6 ms·
Knee-jerk "better safe than sorry" decisions often do more harm than good. There was no conceivable threat from a random North Korean missle test to an airplane
by paxys 5y ago
Knee-jerk "better safe than sorry" decisions often do more harm than good. There was no conceivable threat from a random North Korean missle test to an airplane in Burbank, CA, and that was quickly determined by people who have the responsibility of making such assessments (NORAD). Why then did a random FAA official decide otherwise?
- GordonS 5y agoThe cynic in me says it could have been a propaganda move - as in, the authorities knew there wasn't a credible threat, but it suits their narrative to have the media latching on to it. Because the media are guaranteed to have the story grow FUD-cladded arms and legs.
- KarlKemp 5y agoI have no earthly idea what “narrative“ you are referring to, or what kind of FUD you expect the media to spread. The story will either just disappear because nothing really happened, or it will be about “overly cautious” vs “better safe than sorry”, as this thread is.
- tobyjsullivan 5y agoNations rattling their sabres is just background noise to busy people trying to live their private lives. Grounding my flight for 10 minutes, though? That makes it real and tangible.
- mateo1 5y agoIt could be that the planes could interfere with the long range early warning system. Something that you really don't want to happen for a multitude of reasons. A ten minute delay is barely a minor inconvenience, and a good call to make imho even if it's for all for nothing.
- dragontamer 5y ago> It could be that the planes could interfere with the long range early warning system. "Interference" is one possible way to call it. Another is "US Military getting ready to blast all objects in the sky with counter-nukes", and airplanes really don't want to be in the crossfire right now. I don't really know how the US missile-defense system works. I'm imagining that old 1980s arcade game "Missile Command" though...
- throwaway946513 5y ago> US Military getting ready to blast all objects in the sky with counter-nukes. The missile-defense system work by using SAMs (Surface-to-Air Missiles). Having a nuke counter an ICBM will lead to far worse fallout. While you're correct, the planes don't want to be in that crossfire, the missile targeting system would more than easily account for civilian aircraft and avoid them.
- dragontamer 5y ago> The missile-defense system work by using SAMs (Surface-to-Air Missiles). Having a nuke counter an ICBM will lead to far worse fallout. While you're correct, the planes don't want to be in that crossfire, the missile targeting system would more than easily account for civilian aircraft and avoid them. ICBMs travel in excess of Mach 10, and typical SAMs are Mach 1 to Mach 5. -------- Instead of using a small explosive to bring down an enemy nuke, surely there's an idea to use a bigger counter-nuke? Sure, there's going to be a ton of fallout, but that's still better than losing the entirety of San Francisco. Its a lot easier to hit an enemy missile with a big-bomb, rather than using a little bomb. IE: load those SAMs with nukes and have at it. Even if you're slower, you got the strength and blast-radius of a nuke and have a better chance of bringing down the enemy ICBM. ------ I don't think its an issue of "airplanes would be hit by a SAM". I think it's seriously the risk of airplanes literally getting caught in the blasts (that were aimed at the enemy missile).
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Instead of using a small explosive to bring down an enemy nuke, surely there's an idea to use a bigger counter-nuke? Yes; Russia protects Moscow with such a system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-135_anti-ballistic_missile_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A-135_anti-ballistic_missile_s...
- logifail 5y ago> A ten minute delay is barely a minor inconvenience, and a good call to make imho even if it's for all for nothing Except that argument sounds like an incentive to have a ten minute delay for any potential issue, no matter how little data you have and how unlikely the outcome.
- mateo1 5y agoI'm fine with having a 10-minute flight delay every time a rogue nation fires an experimental ICBM in a desperate attempt to maintain its sovereignty.
- dragontamer 5y ago> I'm fine with having a 10-minute flight delay every time a rogue nation fires an experimental ICBM in a desperate attempt to maintain its sovereignty. Agreed. North Korea is now nuclear-armed. Every single one of those ICBMs could have a nuke on it now.
- logifail 5y ago> Every single one of those ICBMs could have a nuke on it now If only there were a central agency tasked providing aerospace warning, air sovereignty, and protection for Northern America. We could call it something like the "North American Aerospace Defense Command". It could have decades of experience of this stuff! OTOH perhaps the FAA should just make up stuff as they go.
- dragontamer 5y ago> If only there were a central agency tasked providing aerospace warning, air sovereignty, and protection for Northern America. They do exist. Talk to them, or read what they have to say. EDIT: This is the good ol' "Star Wars" missile defense problem, its been discussed for decades. I'm not myself fully up to date with it, but there's a ton of information online from Senate Hearings / House Hearings on whether or not building this missile defense was worthwhile. They aren't really that confident in the probabilities of success in stopping a nuclear-armed ICBM. They're gonna try but its not like anyone has ever actually shot a nuke at the USA yet. The ultimate test of pragmatism has never happened yet.
- jonathankoren 5y agoIt’s not really a good early warning system if regular daily aircraft traffic that’s been around since before radar was invented can interfere with it. If this was the case, the system would be unfieldable.
- dragontamer 5y agoAn ICBM travels at Mach 10 to Mach 20, while your typical SAM travels at Mach 1 to Mach 5. The fact of the matter is: missile-defense is significantly harder than missile-offense. Especially at the ICBM levels. There's almost no certainty that we can stop an ICBM. We have untested systems and untested warning systems that the Soviet Union never even bothered to test. But now there's a rogue nation trying to play tough guy sitting across the Pacific Ocean with nuclear weapons and an experimental ICBM platform. If an ICBM gets launched, the USA is probably going to throw everything we got to try to stop the missile. Then we'll probably fail, and the city will get nuked anyway. But we gotta do everything within our power to make the probability of success as high as possible. ----- San Francisco, Los Angeles, etc. etc. Any of those cities could be lost within a few minutes under these scenarios. If people are saying that this airplane stop-order was over a nuke, I think its actually 100% reasonable to have done these stop-flying orders.
- jonathankoren 5y agoAn ICBM also comes in on well known great circle paths from suborbital altitudes. Not 30,000 feet or less. These aren’t secrets. They’re well publicized facts that haven’t changed since the 1950s.
- dragontamer 5y agoThe "secrets" are how good our radar systems are at tracking a Mach 20 object in space. That sort of stuff is classified and no one seems to be speaking about that. Yes, we know what path it probably will take, but to actually _HIT_ such a target requires extremely precise tracking and positioning. What we do know, is that they ground the entire West Coast's airplanes when an ICBM from North Korea is launched. My guess is that those radars probably work better when there's fewer airplanes in the sky. Hard to know for sure, the spooks don't seem to be talking about the details. But I'm working backwards here with Occam's razor.
- johannes1234321 5y agoWhat a great power for Kim. A simulated rocket launch and massive interruptions in the USA. Better his dreams can't be ...
- ceejayoz 5y agoIt was a 10-15 minute stop. That seems like a fairly quick determination on the FAA's part, too.
- smabie 5y agoBecause if something bad happened, a bunch of FAA would lose their jobs. When you see very risk adverse decisions like this, it's usually because some person or a group of people don't want to get fired in the off chance something goes wrong.
- colechristensen 5y agoI don't think anyone seriously doubts the possibility that DPRK will some day have missiles which could threaten the US west coast, they're certainly trying. What we seem to have here is a failsafe, and the right decision. The key word there is "fail", because that's what it looks like. Some internal line of communication or process broken to the extent that somebody somewhere put out an order to ground planes. (or possibly a deliberate live readiness test) You want to fail safe, the cost of briefly inconveniencing aviation is incomparable to the cost of screwing up defenses in the case of a real attack. Failing like this also gets a lot of attention which will motivate people to fix whatever the issues were that lead to it. I'd just think of it as a test case highlighting a bug. I don't know what great harm could come from it.
- dragonwriter 5y agoI’m not even sure there was a fixable problem; this seems to be something where you want the grounding order near-automatic on a path that doesn't have too much review in the loop and even a cancellation after quick review on a less instant, more certain 9f correctness path. If it is a real attack, delay can be critical, if it's not after the grounding order goes out, a slight delay in cancellation doesn't make a big difference.
- colechristensen 5y agoReading into the scant evidence, this would seem to be a call NORAD would make, didn’t in this circumstance, and somebody between the decision maker at NORAD and the person who sends the message to air traffic control made the call because they didn’t have full information, couldn’t get the right information in time, or didn’t have full knowledge of the protocol and got nervous.
- idealmedtech 5y ago> Failing like this also gets a lot of attention which will motivate people to fix whatever the issues were that lead to it. That's a really fantastic point! What may initially be perceived as government incompetence is _really_ just a self correcting negative social feedback loop! Thanks for the unique perspective on this, have you worked in any of these agencies?
- hammock 5y agoThe first plane hit the WTC at 08:46. A Groundstop (for NY area) wasn't issued on 9/11 until 9:06, 20 minutes after this event and 3 minutes after the second plane hit. Flight 93 took off at 08:42, four minutes before the first plane hit the towers. Additionally, it was known well before the groundstop order that Flight 77 had already deviated at 08:54 and turned off its transponder at 08:56. A "better safe than sorry" groundstop may have saved lives impacted by Flight 77 (Pentagon attack), even more if Flight 93 (PA crash) had been delayed by several minutes more. I'm sure this has something to do with the calculus.
- sigmar 5y ago>no conceivable threat from a random North Korean missle test to an airplane in Burbank, CA I assume it is more about anti-ballistic missile activity and not wanting a mistake to happen where the US gov't takes down a passenger flight(?)
- tunesmith 5y ago> Knee-jerk "better safe than sorry" decisions often do more harm than good. Isn't this kind of a tautological statement? If there's a low probability of high damage, and that high damage ends up not happening, then two things happened. First, a small amount of "harm" happens from the extra caution. Second, it did "no good" since the bad thing didn't happen. So, by definition it did more harm than good. Which is a good thing in the big picture. To believe otherwise is to basically invalidate any scenario of applying caution to low-probability high-damage scenarios.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 5y agoA couple of interesting assumptions in that comment. First is an assumption that the capabilities of the missile being tested are "known" and a follow on assumption that the PRK does not have the capability of flying a missile as far west as Burbank, CA. Neither of these are very good assumptions to make. To understand why, consider the following; KP's collaborates with both the Russian Federation and China on weapons development (multiple open sources) and both of those nations have missile technology that can go from anywhere in North Korea to pretty much anywhere in the US. KP has been telling people they have a working hypersonic ballistic missile (travel time Korea to the west coast at ~ 1hr without going sub-orbital.) The US and KP are technically still at war (the Korean war stopped with a cease fire, not a treaty) and the US and its allies levy sanctions on them that hurt. So while in previous tests it was both not widely believed that KP could reach the US and the KP had not said they could reach the US, both of those positions changed. That changed the threat posture from "zero" threat to "some" threat. Fortunately physics is physics and it's pretty clear after 10 to 15 minutes what a missile is doing and what it might be able to do. As a result I don't really think this was a "knee jerk" decision, I think it's likely policy going forward until better clarity is available on how rapidly KP's missile technology advances and an effective counter can be put into place.
- javajosh 5y agoI'm curious what you think would happen if KP nukes a city or two in the US. I presume we'd nuke them back, but then what? How does the rest of the world react? How would SK and China, in particular react? Surely this is a known plan?
- BeKindAndLearn 5y agoEveryone would look the other way and offer thoughts and prayers. North Korea would be largely vaporized and neither China nor South Korea would prolong the issue and risk total nuclear annihilation of humanity.
- javajosh 5y agoThere would be significant collateral damage to nuking the KP, including to a close ally. Plus, given the prevailing winds, fallout may even drift west all the way to the west coast of the USA. So perhaps we nuke one of their cities, and then begin a full scale conventional invasion? And of course during the chaos Russia takes Ukraine, NATO curses and gnashes teeth but the US has KW2 on its hands and does nothing.
- drzaiusapelord 5y agoNORAD: There's no way our anti-missile and anti-air would hit one of our planes by mistake. We're a professional military! FAA: Iran had a professional military too. And the Soviets and Russians too, and its happened there. NORAD: Fuck you. FAA: We're grounding to keep people safe, the military industrial complex is out of control, dangerous, and a threat to American well being. I side with the FAA. Military systems are extremely dangerous around civilians and the kool-aid the military drinks in terms of their effectiveness and safety doesn't often mesh with reality. The military runs killing machines and when those machines are active its best to get people out of the way. There are no safe killing machines.
- betterunix2 5y agoIt is worth reviewing the KAL007 incident to understand why you see this kind of reaction. The USSR was doing a missile test, the US was flying a surveillance plane just outside Soviet airspace, and just prior to that the US had been deliberating flying planes directly toward Soviet airspace only to turn them around at the last moment. Reagan had been talking tough and the USSR military leaders thought he might actually order a preemptive strike. Then KAL007 takes off from Alaska with its autopilot incorrectly configured, flies right into Soviet territory, and Soviet air defense had to decide if this unidentified plane was the US military finally being bold enough to fly right into their space. When KAL finally contacting Japanese ATC they were told to ascend, which to the Soviet fight pilot sent to intercept looked just like an evasive maneuver. The plane was shot down with no survivors, killing a member of Congress (just imagine how easily the situation could have escalated from there if Reagan really was as out of control as the Soviets thought). So yeah, better safe than sorry when you have a tense moment in between two hostile, nuclear-armed nations. I would rather see a bunch of travelers deal with the inconvenience of cascading delays than see some US air defense system shoot a plane out of the sky.