3 ms·
Granted, there is a substantial degree to which font design has a strong subjective element (even though there are some non-subjective metrics that must be met
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
Granted, there is a substantial degree to which font design has a strong subjective element (even though there are some non-subjective metrics that must be met too). However, the font that emerged in "Yak shave #4", Computer Modern, manages (for me) to pull off a somewhat exceptional double feat. On the one hand, it is to my eyes one of the ugliest fonts designed during the 20th century; on the other, my experience of it as a reader (hence again, my eyes) is that it is one of the easiest to read fonts ever created. I assume that DK found CM to be both beautiful and readable, which is fine, but I think it's even more remarkable that he could have created a font that someone with a modicum of interest in font design and typesetting could find both ugly and very readable.
- taeric 5y agoI'm intrigued. Typically ugly things are jarring and slow down interaction. Can you elaborate on what makes it easy to read?
- nextos 5y agoIf you go through old Springer Undergraduate or Graduate Texts in Mathematics (typeset in TeX and Computer Modern) you'll notice they are really pleasant on the eyes. The amount of information density is just right. There's no noise and it's very easy to distinguish where sections start and end. If you look into any great pre-TeX book like Rudin [1], it looks much uglier and more difficult to read. I'd actually pay a significant amount of money for new editions of Rudin or Halmos typeset in TeX and Computer Modern. They'd be much easier to go through. I must also add Latin Modern is a slight update to Computer Modern that is slightly thicker and looks much better on screens. [1] https://web.math.ucsb.edu/~agboola/teaching/2021/winter/122A/rudin.pdf https://web.math.ucsb.edu/~agboola/teaching/2021/winter/122A...
- taeric 5y agoRight. My question was more surprise that easy to read does not translate to beautiful in this case. Seems an odd juxtaposition. Caveat, I like computer modern.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI really don't know. I just find that the cognitive experience of reading papers or even books set in CM is always very easy for me, certainly compared to some other common fonts. However, my first glance at the page(s) always leads to "Oh, ugh, not CM again" and my eye notices the serifs, the rather blocky aspect ratio, the weirdly varying line weights ... and then I read it and my eyes/brain love it.
- taeric 5y agoFair. I suspect there may be some reminder of over zealous advocates when you first see it? Such that knowing the font is enough to remember a lot of the nonsense around it. Even if it is somewhat objectively good? That is, is this a blending of bad subjective experience with otherwise good objective experiences?
- bombcar 5y agoI wonder if this is something like the Ratatouille effect - you know enough to “know” what shouldn’t work, but Knuth knows enough to know what does work - and your eyes agree.
- adrian_b 5y agoWhile I would certainly not consider Computer Modern as a beautiful typeface, it is likely that your perception of it is biased due to looking at it on computer displays. Knuth has chosen Computer Modern to be a so-called "Modern" typeface, which is a name applied to a certain style of typefaces that became popular at the beginning of the 19th century and which was frequently used for mathematics books of that time. Of all styles of typefaces, the "Modern" typefaces are the least appropriate for computer displays, because no desktop computer display has a resolution high enough to render such typefaces. On computer displays, Computer Modern and all typefaces of this kind (with excessive contrast between thick and thin lines) are strongly distorted to fit the display pixels, so they become much uglier than when rendered correctly on a high-resolution printer (i.e. at 1200 dpi or more). Therefore you cannot compare Computer Modern with more recent typefaces that have been designed to look nice on computer displays or with old typefaces from other families, which were suitable for low-resolution printing. Computer Modern was strictly intended for very high resolution printing on paper and not for viewing documents on computers.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago> it is likely that your perception of it is biased due to looking at it on computer displays. I typeset 2 books with TeX and read far more printed pages typeset with TeX than I ever read online.
- bombcar 5y agoI recall reading somewhere that it was designed for printers that “bled” and if using it on modern exact lasers you need to take that into account and make it “thicker” - but I suppose it could be tested by comparing output to early copies of TAOCP.
- amelius 5y ago> it is to my eyes one of the ugliest fonts designed during the 20th century Makes me wonder what you think of Comic Sans ...
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI was going to mention Comic Sans but decided it wasn't necessary in context. For many things, I'm a Palatino Person, but I am aware that it is aging poorly. I also love the european public display use of Helvetica, and for novels and other continuous text flow, I'm a cheap date, anything will do.
- gjm11 5y agoThe only thing wrong with Palatino is that it was never intended for typesetting body copy (substantial blocks of text) as opposed to display (headings, splash text on posters, etc.) and its proportions aren't quite right for that purpose. Try the closely related Aldus, or in extremis just condense Palatino by a few percent. (The latter suggestion may get me yelled at, somewhat understandably, but I really do think it's an improvement if you're setting substantial quantities of text.)
- b215826 5y ago> On the one hand, it is to my eyes one of the ugliest fonts designed during the 20th century; on the other, my experience of it as a reader (hence again, my eyes) is that it is one of the easiest to read fonts ever created. For me it's the exact opposite. I find the font to be beautifully designed and perfect for mathematical typesetting (e.g., it properly distinguishes ν and v for instance). However, it's terrible for on-screen reading and printing using laser printers because of how spindly the glyphs are. Indeed, Knuth designed CMR for the printers of the 1980s [1]. The most carefully designed math fonts IMHO are the MathTime fonts [2] designed by Michael Spivak to use in conjunction with Times. It isn't a free font however. (For a sample see this paper [3] published in the Annals of Mathematics.) MathTime is also a perfect example of yak shaving. Spivak was dissatisfied with most available fonts when he set out to update his book on calculus so he basically learned type design from the scratch [4]. I also really like the Fourier fonts (meant to be used with Adobe's Utopia) designed by Michel Bovani and I recently came across a book on statistical mechanics [5] that uses them, which I thought was typeset beautifully. [1]: https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/361722 https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/361722 [2]: https://pctex.com/mtpro2.html https://pctex.com/mtpro2.html [3]: https://annals.math.princeton.edu/wp-content/uploads/annals-v171-n3-p08-p.pdf https://annals.math.princeton.edu/wp-content/uploads/annals-... [4]: https://tug.org/pracjourn/2006-1/spivak/spivak.pdf https://tug.org/pracjourn/2006-1/spivak/spivak.pdf [5]: http://www.unige.ch/math/folks/velenik/smbook/Statistical_Mechanics_of_Lattice_Systems.pdf http://www.unige.ch/math/folks/velenik/smbook/Statistical_Me...
- kragen 5y agoDo you mean cmr, cmi, cmtt, ...?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoMostly cmr but the same basic dual experience occurs for me with the whole family.