6 ms·
Economical and performant chip and jet turbine production are two areas where China can't really take any shortcuts. They have to put in a lot of time and resou
by seanmcdirmid 5y ago
Economical and performant chip and jet turbine production are two areas where China can't really take any shortcuts. They have to put in a lot of time and resources to rediscover closely guarded secrets that are almost impossible to reverse engineer. They are dumping in the resources, so I'm sure they will eventually get there, but it might be a few decades (in both fields, they can already do performant or economical, just not both at the same time).
- bsedlm 5y ago> They have to put in a lot of time and resources to rediscover closely guarded secrets that are almost impossible to reverse engineer yes, they have to repeat all that work, they have to solve all those solved problems again because companies that solved the problems won't share their solutions.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoNot just companies, but the Russians were pissed after China copied some of their jet military tech. They were angry enough that they stopped supplying them with military jet turbine parts for awhile, which really tripped things up for the Chinese because they can't produce their own at the same level (they can make fast, they can make economical, but they can't make both yet).
- jeffreyrogers 5y agoWhy would a company share its trade secrets? It's one of the few differentiators left to most companies. Not to mention the national security arguments.
- bsedlm 5y ago> Why would a company share its trade secrets? indeed, I wish I could answer this. > Not to mention the national security arguments. it is an inteserting excercise to consider this from the rival's point of view
- hguant 5y ago>they have to solve all those solved problems again because companies that solved the problems won't share their solutions. ...because those solutions are the company's competitive advantage that China has tried to steal for years on end now? Not to mention in many instances those 'solutions' are owned by or access controlled by the parent country of said company, many of which view China as at the least a bad faith actor, and at the worst an inevitable opponent? Pretending China hasn't engaged in the world's largest industrial espionage campaign over the last two decades, and then victim blaming the companies involved for not "sharing their solutions" with China is a perverse form of logic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bvaldivielso 5y agoInteresting. What about hiring people from the leading companies? Isn't that how a lot of knowledge transfer happens in all industries? Are non-competes enforceable internationally?
- ivan_gammel 5y agoI doubt it is that easy thing to do. What would motivate some key researcher to move from USA/Europe to China to work on stuff that they have already done instead of exploring new frontiers? Hardly any money can buy that. Ego? Maybe few people from the wishlist will take a new job title, but you need the entire list.
- carabiner 5y agoStuff like this isn't just trade secrets, in the US it's often ITAR-controlled and requires a security clearance. There are CFD algorithms that are classified. If you possess this information and plan to move to (or even visit) China, I imagine US immigration will look at you very closely and not simply allow you to leave to go work for Chengdu Aerospace Corporation.
- tablespoon 5y ago> If you possess this information and plan to move to (or even visit) China, I imagine US immigration will look at you very closely and not simply allow you to leave to go work for Chengdu Aerospace Corporation. I don't think the US border control system works like that. If you're a citizen, you never need an exit visa. IIRC, as long as you have a valid passport, you can exit and enter as you please, but if there's probable cause to suspect you of a crime they can arrest you. China's system, on the other hand, does work like that. IIRC, anyone with any authority or access to secrets isn't allowed to have free control over their passport, and they have systems for denying people exit permission.
- r00fus 5y agoDo you actually understand how this works or are you theorizing? The no-fly-list exists. Security clearances are tracked.
- bfung 5y agoI suspect some or most of this secret sauce is more like institutional knowledge and not one single person knows how the whole system works (to produce high quality chips at scale). Or maybe there IS one person, but that’s the CEO/founder, haha. Regardless, it’s similar to software companies claiming to run agile, but always reverting to the “get it done, waterfall deadline” mode. It takes good effort and detailed knowledge of pitfalls to avoid to actually make a less intuitive, but more repeatable and productive process work. (Agile’s been around for over 10years and people still don’t do good versions well)
- kodemager 5y ago> Agile’s been around for over 10years and people still don’t do good versions well) Agile software development has been around since the early 90’ies. Scrum is from something like 1995. The reason people fail to implement it so often is that project management sort or doesn’t work in software development, and it doesn’t work because you can spend two hours looking for a spelling error or a missing semicolon, and you can create Godlike code in half an hour, and you never know which mode you’re going to be in when you get up in the morning. Waterfall doesn’t work either, for the same reason, and for all the adaptive reasons that lead to agile. The best way to deal with it is to take the methods that make sense for your current project and run with that. 99% or the time that’s a kanban board, and maybe some time registration software if you’re unfortunate enough to work in a place that bills by the hour. The worst part about the project management methods in my personal opinion is that they all want to sell themselves as the universal solution, in a world where no two projects are alike but you also can’t be bothered to have 90 different project models in an organisation, because then what’s the point.
- AceJohnny2 5y ago> and it doesn’t work because you can spend two hours looking for a spelling error or a missing semicolon, and you can create Godlike code in half an hour, and you never know which mode you’re going to be in when you get up in the morning. That's ADHD (maybe modulo some external factors like scattered meetings)
- pixl97 5y agoWhat about doing it the old fashion way and just stealing said information?
- nwiswell 5y agoAt least for semiconductors a lot of the magic is distributed tribal knowledge among engineers and the sophisticated equipment used to fabricate the devices (all major suppliers are in the US, Europe, and Japan). So theft is not really a complete solution, although it can help.
- klipt 5y agoSo if there were a war and the existing equipment got bombed, the world would basically be set 10 years behind on computing?
- nwiswell 5y ago> basically be set 10 years behind on computing That probably overstates the case a little bit since capacity is distributed around the world, but in some sense yes. It's not particularly hypothetical. If China (PRC) was to invade Taiwan, that would potentially knock out a frightening proportion of the world's leading-edge capacity.
- dontcare007 5y ago
- 0000011111 5y agoChina launched more rockets to orbit than any other country last year. They make not take short cuts. But they do catch up quickly in terms of development.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoRockets are pretty simple compared to jet turbines, rocket production doesn't have as thick of a moat as jet turbine production. > Developing jet engine is not an easy game unlike rocket engines as it's comparatively very compact in size & it requires advance engineering to develop it's crystal blades technology & maintain it's thrust to weight ratio & that's what make jet engine technology one of the most complicated technology. From https://defenceview.in/how-difficult-is-it-to-build-an-jet-engine-ask-india-and-china/ https://defenceview.in/how-difficult-is-it-to-build-an-jet-e...
- jhgb 5y agoRocket engines are to jet engines basically what paper utensils are to porcelain. But with transition to reusable rocket stages, chances are that the "disposable" designs will get more complex if that extra complexity gets justified by not throwing away the whole unit after several minutes of operation. > Developing jet engine is not an easy game unlike rocket engines as it's comparatively very compact in size & it requires advance engineering to develop it's crystal blades technology & maintain it's thrust to weight ratio & that's what make jet engine technology one of the most complicated technology. That's a terribly worded and nonsensical claim (and almost reads like it was written by a ten year old). How could someone claim that rocket engines are "not very compact in size"? The RD-180 turbopump for example generates 170 MW of mechanical power, much more than any jet engine in operation, and in a smaller package to boot. Likewise, the HPFTP on the RS-25 generates around 50 MW of mechanical power, and does so in a package sized 0.55m by 1.1m or something like that.
- bsder 5y agoNO manufacturing line is easily transplantable or built from scratch. This is not limited to semiconductors. My favorite story about this is a paint manufacturer building a brand new, state-of-the-art manufacturing facility to increase their capacity. Everything was controlled, monitored, etc. to the nth degree. Only one problem--paint from the new line no longer stuck to anything. Cue a crash debugging with all hands on deck. The problem? The new line was too clean. Paint relies on the correct ends attaching to the wall and then the other ends forming a kind of network to protect those. But there is a tradeoff--the outer paint surface (exposed to elements) vs the inner paint surface (attaches to the wall) have different needs. If you make the inner paint surface too dense (molecules all vertical) the paints sticks great, but then doesn't protect against the elements. If you make the outer paint surface dense (molecules all horizontal) then the paint protects well, but then won't stick to the wall. The solution: add some "dirt". Adding some very fine, very small inert particles can change the angle that the paint molecules connect and fix the adhesion issues. The lesson: nobody knows all the things necessary to run a manufacturing line. Ever.
- amboar 5y agoAh, here's the circuit design equivalent of that story: https://twitter.com/dave_universetf/status/1473475348654268418 https://twitter.com/dave_universetf/status/14734753486542684...
- acchow 5y ago> but it might be a few decades They could just hire the experts from the incumbents
- 300bps 5y agoThe article said that’s exactly what they did from CEO to engineers and they still failed. HSMC attracted a former top TSMC executive as chief executive. QXIC recruited dozens of experienced engineers from Taiwan, including from TSMC, with relatively big pay packages, according to former employees.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI wonder if they were playing both sides, ie getting a ton of money from China and TSMC to just lead them astray :)
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoThe process/material knowledge is actually pretty easy to keep under lock and key. No one knows the formula, or the key is in the equipment that whose production is strictly controlled. They need to get access to the all of the knowledge all at once, not just bits and pieces of it.
- kelnos 5y agoAssuming they'll agree to work for them. I imagine many of the people who hold the secret sauce (especially from TSMC) wouldn't work for a Chinese company. I was surprised they managed to hire a former TSMC executive to head up one of the (now failed) companies. Then again, there may be no "secret sauce" in the way we usually think about it. You might have to hire hundreds of people from an incumbent to pull in enough institutional knowledge to get things going. And even then it's not going to happen overnight. I feel like the right people to hire, at any rate, aren't the executives. You need the right engineers, scientists, and researchers.
- WalterBright 5y agoMy grandfather figured out how to grow large haloid crystals, which were used in camera polaroid Carl Zeiss "Bernotar" filters. He kept the process a secret, which died with him. My family gets contacted now and then by researchers trying to figure out how to do it.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoSo interesting! Any pictures?
- WalterBright 5y agoThere are many pictures if you do a google image search on "Carl Zeiss Bernotar". https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferdinand_Bernauer https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ferdinand_Bernauer https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cphc.201000963 https://chemistry-europe.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21370378/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21370378/
- balsam 5y agoWait, Bernauer is your grandfather? He was killed in the war..
- WalterBright 5y agoYes, on my mother's side. He was too old for the draft, but got pressed into the Volkssturm (old men and boys) to defend Berlin, and was mortally wounded in it. Two pictures I have of him, one with a telescope the other with a microscope. Both sides of my family were nerds :-) He also led a team to Iceland in the 1930s to set some surveying markers to determine if Iceland was expanding, which would prove the continental drift theory. After the war, other researchers went back and confirmed it. I'm kinda sad he died before completing this, and so others got the credit for continental drift.
- bcrl 5y agoIndeed, there is no free lunch. Just look at Intel's missteps on their 10nm process. There's a company with decades of experience building semiconductors and $77 billion in revenue last year that took close to 4 years to recover from initial mistakes with their transition from their 14nm process to a 10nm class process. If Intel has that much difficulty, just imagine how many orders of magnitude harder it is for a small upstart without all of that institutional experience and resources to recreate that process step from scratch.
- kurthr 5y agoWell, to be fair their 10nm is everyone else's 7nm and they were trying to do it without DUV litho, for reasons? However, their style of process/chip design is very hierarchical with HUGE teams to get the implementation out in the 3-4year cycles (there are multiple overlapping teams). This was driven over the successes of decades of scaling. Then it failed. Now they are behind. If they had been able to pivot early they might be parallel with rather than behind TSMC, but they couldn't admit it wasn't working. The large group structure got in the way. We'll see if they can fix it.
- bcrl 5y agoI do wonder at what point Intel will no longer be able to function being the sole source of products running through their own fabs. Companies like TSMC can amortize the cost of fab construction and process development over a much larger swath of the electronics industry. Combined with the fact that Intel no longer has Apple as a customer for new products, they could be facing enormous change by 2030. AMD couldn't support their own fab, and I think that's still a risk factor (albeit much smaller than it was for AMD) for Intel if the cost of new fabs keeps going up by factors of 10 or more every generation.
- inter_netuser 5y agowhy are they impossible to reverse engineer? especially in case of jet turbines, due to their much larger size than chips?
- prewett 5y agoI expect it is because jet turbine blades need to be precisely shaped to maximize proper airflow; spin around so fast that the shear forces destroy most materials; operate in an environment so hot that it melts most materials (which does not help with the shear forces, I expect); and be as lightweight as possible. Some blades have channels on the inside to run cool air through them to cool them down so they don't melt. I wonder if the egress of the air may be used to help keep the flow laminar, I thought I read something about that in experimental airplane wings. So you have fluid dynamics for the shape and a serious limitation in available materials. I know fluid dynamics is a bit of a black art, and I expect that metallurgy is somewhat similar. Especially at 2000 deg C and 3500 - 25,000 RPM! Even once you have the blade to copy, you don't know why the features are the way they are. What bits are important? Which areas must have high tolerance? After that, there is the question of how to make it. You probably cannot just mass spectrometer it, put those ingredients in a vat, heat it up, and pour it into a mold. Is the order of ingredients important? The exact ratios? How quickly do you cool it? At what temperature? And how do you get those holes in it? How do you do it economically? You can't just 3D print these, and even if you did, it'd be way too slow.
- selimthegrim 5y agoI think they are also formed from single crystals