6 ms·
I don't disagree with you, but at the same time, who else is going to make this kind of noise? It's not like we can rely on the US DoJ to investigate these thi
by kelnos 5y ago
I don't disagree with you, but at the same time, who else is going to make this kind of noise? It's not like we can rely on the US DoJ to investigate these things and find solutions, despite all their noise about "policing big tech".
I personally think the current situation with iMessage is garbage. Even if Apple doesn't care about Android users, they are hurting their own users: every time an iPhone user has to send a text to an Android user, they degrade the security and privacy of their own users.
(It's telling to see where Apple draws the line: being anti-competitive around messaging is more important to them than their customers' privacy and security.)
Even if Google had their shit together when it comes to messaging, there's always the "default install" problem: iMessage is on every iPhone, from the factory. That creates a barrier for any competitor to gain market share with an alternative messenger. Sure, WhatsApp, Telegram, etc. have been pretty successful, but they're not the default install. (Remember when Microsoft got in trouble in the 90s for bundling IE, at the expense of Netscape?)
As an Android user, all I really want is a secure way to communicate with others by default, without having to figure out which secure messaging app I have in common with each of my peers. Apple has made that impossible, and should be required to allow Google to integrate iMessage support into the stock Android Messages app. Or they should be required to support RCS (with E2E encryption compatible with Google's extension) on iPhones. I'll accept either option, though I'd probably prefer RCS rather than an Apple-proprietary protocol.
- ddek 5y agoI don’t see how you’re not suggesting yet another competing platform (insert xkcd here). SMS is the default, and iMessage is an elevation of SMS; in the same way FaceTime elevates it’s respective default (phone calls). If iMessage was cross platform, it’s just another messaging app. We have that. If you want secure cross platform messaging, use any of the other platforms built around that feature.
- stale2002 5y ago> yet another competing platform People are advocating for the opposite. Make apple stop using their anti-competitive market to harm alternative messaging apps. > If iMessage was cross platform, it’s just another messaging app. No, it is just as good, and better if it is forced to be cross platform. You lose nothing, and everyone else gains, when anti-competitive markets are made to support alternatives. > If you want secure cross platform messaging Or, instead of that, we could use anti-trust law, against Apple to force them to be less anti-competitive, and allow other people to integrate with it. Problem solved.
- threeseed 5y ago> messaging anti-competitive market I love how it's such an anti-competitive market that in many countries Apple isn't even close to being a popular service. WhatsApp, WeChat, Kakao, Line etc dominate in non-Western countries.
- lxgr 5y agoEven in all of Western Europe, WhatsApp clearly dominates, with iMessage coming in third or fourth in popularity in my practical experience (after Signal and lately, unfortunately, Telegram).
- kelnos 5y ago> I don’t see how you’re not suggesting yet another competing platform I'm not suggesting another competing platform. I'm suggesting an already-widely-deployed platform (RCS) that is standardized, has been around since 2008 or so (older than iMessage!), and is the actual real elevation of SMS, not an Apple-proprietary protocol. > If iMessage was cross platform It's not, and that's the problem! Making it cross-platform would at least partially solve the problem, though it does mean Yet Another Messaging App I have to install. > If you want secure cross platform messaging, use any of the other platforms built around that feature. That's a huge pain in the ass. Not all of my friends have Signal, and I'm tired of evangelizing. Not all of my friends have WhatsApp, and I'm not interested in evangelizing a Facebook property. I don't use Telegram, and very few of my friends do, and I'm also wary of evangelizing a messenger that is not secure by default, and that has what is IMO a sketchy, secretive history around its cryptography. Looking through my Messages history, there are 27 people I communicated with over unencrypted SMS/MMS over the past month. Only one of those people has Signal (not sure why they SMS'd me, but that just further illustrates the problem of how it's difficult to remember to contact people using the "correct" means), and maybe 6 or 8 of them have WhatsApp (for whatever reason, they/I don't really use WhatsApp often). Why is this so hard? Apple! If Apple supported RCS (with the E2EE extension), literally every single one of those 27 conversations would have been encrypted, without me (or, critically, the other party, whom I have no control over) having to do anything special. As much as I love blaming Google for many things, they cannot solve this, because iMessage is a closed protocol that they are not permitted to implement, and the messenger app that is in the default install (the iMessage-supporting Messages app on iOS, and the RCS-supporting Messages app on Android) has a huge easy-adoption advantage that third-party messengers will never be able to match. You can argue a bunch of "shoulds" here, but I'm talking about what the reality actually is.
- aspenmayer 5y ago
- smoldesu 5y ago...so the onus of standardization falls on Apple's shoulders then? If they want more features they can file an RFC, they're not "too good" for any of that stuff. If they think they're better at it, then they can open the iMessage protocol in some capacity. If Apple wants to present "the future" of messaging, then they're going to have to stop segregating between their own devices and third-party clients. There's no point in arguing about the technical aspect of this anyways. It's purely a social manipulation campaign by their marketing department, they as much as admit to it in their advertising.
- fomine3 5y agoMessaging platform for specific hardware platform is nonsense. Theoretically it shouldn't be widely used.
- blunte 5y agoBlackBerry made a very success business doing exactly this for years.
- threeseed 5y agoRCS doesn't support E2E encryption out of the box. So for me it seems like a far worse solution than the status quo.
- kelnos 5y agoI address this in my post: there's an extension, and there's nothing stopping Apple from implementing it, as Google has. Any other features that are missing or sub-par in the RCS vs. iMessage equation is IMO trivial compared to the harm we have now of the lack of interoperability.
- threeseed 5y agoBut if it's an extension to the spec then other client implementors don't have to support it. And then you end up with a lower common denominator effect where end to end encryption is no longer widely used. That is by every definition worse than what we have today.
- magicalist 5y ago> But if it's an extension to the spec then other client implementors don't have to support it. And then you end up with a lower common denominator effect where end to end encryption is no longer widely used. That is by every definition worse than what we have today. This is a pretty literal description of how iMessage interfaces with non-iPhones today though, so not worse.
- PlanckMeasure80 5y agoIt’s worse because people might actually use it. I currently use WhatsApp for my main contacts that are on Android.
- kelnos 5y agoHow is that any worse than iMessage degrading to the lowest common denominator of SMS/MMS? And SMS/MMS is a much lower common denominator than RCS. Look, I'm not asking for the perfect messaging system here. Because we're never going to get that. I just want something secure and private, and that works by default. Agreed that other client implementors don't have to support E2EE, but Google does, and Apple certainly would, and that covers enough cases right now to make me happy. I'd grudgingly accept an iMessage app for Android, or (better) iMessage integration with the stock Android app. But I'd much prefer a standard that isn't controlled by a single company's goodwill... goodwill that they have already shown is in short supply.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aspenmayer 5y agoRCS is garbage. Here’s why: There is a publicly-facing Google site to enter an RCS enabled cellphone number, in order to disable Chat features… including end-to-end encryption.[0] This feature should only be configurable on-device, ideally, or at least be behind a login and 2fa. It’s just there on a public site. This is basically asking for sim-swapping attacks. And you’d never notice, only wonder why your RCS e2e keeps turning itself off. I wonder which individuals and agencies may benefit from that… Even with the Chat features enabled, RCS doesn’t not support e2e on group texts[1], unlike iMessage, which does[2]. Google is just playing dirty pool and calling Apple users bullies by proxy, and I’m calling them on it. Edit: Apple has a similar site to disable iMessage. This setting should only be available on-device, or if it has to have an online workaround, behind a login with 2fa. If you no longer have access to your phone, you should have to contact Apple support or go to an Apple store. The status quo benefits bad actors and intelligence agencies more than it improves the experience for end users IMO. [0] https://messages.google.com/disable-chat https://messages.google.com/disable-chat [1] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202724 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT202724 [2] https://support.google.com/messages/answer/10262381?hl=en https://support.google.com/messages/answer/10262381?hl=en
- profile53 5y agoThere’s a public site to disable iMessages too. Same exact design.
- fomine3 5y agoApple do the same for [0] https://selfsolve.apple.com/deregister-imessage/ https://selfsolve.apple.com/deregister-imessage/ It's interesting that both sites are very similar. Maybe Google copied Apple's site.
- aspenmayer 5y agoSeems like it. My points in that regard about only have this setting be accessible behind a login and 2fa is the way to go. You sold or otherwise deprived yourself of your iPhone and forgot to turn off iMessage? Contact Apple support or go to an Apple store. This functionality disproportionately benefits bad actors and intelligence agencies around the world.
- imaadrashied 5y agoSeems like you're only thinking of one piece of the puzzle, which your Android phone sending RCS thanks to a carrier allowing you to. Doesn't address this part of the problem: > "Even if Google could magically roll out RCS everywhere, it's a poor standard to build a messaging platform on because it is dependent on a carrier phone bill. It's anti-Internet and can't natively work on webpages, PCs, smartwatches, and tablets, because those things don't have SIM cards. The carriers designed RCS, so RCS puts your carrier bill at the center of your online identity, even when free identification methods like email exist and work on more devices. Google is just promoting carrier lock-in as a solution to Apple lock-in."
- kelnos 5y agoThat's a fair point that I hadn't considered. I agree that's a negative, but for me, personally, I don't consider it a showstopper. I do get that other people might, though, and am understanding of that position. On the flip side, most people using RCS would otherwise be using an @gmail.com address as their identity if that was how it worked. I'd say that's probably better than the carrier owning the identity, but it's still not ideal.
- blendergeek 5y ago> Google is just promoting carrier lock-in as a solution to Apple lock-in. But, there is no "carrier lock-in" (at least not in the USA). In the USA, carriers are legally required to allow users to port numbers to and from any carrier thus creating competition rather than lock-in.
- waffle_maniac 5y agoBrave browser has the same problem on Android and iOS. Hopefully there will be some distribution deals in the future. But the default install is a huge problem for competition.
- olliej 5y agoOk, but the problem is group messaging. RCS doesn't support encrypted group chats. Given that the "ugh green bubble" peer pressure examples seem to mostly be in group chats, implementing RCS wouldn't solve anything. But security is besides the point: Google doesn't want RCS support for security, it wants people not to know they're communicating with a non-apple device because they're afraid of the peer pressure. Given that android has a huge marketshare lead, and google definitely knows how to make chat apps, they just never made one and stuck with it. Instead they kept continuously shipping new, incompatible, disconnected, chat apps and services. Because of that no one really trusts Google when it says "use this chat app, this time we'll keep it around". Meanwhile a person with a first gen iPhone or iPad (or a Mac from that era) can still use iMessage to talk to someone using the latest generation software. I would guess there's a loss of feature set, but it should theoretically still work.
- jvolkman 5y agoEncrypted group chats are apparently coming soon. https://twitter.com/lockheimer/status/1480663656463437824 https://twitter.com/lockheimer/status/1480663656463437824
- olliej 5y agoIt’s too late at this point: the vast majority of RCS clients won’t support it (if it happens), so the green bubble that google hates is destined to remain. Google could have avoided this by not continuously releasing and killing chat services. If they’d stuck to one they would have a much bigger number of users - people complain about iOS, but lets be real: android is a much bigger market. Google allowing both the hardware and software to fragment in basic functionality is a questionable decision.
- Melatonic 5y agoYea - its frankly ridiculous at this point. The original Google Chat was great and was (as far as I know) their only offering at the time. Then it all went to hell. And now we are back to Google Chat again!
- jmull 5y ago> As an Android user, all I really want is a secure way to communicate with others by default, without having to figure out which secure messaging app I have in common with each of my peers. What you want is for everyone to support whatever messaging protocol Google is pushing today. There have been a lot over the years and it seems like RCS won’t be the last (it has its flaws — serious, fatal ones, IMO).
- dwaite 5y agoNot to mention the nine year gap since they killed off support for an actual standard in all their products (XMPP). Nearly a decade and a dozen failed messaging products later, now they are shaming others for not being interoperable with their preferred spec?
- xbar 5y agoYou bought a device and want every one else to make software for their devices to make your device work the way you want it to. I don't think that's the way the world is.
- djrogers 5y ago> every time an iPhone user has to send a text to an Android user, they degrade the security and privacy of their own users. RCS wouldnt change that one bit.
- silisili 5y agoGoogle doesn't even enable RCS with its own Voice product. It's worse than the left hand not knowing what the right hand is doing, it's like the left thumb not knowing what the left pointer finger is doing. Google cannot deliver, then cry foul instead of even thinking to fix the organizational hell they've created.
- FormerBandmate 5y agoThe government should intervene to force interoperability and stop the lock-in that comes with any of the tech giants
- WhyNotHugo 5y ago> As an Android user, all I really want is a secure way to communicate with others by default, without having to figure out which secure messaging app I have in common with each of my peers. I'd prefer the opposite: an OS with _no_ messaging app, and let users pick their own (both for Android and iOS). Expecting OS vendors to ship one out of the box is asking for a new IE-like scenario where whatever big tech companies pick becomes the standard, no matter how good or bad it may be.
- wbsss4412 5y agoI currently have 4 messaging apps on my phone, messaging is absolutely a competitive space. What you are upset about isn’t anti competitiveness, but fragmentation. Messaging is easily a more competitive market than search.