3 ms·
There are plenty of subsets of the software industry that are grown-up. Anybody who wants to learn more should read the RISKS mailing list and its archives. I
by dekhn 5y ago
There are plenty of subsets of the software industry that are grown-up.
Anybody who wants to learn more should read the RISKS mailing list and its archives. It's remarkably hard to produce reliable software but a number of groups around the world can do it.
Examples I can think of: the teams that built the series of ESS for AT&T. The folks who built Erlang (telecom reliability is a common theme here, being one of the other technical areas where software and hardware engineering excellence greatly exceeds that which we see from typical groups today). Even Qt, although the quality of their code and its adherence to the principles that make Qt great is variable, I'd say is a good example of a system built by grown-ups.
BTW, when i say "grown-up", I don't really mean anything directly related to age, although age and experience are the best proxies for grown-up. Grown up is really a way of saying: working with more weight on wisdom as raw intelligence (Ghemawat's law), respecting experience even if it's not obvious why you should, (Chesterton's Fence), using statistical testing techniques effectively for quality control (Shewhart), practicing discipline to ensure long-term compatibility and not burning your dependents (jwz's law of CADT). I don't think there's a general term for acting with these principles, I just mentally associate them with being a grownup who has learned from experience.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Anybody who wants to learn more should read the RISKS mailing list and its archives. Yes, totally second that, that's the best school there is, seeing what goes wrong and what the consequences are. I probably spent weeks just reading and analyzing the various posts there. As for the part of the industry that isn't grown up: anything that can do OTA or automatic updates is likely to suffer from a rash of bugs and usability issues, which includes everything that's SAAS and almost all application software with the exception of some industrial stuff. There is far more low quality software than there is high quality software.