4 ms·
I'm usually a free speech absolutist and privacy advocate, but whomever is sending that poor woman's parents videos of her torture and beheading deserves to be
by echelon 5y ago
I'm usually a free speech absolutist and privacy advocate, but whomever is sending that poor woman's parents videos of her torture and beheading deserves to be banned from the Internet forever. At minimum.
I can't imagine how those poor people must feel.
- causi 5y agoBeing against harassment doesn't make you any less a believer in free speech.
- fivea 5y ago> Being against harassment doesn't make you any less a believer in free speech. The validity if your statement depends heavily on what's your personal definition of free speech, and where you draw the line regarding acceptable censorship and persecution from the state. Considering the spectrum of free speech includes absolutists who argue speech can only be free if it's free from any consequences from the state, there's a huge grey zone on where to draw the line.
- causi 5y agoIndeed. Personally I think we could solve a lot of our problems by offering users robust content filtering controls and teaching people to use them as a basic life skill.
- dncornholio 5y agoHow do you categorise content though? You seem to think it's an easy problem..
- causi 5y agoIt doesn't have to be that complicated. Blacklist certain words and phrases. In this case, the people are being sent videos of a murder. Silently block all media content from non-whitelisted users, or any video that falls within a certain range of lengths. On a larger scale, content filtering rules can get more complicated and can be collaborated upon and shared. If we can do it with advertisements we can do it with offensive content.
- dncornholio 5y agoBlocking users is useless, they will make new account. Blocking words is useless, they will use fake words. Block on hash is useless, they will distort the video to generate new hash.
- bigfudge 5y agoI'm not sure any of the those points is true always, and at the very least will raise the bar slightly. Blocking on a naive hash wouldn't work, but there are more sophisticated video matching algorithm. If they're good enough to be applied to DMCA type content, this seems like a higher priority.
- wccrawford 5y agoBullies don't stop when a few people ignore them. That just creates an echo chamber, and they get more bold. Bullies stop when you punch them in the nose. Offering people "content filtering controls" might work in a small population where bullies could get ignored completely after a short time, but IME it doesn't even work then. What does work is when the community stops them cold by banning them. But not everyone is a bully, so the system needs to be more nuanced than that, with warnings and lesser punishments before the final ban. Personal filters are a good thing because it allows people to go beyond the rules and filter out things that bother them personally, and even to stop the bullying personally while the community works out that the bully will not stop. But it's the first step, not the last.
- chii 5y ago> what's your personal definition of free speech there's no personal definition imho - free speech is the allowance of the citizens to say anything, regardless of whether the state wants it heard or not. Free speech isn't the idea that other people must have the opportunity to hear one's speech. So sending emails or photos to people (ostensibly to harass) doesn't constitute free speech.
- himinlomax 5y agoI believe it was Chomsky who defined what we mean by freedom of speech would be more appropriately defined as freedom of opinion. Harassment, calls to violence, inciting panic and defamation are not opinions.
- throwoutway 5y agoI think I can agree with that. Although defamation is probably a grey area. If I say, “the vice president is corrupt and unintelligent”, should I not be allowed to speak that opinion?
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoThat’s an opinion though. Defamation has a very specific definition, often with a high bar. This would be like “the Vice President accepted a bribe of ten thousand dollars to inject a support of terrorism in their past speech on January 5, and I have film evidence to prove it” explicitly knowing this is false and saying it anyways just to hurt the Vice President.
- xwolfi 5y agoFree speech is nothing to be absolute about. Things that were encouraged before can become absolutely abject later on - free speech in the public sphere must be regulated, and is in many jurisdiction (I'm French, I live in China - both are very similar in how they approach it in principle, China is more ideological when implementing but France can go very far when someone must stop talking). I'm glad that as an absolutist, you managed to make a compromise, even if it's just for beheading. How can we convince you rape, insults, religious conflict, racism apology, or even treasonous discourse also can be regulated ? What is so good about stupidity that it has to be exposed so free to the public or what is so special about it that it can't be distinguished from intelligence ?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Nevermark 5y agoI don't think there is a conflict between a right for absolute speech (on a practical level) and being held responsible for direct and foreseeable harm without a mitigating reason. I.e. nobody can shut your mouth, or stop you from speaking, but there can still be consequences if your speech is directly aimed at unjustifiable harassment. For instance, simply making the video available on a web site would be protected speech (no restriction on that) - assuming no other law was conflicted (copyright, etc.) But going out of one's way to push the speech to those it harms, and on services that prohibit it, creates a problem independent of the freedom to simply speak/publish. Likewise, you can publish technical secrets you were given under a nondisclosure agreement, but will be prosecuted civilly and possibly criminally (depending on circumstances) for the damage you have done to intellectual property value. You can claim anything you want for some product, but expect to pay for it legally if you are defrauding people. You can publish any code you want, source or object code, but expect to pay the consequences if you are publishing code that doesn't belong to you, or violating an open source license by only publishing in one form, without providing the required form, or without proper attribution. Etc. For all those cases, nobody limits your speech, but direct consequences of your speech can still result in enforcement action.
- 5y ago
- lottin 5y agoBanned from the internet? These scumbags need to be hunted down and be given long jail sentences, at the very least.
- jka 5y agoYes, it's an awful and unacceptable situation. Different people have different ways of responding to harassment based on their risk acceptance and resilience: some people respond and fight back, some people hide, and some people seek help from others around them (the latter is, it seems to me, probably generally the healthiest approach, although I'm no expert). What the parent post seems to be advocating for is that tech companies should automatically attempt to hide people from harm, and that they're best-placed to do that. I think it's doubtable whether they'll be able and willing to implement that in an effective or accurate manner (partly because it requires putting significant time, money and staffing into it, it can never be completely automated, and attackers -- especially in individual or small cases -- evolve as the representative mentions in the quote), and I don't think it respects or empowers victims, long-term. It's also key to focus on the perpetrators - hold them accountable and figure out the reasons why this happened in the first place.
- lamontcg 5y agoFree speech absolutists are probably going to wind up losing us our freedom of speech. Its good that you're exploring what the limits are and that you have found a limit. Those need to be clarified.