7 ms·
My favorite liar (2009)
- andi999 5y ago'so lets start with the efficient market..'
- dwohnitmok 5y agoThe overall idea seems quite fun, but I'd be cautious about the lecture where he doesn't actually lie. Although the author seems to have taken it quite well, it could easily have come off as a cheap trick to other students and reduced motivation to find future lies. One of those kinds of lectures might work, but much more might not. Although on the other hand I do remember hearing something along the lines of inconsistent rewards having a stronger incentive effect than consistent rewards, so maybe not?
- smitty1e 5y agoI recall seeing this anecdote on Slashdot a decade or better ago. Possibly the same author, or, given the 'zen' in the site name, it is a koan?
- basq 5y agoZen is extremely misunderstood in the west. Mostly because what we understand of it comes from a conman and his followers who appropriated it a la scientology/mormonism. Therefore, the default assumption when seeing 'zen' mentioned is that it's the bogus religion version.
- Agentlien 5y agoThat's interesting, what was his name and where can I read more about it?
- denton-scratch 5y agoIf most of what we know of Zen in the West was disseminated by him and his followers, that points to DT Suzuki. I'm not aware that he was a con-man, although he appears to have had some pretty distasteful opinions.
- its_bbq 5y agoThis may be a leak of the pet theory of /r/zen that Dogen, the founder of Soto Zen, was a fraud and that Zen is somehow not Buddhism. I haven't seen this theory taken seriously anywhere else.
- basq 5y agoCalling it a 'pet theory' is extremely disingenuous. Of course every scientologist will 'not take seriously' claims that their founder was a conman, because to do so is to admit their beliefs are based on falsehoods. It's a self reinforcing system.
- aspenmayer 5y agoIsn’t it a lie to to invite folks to a lecture where it’s understood that you will lie, only to tell the truth instead?
- ptx 5y agoI'd consider it a type error: he's declaring Lie<T> but providing Lie<Lie<T>>.
- aspenmayer 5y agoCan you draw the truth table of this lie about lying? Is it a Type 3 error, specifically? I’m not great at coding, but I’m learning with your help! I’m only half-joking. I have only rudimentary formal logic education, or else I would myself. :P https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_table https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_table
- ptx 5y agoWhat I was trying to get at is that it was agreed that he would lie in a certain context, but he instead lied in a different context that wasn't part of the agreement. If you buy tickets for a magic show, it's agreed that you will be tricked. But if the trick is that there is no show and they're simply scamming you out of your money, that wouldn't generally be considered acceptable. The show itself and buying tickets for the show are different contexts. Similarly, a box of cookies is not same thing as a box of boxes of cookies. The contents of the outer box in the latter case wouldn't be very tasty.
- aspenmayer 5y ago> If you buy tickets for a magic show, it's agreed that you will be tricked. But if the trick is that there is no show and they're simply scamming you out of your money, that wouldn't generally be considered acceptable. This is a great explanation. I was immediately reminded of Joker’s “magic trick” with a pencil during his interrogation in The Dark Knight. https://youtube.com/watch?v=L3oOldViIgY https://youtube.com/watch?v=L3oOldViIgY
- thibran 5y agoThe strategy used here is called something like "volitional obstacle" and is a known learning strategy.
- dataflow 5y ago> “Ah ha! Each of you has one falsehood in your lecture notes.” Wouldn't that itself be the lie for that lecture?
- hirundo 5y agoI have too many colleagues who rubber-stamp my pull requests. I'm tempted to include a significant mistake in each one to see who's paying attention. Unfortunately I have done so too many times by mistake with nobody noticing. Maybe if we gamify it a bit and start keeping score. I don't have authority to make a bonus contingent on the result, but it could be money well spent.
- kubb 5y agoI prefer the people who only comment when they have something useful to say. Either way the responsibility for the correctness is with the code author, not the reviewer. Writing whatever and hoping for your coworkers to correct it is equivalent to asking them to do your job.
- hirundo 5y agoDisagree. Finding those mistakes is the whole point. When I miss one in someone else's PR, the resulting problems are my fault.
- auselen 5y agoI can never claim I can find all the bugs, I’m not even that smart. Thus I can comment on style, overall compatibility with existing mechanisms. Ask/remind which tests were run. Trivial stuff is easy to catch, refactoring parts I’m familiar might help with pitfalls known to me. Still I can’t see how one can claim finding all bugs is possible.
- tremon 5y agoThey're not your fault, they're at most your responsibility. You should be paid triple what your coworkers earn if you're willing to accept fault for what they produce. Are you perhaps a team manager and insisting that all your team PR's go through you? Might I suggest that instead of signing off on all PR's yourself, setting up a good testing framework may help you sleep better at night?
- TrainedMonkey 5y ago
- NKosmatos 5y agoNice one! I heard/read a similar story where in some math exams the teachers provided “faulty” calculators to all students in order to see which students relied to the result of the calculator screen and which of them used their logic and common knowledge to understand when a result is wrong. The calculators didn’t produce errors obvious like 1+1=3 but more like 22/7=3. Nice tactic and highly educational lesson :-)
- fartcannon 5y agoYou might as well ask them to do the exam on a cliffs edge, or with a gun pointed at them. Fucking with students during an event that can have huge long term consequences for their future is shamefully cruel, if you ask me.
- openfuture 5y agoThe shamefully cruel part is that some random exam can have long term consequences.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, I don't agree with messing with people in stressful situations, but at this point we are better controlling the consequences of those exams. You need to measure learning, you can't make exams trivial. If the consequences are that large, they will always be problematic.
- scarier 5y agoFrankly, even a working calculator can induce the same problem. My school allowed calculators with a “solve” function to be used on calculus tests, and a staggering number of people would directly transcribe whatever output it gave, regardless of how nonsensical. “NaN” was a favorite.