8 ms·
The problem is that "market" is a really bad fit for meeting healthcare needs, and doubly so when it's intermediated by insurers. People get the amount of healt
by pjc50 5y ago
The problem is that "market" is a really bad fit for meeting healthcare needs, and doubly so when it's intermediated by insurers. People get the amount of healthcare they can afford from their discretionary budget and work their insurers for - not the amount they need. So they may get "more" (or at least more expensive) care than they need, or less.
Note that many of the European systems are semi-private, so you retain choice of providers. It doesn't need to be a full state-run system, which is vulnerable to undercapacity (which the UK is currently suffering from).
There's also an informational problem; in a fully free speech environment it's much easier to sell people unreliable cures, Theranos passim.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoMarket is a fine fit for every healthcare need that doesn't start with a trip to the ER which is the overwhelming majority of healthcare dispensed in the US. Using insurance, government or some other centralizing layer (e.g. the church) for routine activity would raise massive "you're pissing money away" red flags in literally any other context. We shoehorn so much economic activity (healthcare) though a middle man (insurers) and then act surprised that they take a fat cut. The solution isn't to government-ize the middle man. That will almost certainly just be a wash. It's to get rid of the middle man where possible. There's no reason someone shouldn't be able to get a physical or a colonoscopy the same way cosmetic surgery and dental care are done. These are cookie cutter outpatient services. The deviation from instance to instance is small and predictable so insurance should not be needed on the consumer side. Edit: Anyone wanna do me the courtesy of explaining why I'm so wrong?
- netizen-936824 5y agoThe healthcare industry already pisses away huge amounts of money. Its evident in all those stories we hear about people getting a huge $5000+ medical bill, then calling the hospital and suddenly its $100 or less. That $4900 is literally all wasted
- andrekandre 5y ago> Edit: Anyone wanna do me the courtesy of explaining why I'm so wrong? just a guess, but it might be because of... Market is a fine fit for every healthcare need that doesn't start with a trip to the ER which is the overwhelming majority of healthcare dispensed in the US. ... one of the reasons most visits in the us is the er is precisely because preventative care is so expensive/hard-to-get in the u.s and people put off visiting the doctor regularly since its so expensive... the market isn't very amenable to these extra costs in the short run, whereas a state-run system might not have the same short-term cost concerns and encourage/subsidize regular visitation/preventative-care...
- nradov 5y agoPreventative care in the US isn't expensive or hard to get for most patients. Under the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) there are a wide range of preventive services that must be covered at no cost to the patient. While some coverage gaps remain, those plans cover the majority of US residents. https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/preventive-care-benefits/ https://www.healthcare.gov/coverage/preventive-care-benefits...
- nicoburns 5y agoWhat about treatment for severe conditions such as cancer or chronic conditions such as life-long disabilities where the expense is significant to the point that it may well be crippling for an individual but is rare enough that it's only a moderate cost spread across a society? These are the cases where insurance is a perfect fit. The issue with letting it be market-based insurance is that (as you say) it allows insurance providers to take a fat cut. The obvious solution is to regulate insurance costs. At which point you might as well state fund it. Which leads us to the system we have in most of Europe. As these system seem to work quite well, why do you think a market-based approach would be better?
- pjc50 5y ago> routine activity But as you observe yourself, that's not the majority of healthcare, which is emergencies and unforseeable needs. Hence there has to be an insurer of some kind. > There's no reason someone shouldn't be able to get a physical or a colonoscopy the same way cosmetic surgery and dental care are done. These are cookie cutter outpatient services. The deviation from instance to instance is small and predictable so insurance should not be needed on the consumer side. Sure, whatever, the small part of the healthcare market that actually functions like a market - consumer choice, legible prices - can be left to get on with it. Let's not let that get in the way of a functioning provision of necessary care to the majority of people.
- nmhancoc 5y agoI misunderstood your comment on first read, and looking at other replies others did as well. > Market is a fine fit for every healthcare need that doesn't start with a trip to the ER which is the overwhelming majority of healthcare dispensed in the US. I think most people are interpreting this as “market is a fine fit for every healthcare need [except for those that start in the ER] which is the overwhelming majority...” I.e. that you’re advocating the market for the majority of healthcare rather than the majority. I think your actual recommendation is the opposite. Maybe this would be clearer if you just laid it out like, “Most healthcare is non emergency, cost is a primary concern which insurance makes worse, markets are good at solving cost issues.” Responding to your actual argument, however, I see many people claim that insurance companies are taking a “fat cut”, but I see very little evidence of higher than expected ROI/ROE in Aetna / United / etc. (ref: United’s net margin is ~5%, ~15B in net income on 300B of revenue). ROE is ~20% which doesn’t seem ridiculous for an insurance business. The bigger problem seems to be personnel spending in healthcare (admin, support staff, billing), and generally a systemic culture that’s not even knowledgeable about what prices they charge, let alone price conscious in the services they deliver.
- nicoburns 5y ago> ~20% which doesn’t seem ridiculous for an insurance business. I think the issue with healthcare insurance companies in the US is that they collude with the hospitals to artificially inflate the cost of things so that their 20% is 20% of 10x the actual value of the treatment.
- zimpenfish 5y ago> a full state-run system, which is vulnerable to undercapacity (which the UK is currently suffering from) That's more because we've had decades of deliberate underfunding due to the "austerity"/"capitalism++" lunatics in charge than a natural consequence of a state-run system though.
- netizen-936824 5y agoGreed unfortunately seems to be an endemic issue. It creates these fanatics that want to leech on every part of the system imaginable, even if it means people die
- virgilp 5y agoBut how is that not "expected"? Feels like the argument that "communism is good, it just wasn't implemented well anywhere so far". Well, sorry, but by this point I chose to believe that a full state-run system is vulnerable to under-funding in the long term.
- netizen-936824 5y agoSo we should just expect people to be greedy and try to ruin systems for their own benefit. That raises the question of how to make these systems more robust to defend against that sort of attack.
- virgilp 5y agoExactly. Expecting people to be generous and collaborative and selfless and whatnot is just asking for trouble. Note that I'm not saying that people are not/ cannot be generous, selfless etc. I'm saying that relying on them being so is a crappy strategy. You need a system that continues to work in the presence of greedy people.
- vorpalhex 5y agoThat is the pro of a market system. A market with a malbehaving dominant party is liable to be upset by a new contender who will undercut them, thus depriving the misbehaving party of income.
- dgb23 5y agoI agree. The "everything is a market" ideology had a good run of almost half a century, but it should be heavily criticized in hindsight. Institutions like healthcare, education, public transport, prisons(!) and so on are more efficient, less corrupt and of higher quality when they are in large parts collectively and democratically organized and funded. The "in large parts" is important here: A community should agree on what that means and let the market play out on the edges, or the bureaucratic costs become too heavy _and_ unfair. Decentralization is key here.
- dqpb 5y ago> The "everything is a market" ideology had a good run of almost half a century But that never actually happened. Externalities were never part of the market.
- howdydoo 5y agoAre you suggesting that healthcare-as-a-market would start working if externalities were priced in? How would that help?
- donatj 5y agoI suspect the argument is "Healthcare has never been allowed to be a market" Given how many legal restrictions are placed on it, I tend to agree.
- tablespoon 5y ago> I suspect the argument is "Healthcare has never been allowed to be a market" Given how many legal restrictions are placed on it, I tend to agree. Emergency services aren't a good fit for markets. For markets to work, people really need the luxury to shop around with some leisure. Wasn't there some Roman oligarch that ran a private fire department, and basically just used it to extort property owners when they had a fire? Truly market based emergency medical care without legal restrictions would likely frequently resemble that with some frequency. Edit: Yep: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_firefighting#Rome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_firefighting#Rome > The first ever Roman fire brigade was created by Marcus Licinius Crassus. He took advantage of the fact that Rome had no fire department, by creating his own brigade—500 men strong—which rushed to burning buildings at the first cry of alarm. Upon arriving at the scene, however, the firefighters did nothing while Crassus offered to buy the burning building from the distressed property owner, at a miserable price. If the owner agreed to sell the property, his men would put out the fire, if the owner refused, then they would simply let the structure burn to the ground.
- dqpb 5y agoIn my book, it’s a big red flag when a market is intermediated by anyone. The whole point of markets is to crowd source decision making, so if you remove the crowd, then what is it that you actually have left?
- wombatpm 5y agoRent seeking oligarchs?
- dpierce9 5y agoUS healthcare is a four-party arrangement since employers are also intermediaries. Employers select the plan (or plan options) and they pay the bulk of the premiums. Their check is always bigger than yours even if you pay more for your policy than they do. As such, most of the sales effort by health insurance companies is directed at the employer and they exercise a lot of judgment. In contrast, I have never once spoken to a representative of the health insurance company during open enrollment, it is always HR.
- thedougd 5y agoFurthermore, a lot of employers self-fund and use the insurance company only for management and possibly secondary insurance.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThis whole situation would be solved by a simple change to the tax code. Managed healthcare (health insurance) can no longer be purchased via employers with pre tax income. Everyone gets funneled to healthcare.gov where they can choose. The whole buying things (life insurance, gym membership, retirement savings) with pre tax income if it is bought through an employer system needs to go in the trash.