaddock.com/posts/google-widevine-blocked...
- endisneigh 5y agoDoes edge, brave and Firefox all support it?
- mmastrac 5y agoIf this succeeds, they'll target the others next. Google, Microsoft, Amazon and Apple all have easily divisible lines.
- Tenoke 5y agoIt is pretty ridiculous as Facebook have big competitors in all their markets which aren't even that many. Google has more near-monopolies and in more markets and co-integrated more heavily at that. It's really hard for me to see this as due to just Facebook being a popular target rather than actual solid analyses.
- tarsinge 5y agoThe way I see it Facebook+ is a societal problem and so is a larger one than the usual tech monopoly problem which Google fall in (which is still a problem though, just not on the same level).
- echelon 5y agoOut of all the anti trust cases, this one feels like the least prepared and perhaps least warranted. Facebook faces competition from Twitter, TikTok, Reddit, Twitch, YouTube, Discord, Steam, VRChat, dating apps, Netflix, etc. They deal in attention, and there are a lot of attention seeking companies. Even in the social networking space. I'm not defending the company by any means. I'm just pointing out the landscape. The companies most applicable to break up scrutiny are Google, Apple, and Amazon in precisely that order. Google owns the web. They control search. The desktop and mobile browser space. Web standards. The ads marketplace. Google Play and the associated profits. They lock people into their ecosystem of store, messaging and productivity apps, and force competitors to play nice using this leverage, despite Android being "open source". They're trashing the quality of the web for profit maximization and extorting advertisers. They're trying to strong arm all of the web into a hosted AMP-like platform that Google serves and controls. Apple owns 50% of the mobile market and keeps it under a tight grip with rules and taxes. They have a deep ecosystem of hardware and software that only plays nice with itself. They're anti-repairability, anti-portability, and treat their platform as a Berlin Walled dictatorship. They drag their feet on web standards and don't allow any edge for competition, meanwhile they grow into the payments, ads, healthcare and other spaces. They've grown a protected republic that is 50+% of domestic computing. If you launch a business on Apple, you'll owe them 30%, must play by their rules, can't build a customer relationship, and will probably wind up competing with them. And when Apple wants to compete with an offering a small company in their app store has, they ban or remove them. As much as we hate ads, they can destroy billion dollar businesses with simple policy changes, acting as a gravitational wave proportional to the scale of their business. Both of these companies frequently get caught colluding on labor and anticompetitive pacts. Amazon treats its sellers like shit and copies the ideas that work at scale. They horizontally integrated to the point that they run half the Internet, a major grocer and food retailer, consumer electronics, logistics and transportation, multiple film studios, video gaming, etc. There's nothing their hands aren't in, and due to economies of scale they can push anyone else over. If you host on AWS, they're offering deep discounts to their internal competitor. They're also turning all of open source into "free labor" for Amazon and using it as a tool for lock in. Each of these companies could easily be split up. Amazon probably the easiest, because it's plainly obvious where most of the business divisions lie. They're into everything. Apple the most difficult - maybe forcing them to open up their platform and divest of media interests is a better action. This wouldn't be about about destroying value. It's about making our economy robust and resilient. Giants are not conducive to that as they can price out actual economic activities and innovation.
- fallingknife 5y agoIt's ridiculous that the government is litigating this while ignoring the long standing monopolies that have been hurting consumers for decades. I would say it's also ridiculous that the government is putting the interests of advertisers over consumers, but that's not what they are doing. This is a transparent political maneuver by the bureaucrats in dc against the tech industry.
- hn_version_0023 5y ago
- KerrAvon 5y agoSure, they’ve failed to do this a lot, but why discourage the government from doing this good thing just because they haven’t done it enough in the past? Your last sentence is full of buzzwords. What is the mechanism behind that? What is their motivation? Why would “dc” care about Facebook? If your answer is somehow related to “the blob,” you probably need to do some actual reading on the theory and practice of monopoly enforcement in the United States.
- fairity 5y agoGiven that Meta’s stock hasn’t dropped, I’m willing to bet either this isn’t news or it poses no real threat to Meta.
- metacritic12 5y agoOr it's possible the split up company doesn't have significantly lower market value than the monopoly company. Imagine a 25% non-monopoly discount and a 25% chance of being split up and that would only be a 6% drop in value.
- maaanu 5y agoThat only holds true if the market is purely rational which it is not.
- BbzzbB 5y agoConglomerates tend to be valued less than the sum-of-the-parts, getting control of conglomerates to spin off their businesses is a common active investing tactic. Breaking FB up is likely to unlock value for shareholders rather than hinder it. At least, short term as far as stock valuations go, a "markets are irrational" stance works in favor of this theory as it (the market) gets to speculate on every sub-business individually. Long term there are advantages to being under a single banner, like subsidizing Oculus growth and R&D through profits from the social medias to capture long term market share (like Amazon can subsidies retail with AWS, Alphabet can subsidies its "Other bets" with Search, etc).
- lovecg 5y agoI remember reading that in many cases total market cap goes up post-split.
- badRNG 5y agoIt isn't much news (disclaimer: IANAL.) Facebook had submitted a motion to dismiss the lawsuit. A motion to dismiss means they assume that every fact alleged by the FTC is true. You perform a motion to dismiss to say "even if everything they said is true, it still isn't even possible for them to win the lawsuit." The judge said, essentially, that if every fact the FTC alleges is true, then it is at least feasible that the FTC could have a successful lawsuit. There are two key things that this go ahead does NOT do: 1. It does not look at whether even a single alleged fact by the FTC is true 2. It does not mean that the FTC suit would be successful even if every fact is successfully proven
- namelessoracle 5y agoTargeting Facebook and not Google or Amazon for tech monopoly is not a good look, and just makes people feel like Zuck didnt make the right political donations and didnt censor for the benefit of the party in power hard enough. Whether Meta qualifies or not is a different question, but Facebook as your first target?
- metacritic12 5y agoIn the balance between looking good and getting started somewhere, what's more important?
- mmastrac 5y agoFacebook's purchases of WhatsApp, Oculus, and Instagram probably make them a softer target given how they've used those properties. On top of that, they've had some of the worst overall news. Why not start with thesortedt target and get some ammunition when you go for the others?
- leros 5y agoFacebook actually has pretty decent arguments why all their products have strong competition. They can also make some arguments about how the other tech giants have much worse monopolies.
- DCKing 5y agoAntitrust is not about monopolies. It's true Facebook is not a monopoly in the classic sense of that word. Antitrust is about anticompetitiveness. Big tech and especially Facebook is in this new situation where they're causing anticompetitiveness not due to supply side control (i.e. you can get other services that compete against Facebook's products). They're causing anticompetitiveness due to demand side control - the social media that people want to use _in practice_ is all controlled by Facebook. Not because Facebook is intrinsically a superior product (e.g. cheaper, quality of content, technical qualities), but due to network effects and acquisitions of network effect through Instagram and Whatsapp. We're in a new situation where new precedent needs to be created in what kind of demand side control is desired, permitted and should be dealt with. Which makes this new territory, and it also means that a defense of "we have decent competitors" shouldn't be a decisive argument on Facebook's behalf.
- endisneigh 5y agoWe should just break up all companies. One company - one product. Then we can end all of the hand wringing about how and why to divide. /s
- ceejayoz 5y agoGood luck deciding where the line between products is. Is the Gmail spam filter a product, or part of Gmail? Is Gmail a product, or is GSuite the product?
- endisneigh 5y agoYes, exactly - my comment was in jest
- wintermutestwin 5y agoInstead of this old school "break 'em up" approach, which just allows them to out lawyer the government, why not simply create regulations which criminalize their specific harmful behavior with teeth big enough to make them stop? Unfortunately, the answer to my rhetorical question is: because theater.
- akersten 5y ago> why not simply create regulations which criminalize their specific harmful behavior It's a lot easier to say "break them up!" and get a rise out of anyone who has any vague sense of having being slighted by said companies than actually defining specific behavior that should be criminalized. Because once the agitators put pen to paper and define the behavior, I bet it looks laughably innocuous.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo you will replace one lawsuit which they can 'out lawyer' with a slightly different lawsuit they can 'out lawyer'? I am not seeing a winning strategy here.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoINAL, but it seems to me that anti-trust litigation is far more complicated, costly and time consuming than passing a law that makes (for example) unauthorized data theft a crime.
- mburns 5y agoWhat kind of teeth do you imagine would be required?
- wintermutestwin 5y agoFines that make such practices unprofitable and with repeated crimes, revoke their corporate charter.
- sorenn111 5y agoWhere's the meaningful action against ISP's? In my opinion, ISP monopolies and collusion cause orders of magnitude more consumer harm than FAANG by a lot. If one is truly interested in helping out consumers, start with the less flashy lawsuits against monopolies that do more direct consumer harm than FAANG. Starting with FAANG (in my opinion) betrays the true motivation of this action which is political theater instead of meaningful action.
- bradknowles 5y agoWith respect, “whataboutism” doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t also solve the problem of Fuckerberg and whatever he’s calling his latest sneeze machine.
- Retric 5y agoModern Cellular and Starlink are actually bringing some real competition. For the average consumer a Tablet with unlimited data on any major network crushes DSL’s speeds and cost. Starlink is still rolling out, but I suspect it will keep cell networks honest and they both will end up keeping wired ISP’s honest.
- Brendinooo 5y agoThis is a good point; if I recall, the Sirius/XM merger was allowed to proceed because, even though that created a monopoly in satellite radio, they were competing in a broader landscape.
- Jaepa 5y agoIts worth mentioning that both LEO & WISP are explicitly not include in net neutrality provisions. That being said any net neutrality provisions outside of CA is kind of up in the air right now so I don't know if that really matters.
- encryptluks2 5y agoThank you. I always bring this up. Politicians like targeting things that they gripe about being excluded from to get more votes, but there are much more serious problems that they are ignoring.
- delecti 5y agoAlmost all of the top level comments (5/8 at time of writing, and 1 of the other 3 is a reductio ad absurdum) are mainly just comparing this lawsuit to hypothetical ones against other companies. If I weren't at risk of getting flagged for spam, I'd reply to every one of them with the wikipedia link for Whataboutism. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism This case isn't any less valid because there are other possible cases that don't also exist.
- Tenoke 5y agoThis isn't whataboutism, this is questioning your sheriff why they used their limited resources to arrest a shoplifter but ignored a burglar. People are rightfully curious why the priorities seem off.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThat is literally textbook definition of whataboutism
- khazhoux 5y agoSo is there no valid way to say "This is a waste of time and resources" ?
- delecti 5y agoSaying an antitrust lawsuit against Meta is a waste of time and resources is a potentially valid argument. Saying it's a waste of time and resource unless they also go after Google or whoever is not.
- aspenmayer 5y agoCompared to doing not prosecuting anticompetitive behavior? Doubtful.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoYou just did! And this claim is very different to the claim above. If you wanted to argue in favour of this claim, something like the statement below would be convincing: "The expected cost of prosecution is X, and expected benefit is Y. X >> Y"
- bussierem 5y agoThere's a lot of "whataboutism" happening in this thread. How about our reaction to something like this is not "do more", but instead encouraging and be happy they are finally doing _anything_? Being negative will just make it seem like they shouldn't be doing anything.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DesiLurker 5y agothats probably because influencers/fanbois are trying to fix the conversation's overton window early on. give it time, usually high comment volume breaks out of it.
- mrkramer 5y ago>Federal Trade Commission wants to force sale of Instagram and WhatsApp Sale to whom? Google can pick up WhatsApp. They tried to buy it initially years ago.
- bobthepanda 5y agoCould be separate IPO (so a sale to the public) Spinning out companies is pretty common. If anything, tech is the odd sector out in the US economy for still having conglomerates.
- nazgulsenpai 5y agoRemember when Microsoft was broken up for trying to use their install footprint to strongarm the usage of the browser that came bundled with their operating system? Boy am I glad those days are over. Oh, wait... In all seriousness, this doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Sure, maybe Facebook needs to be broken up but there are bigger fish.
- friendlydog 5y agoSometimes a small domino can knock down larger ones.
- skarz 5y agoI mentioned this last time when the FTC refiled its complaint but the FTC still has a pretty tough case to prove here. Among other points the core of the FTCs complaint states Facebooks market power dominance by stating its largest competitor is Snapchat. While not impossible I think it'll be tough to convince people that platforms like Twitter and TikTok operate in a completely different market than Facebook does while also saying that Snapchat is in that market.
- sjg007 5y agoI think the antitrust issue is in the targeted digital ad market because FB has all of these products in the social networking space.
- vineyardmike 5y agoIts not.
- oneoff786 5y agoIt would be pretty funny if Facebook was pried off of everything. And was just receded into the obscurity of MySpace.
- saos 5y agoI would totally jump back on WhatsApp if this happened
- anticensor 5y agoThis attempt would not work out the way it is expected, as the subjecture i.e. the user base would still stay mostly identical. It would be far better to strip Facebook and Meta out of for-profit status.
- perryizgr8 5y agoWhat about Apple, Google and Microsoft? At least I can totally avoid Meta in my life, because their products are completely optional and have a ton of alternatives. But I simply cannot avoid Apple and Google because of their total monopoly on mobile phones. Break them up first.