6 ms·
RSV is more dangerous than COVID-19 for most small children. We don't shut down society because of RSV. https://www.medscape.com/answers/971488-177692/what-is-
by nradov 5y ago
RSV is more dangerous than COVID-19 for most small children. We don't shut down society because of RSV.
https://www.medscape.com/answers/971488-177692/what-is-the-prognosis-of-respiratory-syncytial-virus-rsvinfection https://www.medscape.com/answers/971488-177692/what-is-the-p...
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> RSV is more dangerous than COVID-19 for most small children. Children don’t exist in isolation. They’re phenomenally good at spreading every infection to the rest of the household and everywhere else they go. Trying to focus on children's outcomes and ignoring all of the second-order effects is dishonest. Children don’t live alone.
- BTCOG 5y ago
- nradov 5y agoThe other members of the household are already vaccinated for COVID-19 if they want to be. The vaccines are still highly effective at preventing deaths. RSV isn't really safe for adults either. But we accept the risk.
- meatsauce 5y agoSo effective, you go from 98.999% recoverable to 99.998% recoverable. Amazing. So glad we shut down everything and destroyed countless lives for less than 1% of gain.
- hcknwscommenter 5y agoYour numbers are . . . oddly chosen. Nevertheless, consider the following: Calculate (1-(98.99/100)7.753 billion to get 78 million deaths Calculate (1-(99.998/100)7.753 billion to get 155,060 deaths. That seems like really good progress.
- neuronic 5y ago
- bb88 5y ago"Germ Casserole" is the term I've heard used for schools from K through College during flu and cold season.
- 8note 5y agoThe concern raised is "everyone and their dog is getting omicron, and I'm worried about my child getting it when they aren't vaccinated" Everyone else already has it, and have access to vaccines
- jtbayly 5y agoThe GP explicitly says he is concerned for his child, and that's the only thing under discussion in this thread. In that context, it's worth pointing out that RSV is more dangerous to help people think about how they process this current risk.
- Diesel555 5y agoIt has been frustrating to see how these two non-mutually exclusive points have been used to debate each other. We talk around each other and can't have a logical conversation.
- oxymoran 5y agoRight, so get vaccinated and get on with your life.
- rhino369 5y agoIt's society's job to protect children, not the other way around. Closing schools while opening bars is huge failure of leadership.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y ago
- notch656a 5y ago
- mavhc 5y agoLine 1: I'd like to protect them from becoming orphans Line 2: Agreed, close bars, no one needs more drug addicts
- amatecha 5y agoyou could be like BC and keep everything open! at least it's consistent! -_-
- rhino369 5y agoOmicron is so contagious that its going to burn through regardless of moderate mitigation techniques. NYC went from 1 case to 40,000 in a month. Even if you lock down for 3 months to get back to 0. We'd be back to 40,000 the second we reopened. Delay isn't worth anything unless hospitals are so bad people will die from preventable deaths.
- amatecha 5y ago
- tomjakubowski 5y agoI don't have numbers handy, but I would suspect that at least 10x more Americans caught Covid at work as out partying. If only because people spend more time at work. Only about a third of American households had anyone working from home during the pandemic. https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/03/working-from-home-during-the-pandemic.html https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/03/working-from-...
- golemiprague 5y agoBut what it got to do with vaccination? Children are going to still spread it whether they are vaccinated or not. There are some claims about vaccination reducing the load and therefore reducing infection of other people but I find it a very hard to control type of research and seeing so many vaccinated getting corona I don't think it is so significant in protecting other people and preventing spread. Maybe just a little bit, but how do you measure how much is the right amount in order to make kids getting the vaccination more beneficial overall than not?
- disambiguation 5y ago> Children don’t exist in isolation. They’re phenomenally good at spreading every infection to the rest of the household and everywhere else they go. This really is _the_ important point of contention. Phrased differently: Does viral spread in one cohort drive the viral spread in another? And can policy be designed to drive wedges between cohorts to reduce such co-factors? That being said, as it stands, the data doesn't support your claim. It seems child activity is largely independent of spread among adults. https://academic.oup.com/cid/article/72/12/e1146/6024998 https://academic.oup.com/cid/article/72/12/e1146/6024998 15 June 2021, Meta-analysis > Children are Infrequently Identified as the Index Case of Household SARS-CoV-2 Clusters > In analysis of the cluster index cases ... only 3.8% were identified as having a pediatric index case. > These pediatric cases only caused 4.0% of all secondary cases, compared with the 97.8% of secondary cases that occurred when an adult was identified as the index case in the cluster. > Clusters where the asymptomatic/symptomatic status of the contact cases was not described were excluded from the analysis. Even with this broader definition, 18.5% children were identified as the index case in the household clusters.
- imgabe 5y agoAnd as TFA says, the rest of society is “vaxxed and done”. So why are we harming children by closing schools to “protect” people who are going out to bars and restaurants?
- edmundsauto 5y agoAnd we aren’t shutting society down because of the risk of C19 to small children either. The risk to children is part of that, but the risk to the adults who care for them is another reason. Additionally, staffing levels are impacted because the adults who have it. Also, generically, when we have a super spreadable disease, we want to minimize transmission. This is done as a precaution against mutation (the more infections mean more mutations!) and because we don’t have a good idea what the long term effects are. If you only look at the daycare closures in isolation, you’re not doing the calculus for the system. If there is one thing we’re learning during Covid, it’s how interconnected we all are. Finally, is the acceptance of RSV a result of a good public health decision? Or have we, as a society, just massively underindexed on ignoring public health?
- SubiculumCode 5y agoAt this point, Omicron is looking like its going to vaccinate a large portion of the population, especially the more folks resistant to vaccination. My hope is that Omicron is the real first step to herd immunity.
- swader999 5y agoNo, it'll live and mutate in deer, rodents cats etc. Won't see herd immunity ever. Even this 'natural' vaccine won't distribute fast enough to outrun the pace of its mutations.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThe more varieties of coronavirii that we encounter, the more our immune system will build a broad-spectrum response to that "class" of virus. To be clear, I am not saying that the coronavirus is going to disappear. I'm saying that it will become closer to a common cold over time.
- jquery 5y agoLet’s hope.
- 5y ago
- aljones 5y agoWhy the hyperbole?
- neuronic 5y agoHow is it so hard for you people to understand that we shut down society because the health system is stressed at unforeseen levels? I mean just ask your fellow emergency workers how their life is right now.
- rajup 5y agoStressed by the numerous asymptomatic hypochondriacs you mean? [1] I have no idea what these asymptomatic folks are wasting hospital resources for [1] https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/coronavirus/ny-covid-cases-top-90k-as-dozens-of-upstate-hospitals-halt-elective-surgeries/3486369/?amp https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/coronavirus/ny-covid-cases-t...
- runako 5y agoThe major hospitals in my (Top 10 American) metro area are currently doing patient "diversion." In practice, this means that they are not accepting most trauma patients, elective surgeries like cancer removals are being delayed, and patient care for non-Covid conditions is being impacted. This is primarily due to the hospitals being at/over capacity. These hospitals are not admitting hypochondriacs, the folks taking up the beds are sick and need to be hospitalized.
- neuronic 5y ago
- BTCOG 5y agoUh, it factually is a coronavirus, of which several are already endemic "colds," and within another year or two (or so) we are looking at this also becoming "just another cold." This is the meaning of currently talking about the virus becoming endemic. It's here to stay like our other colds that should be added, were also deadly when they first started.
- 5y ago
- kingsloi 5y agoMy little girl was eligible for the RSV vaccine, as she was immunocompromised. It sucks watching/hearing our friend's kids being hospitalised by it, knowing there's a vaccine for it, but it's so expensive ($3000-$6000 /yr /child), unless covered by insurance (if eligible), that it's out of reach for most families.
- Vecr 5y agoIt's not a (active) vaccine, it's monoclonal antibodies, if it was a trial vaccine it would not cost that much.
- kingsloi 5y agoSorry, it was naive of me to call it a vaccine, it’s just what it was referred to, or RSV shot. There are vaccines for RSV in the works though, hopefully give people better access to preventive medicine
- georgeburdell 5y agoRSV is the worst virus I've had in a decade, probably since I had shingles in my twenties. My daughter brought it home from daycare and both my partner and I had a low-grade fever for 2 weeks, and a bad dry cough for another 2 weeks after that that would wake us up multiple times a night. Daughter bounced back in about half the time. By contrast, Covid hit us all recently and we were all 100% within the week. Your mileage may vary.