3 ms·
What I want to know are who are the 29% who think daylight savings time is a good idea? There are zero good arguments for it.
by mikewarot 5y ago
What I want to know are who are the 29% who think daylight savings time is a good idea? There are zero good arguments for it.
- providedotemacs 5y agoI don't like DST, but what I would like even less is staying on DST permanently (which is what most proposals for the US West Coast are calling for). Staying on UTC-7 in winter will make the darkness stretch too long into the morning.
- Scarblac 5y agoSimple: in summer, summer time is much better than winter time, and in winter, winter time is much better than summer time.p Using summer time means you get the light in the evenings. Things like doing sports activities that need daylight after work become possible about a month earlier than without time, and you gain another month at the end. Long evenings are glorious for all sorts of activities. The alternative puts the light in the early morning when people sleep. In winter, winter time here means it's at least a bit twilighty during the morning commute; without it it would still be pitch dark, and it would still get dark before the end of the work day. (I'm in the Netherlands, which is actually already on a bit too summer timey timezone compared to its location). Yes, some people can change their schedule instead. Most people are tied to fixed times of work, their kids' school etc.
- frogulis 5y agoMelbourne, Australia here -- I wonder if the negative attitudes to DST relate to something specifically American. Perhaps school starting earlier in the US than here? Can't say I've ever wanted to stop daylight savings. Never-ending afternoon evenings every day in summer, delightful!
- Scarblac 5y agoMost of the US is to the south of my country. I guess that the closer to the equator you are, the less sense it makes. But also in the Netherlands, there are many people who want to abolish it. In my view, they're only thinking of the weekends when the switch is made. At that time, it doesn't seem to make a huge difference, and the switch is annoying, it takes some days to get into the new rhythm. But ask them, at the start of summer you have X hours of sunlight -- what times during the day would you like them to fall? And the same question for the darkest months of winter. I wouldn't be surprised if it needed a switch of two whole timezones to make both answers true.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> it would still get dark before the end of the work day. Where you are, yes. In the US, there's a lot of the country spending a lot of months of standard time with sunsets between 5pm and 6:30pm, where the shift would do the most good.
- slyall 5y agoI guess you are one of those people who goes to bed at 7pm in time to get up with the Sun at 4am.
- andreareina 5y agoI abstained because while it does play merry havoc on interop and other stuff the extra hour of daylight is a nice bonus. You could get the same result by shifting the timing of when stuff happens (work hours etc) but approximately no-one actually does that in dst-less zones. It's a solution to a human problem, not a technical one.