6 ms·
>though we did almost have an internal coup. no, we didn't. there's no plausible way the people there would have seized power.
by gruez 5y ago
>though we did almost have an internal coup.
no, we didn't. there's no plausible way the people there would have seized power.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoThe fact that they got as far as they did is only going to embolden them to do it again.
- DamnYuppie 5y agoIt was a protest turned aggressive, it was in no way an insurrection, no evidence has been presented that was the intent of the group what so ever. Also why would you even bother doing it that way? You could use far fewer people who are coordinated and go after the politicians at their homes where there is much less security.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoBecause the entire point of it was to pressure Congress into forcing the election of Trump by interfering with the counting of electoral votes which had already taken place. After exhausting all their legel remedies, the last thing they thought they could do was scare Congress and Pence. This isn't some new information.
- vsareto 5y agoPlenty of videos of people in the crowd caught saying that they were seeking the chamber and congressional members to stop the certification. Admitting you’re trying to stop the process is an act of resistance against the government.
- gruez 5y ago>> It was a protest turned aggressive, it was in no way an insurrection, no evidence has been presented that was the intent of the group what so ever. >[...] Admitting you’re trying to stop the process is an act of resistance against the government. So you're saying resisting the government = insurrection? Is picketing outside of government offices (ie. the kind where you block people/cars from entering/leaving a building) an "insurrection"? Or does it only apply to capitols? Suppose you got a bunch of picketers to surround your state capitol, and representatives couldn't enter, would that be an insurrection?
- cogman10 5y agoThere's a pretty clear dividing line in the fact that violence was involved or attempted. So, yes, you can picket government buildings all you want, but the moment you start killing security and seeking to kill representatives, you've insurrected or are a party to an insurrection. > Insurrection - a violent uprising against an authority or government.
- gruez 5y ago>There's a pretty clear dividing line in the fact that violence was involved or attempted. BLM protests can get pretty violent. Are they insurrections?
- cogman10 5y agoNo, they are riots, because they are missing the second half of the insurrection requirement. > a violent uprising against an authority or government. 2 elements needed to be insurrection, Violence, and against authority or government. BLM riots are violent, but not targeted at the government. The Jan 6 insurrection was both violent and against the government. They disrupted government operations to try and change the results of an election. Can you find a definition of insurrection that wouldn't include the Jan 6 riots? Can you name a BLM riot which was targeted at the government?
- abduhl 5y agoWhat about this one? "Portland protest declared a riot Sunday as federal building is breached" https://nypost.com/2020/07/26/portland-protest-declared-a-riot-sunday-as-federal-building-is-breached/ https://nypost.com/2020/07/26/portland-protest-declared-a-ri... In fact, wouldn't all of the BLM movements accurately be described as targeted at the government because they were explicitly aimed at enacting change in government institutions like the police? In another post you say that "until a BLM protest attempts to use force to overthrow a city, state, or federal government, it's a riot at best when violence is involved." But how do you classify the CHAZ in Seattle, where force was used to overthrow city and state governments and establish an "autonomous" zone where guns and violence were the only recognized power by the occupiers?
- cogman10 5y ago> It was a protest turned aggressive We call that a riot.
- giantg2 5y agoYou mean how they got as far as prison?
- tamaharbor 5y agoI think if it were a real coup, they would have brought weapons.
- twofornone 5y agoA key point that many people seem to miss. A band of unhinged, bloodthirsty right wingers, staged a preempted coup, targeting politicians, and did not bring the guns that they're famous for amassing? Clearly this was not what it's being made out to be. Never let a crisis go to waste I suppose...
- beams_of_light 5y agoBut did enter the Capitol building with hand held weapons, body armor, zip ties to subdue people, and were heard talking about locating members of Congress. Enough with the disingenuousness.
- twofornone 5y agoBut no guns. Why would they plan a violent insurrection/coup without guns? Moreover, the "handheld weapons" consisted largely of sticks and flagpoles, with some bearspray...you know, things you'd bring to a riot? And zipties were found on one or two participants. The only disingenuousness here is the attempt to manufacture an insurrection out of a riot.
- beams_of_light 5y agoSeveral of the insurrectionists did have guns. The protest began peacefully, and turned violent following Trump's speech, where he urged the crowd to "fight like hell". These people aren't normal like you and I. They are extremely impressionable and subject to radicalization. Listen to the Channel 5 interview with the QAnon Shaman on YouTube. Does that strike you as someone that is capable of functioning in civil society?
- danans 5y ago> Why would they plan a violent insurrection/coup without guns? To minimize the chances they got shot at by police (only 1 person was). They wanted to overturn the election, not die. But just in case they needed it, this group had an armed backup force waiting at a hotel in VA: https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/legal-issues/quick-reaction-force-capitol-riot/2021/04/14/2021da66-9d39-11eb-8005-bffc3a39f6d3_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/legal-issues/quick-reac...
- fallingknife 5y agoThey only got that far because they were deemed (correctly) to be not a real threat and allowed in. The police could have mowed them down but they (rightly) decided it was better to just let it go and be embarrassed than to slaughter rioters in front of the capitol. Same goes for BLM rioters. I'd rather be in a country that allows a bit of chaos rather than using the full, deadly force of the state.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoSorry, but that's ridiculous. There's no scenario where a bunch of cops with pistols would have opened fire on a crowd that large. They would have been instantly overwhelmed.
- fallingknife 5y ago1. Cops in the US have a lot more than pistols. Assault rifles, flash bangs, tear gas, not quite tanks, f'ing helicopter gunships. 2. Live fire was way more than these guys bargained for. If they heard gunshots, even just pistol fire, and saw bodies dropping they would have scattered.
- beams_of_light 5y agoThe insurrectionists at the Capitol killed and injured Capitol police officers. If Mike Pence had been complicit with their wishes not to certify the election, we'd be living in a dictatorship. It was a very serious and pivotal moment for the country.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ryan93 5y agoYes it was a riot. No evidence any cops were killed
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIf Mike Pence had been complicit, they wouldn't have needed the rioters. I agree that "it" was serious, but the "it" was Trump's attempt to not certify the results of the election, not so much the protest/demonstration/riot/incursion into the Capitol. Mike Pence did what he was supposed to, under severe pressure to do otherwise. The country (especially the left) owes him a huge debt of gratitude.
- abduhl 5y ago
- jonnybgood 5y agoIt's irrelevant as to whether they could have seized power or not. What matters is the attempt to do so.
- LordEthano 5y agoSo a random moron who tweets "I want to start a coup", and brings a baseball bat to the white house tried to start a coup? If it's irrelevant as to their chances of success, it certainly seems like that's a coup.
- cogman10 5y agoCan you make a distinction between a terrorist and a crazy person committing suicide by detonating an explosive vest?
- gruez 5y agoWhy is is it not relevant? Surely there's a difference between a bunch of people LARPing as terrorists[1], and a bunch of ex-spec ops soldiers that actually have a plan? [1] https://twitter.com/thegrugq/status/1314237833276612609 https://twitter.com/thegrugq/status/1314237833276612609
- voisin 5y agoMaybe not have seized power but they certainly could have killed a number of elected officials including Pelosi and Pense. That might have had a stifling effect on future elected officials who otherwise would not have listened to the President’s wishes. It’s about making ground, inch by inch.
- shrimpx 5y agoThe coup is not about the people with trump flags seizing power. It's about trump and congresspeople inside the building trying to reject the vote certification by using the anger of the people outside as justification. And yes, there's a plausible way GOP could have seized power. It's hard to see beyond the total national chaos that rejecting the certification would have caused, but the chaos would have absolutely been an asset to the coup attempt.
- gruez 5y ago>It's about trump and congresspeople inside the building trying to reject the vote certification by using the anger of the people outside as justification. And yes, there's a plausible way GOP could have seized power. According to that logic, does any sort of protest outside the capitol = "coup attempt"? After all, you don't need to actually need people breaking in to cite "anger of the people outside".
- danans 5y ago> According to that logic, does any sort of protest outside the capitol = "coup attempt"? No, because other types of protests outside the Capitol (i.e. over abortion, environmental issues, civil rights, war), and their related tactics within Congress are not aimed at stopping the constitutional process of certifying a lawful election. That's is quite literally what differentiates a coup from the others: A coup uses force and threat to unlawfully take control of the government. Normal protests outside the Capitol are about influencing the legislative process, which is a completely different function of Congress. But even then, it would be unlawful to influence the legislative process by threat or use of force.
- gruez 5y agoSo it's only a coup if it's "aimed at stopping the constitutional process of formalizing a lawful election"? Why is the "constitutional process of" passing bills not protected? responding to your edits: >That's is quite literally what differentiates a coup from the others: A coup uses force and threat to unlawfully take control of the government. But using force to prevent the legislature from functioning when they're not certifying elections is fine? >Normal protests outside the Capitol are about influencing the legislative process, which is a completely different function of Congress. But even then, it would be unlawful to influence the legislative process by threat or use of force. I'm specifically talking about protests that involve denying access to the legislature, not just a bunch of people protesting in the free speech zone.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> there's no plausible way the people there would have seized power. Sure, there is. Make Pence incapable of presiding, convince (this may not be necessary if the person is already a sympathizer), by inducements or threats, the person acting as President of the Senate to act in the manner Trump and various political allies had encouraged Pence to and which Pence had refused and simply decline to present certain state electoral votes, denying an immediate majority and either requesting friendly state legislatures to send alternate ballots, or preceding to vote by states in each house in the absence of a majority. The “they couldn't have seized power” argument only works when you consider the people physically inside the Capitol as a separate force completely unrelated to the people that set out the goals in writing, the people that—publicly and unambiguously—told the people to go to the Capitol to get Congress to follow the goals set out in writing, and the people in State legislatures and in Congress who had publicly backed the goals set out in writing. Which is a bizarre level of willful blindness.
- lokar 5y agoThe point was had they been more successful (kill a few congressman, take some hostage) trump could have successfully declared martial law and stayed in power.
- ModernMech 5y ago> there's no plausible way the people there would have seized power. The sitting President was the one who attempted the coup. He didn't need to seize power -- he already held power. The objective of the insurrection on Jan 6 was to prevent the transfer of power, which they absolutely almost did.