4 ms·
Female patients of male surgeons experience worse health outcomes
- tryptophan 5y ago
- marcosdumay 5y agoIt's a small phenomenon with weak statistical significance. So, yeah, if a few teams looked to something like it, one of them would find the result that gets attention just by chance, and then publish it, while the others would probably not publish.
- dzdt 5y agoThis study is 1.3million patients treated by 3000 surgeons, and reaches statistical p=0.004. Not small or weak!
- marcosdumay 5y ago> adverse postoperative outcomes (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 1.07; 95% CI, 1.04-1.09), as well as death (aOR, 1.07; 95% CI, 1.02-1.13), and complications (aOR, 1.09; 95% CI, 1.07-1.11) That on a research that screams "data mining" all over it is nearly meaningless. Those are reasonable starting points for further research and nothing else. For a start, a 5% p-value in a multi-hypothesys study is a real issue.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoNot just that. Imagine I do a replication study and the results are at odds with these findings - it wouldn't be easy to publish them. But I bet this study will be quoted/referenced liberally.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- oh_sigh 5y agoAs someone who can't read the full text(and it isn't on sci-hub yet), is it possible that male doctors and female doctors are attracted to different specialties, which could account for this? It doesn't make sense to me how male doctor + female patient can have a statistically higher chance of death and complications, but not a statistically higher chance of readmission.
- PeterisP 5y agoThere are all kinds of potential confounders, for example in other analysis of surgeries we sometimes see that senior surgeons get worse results than less experienced surgeons because senior surgeons take on all the non-standard risky cases and leave routine operations to less experienced surgeons; however, aspects like this and also "male doctors and female doctors are attracted to different specialties" would not adequately explain that the correlation is specific to female patients. One thing that has been studied and plausibly seems relevant is the issue that (at least earlier, perhaps this has improved after criticism) often when teaching internal anatomy, the male body is implicitly considered as "the default" and female specifics are (were?) looked at only with respect to the reproductive system, while in reality there are all kinds of average differences; the same applies to all kinds of drugs which often are tested only on males for efficiency (and later on everyone for safety, incl teratogenic issues) simply assuming that the effectiveness and side effects are the same for everyone, which is known not to be fully true. So it may be that doctors out of med school are literally a bit less prepared to handle female bodies than male ones. However, that would apply to both male and female doctors equally, so that's not a good explanation as well.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoIf you told me that men were more likely to be distracted in the presence of a naked woman I would say, duh. Though now I'm curious if there was a difference between the different procedures, and if it holds up across cities. Probably most importantly, did any particular surgeon skew the number?
- PeterisP 5y agoLet's just say that for the vast majority of people there's absolutely nothing sexy about a partially covered body where you're cutting in some body parts and focusing on tiny aspects of blood covered meat and vessels and bone at the exclusion of everything else. You get desensitized to a lot during med school. Also, surgery patients are disproportionally older and less healthy than the general population, which is correlated with attractiveness even before the surgery starts.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoHave a corrective upvote. I don't think it's a completely unreasonable thought and possibly not entirely irrelevant. But a more likely explanation is that it is easier for men to understand what is going on with a man's body and it's easier to have that conversation between two men. Medical research has a history of skewing towards investigating male health issues because men have historically been in charge of such research and because medical research has often been done on medical students and that population tended to be mostly male. A male doctor I was friends with told me once that the first time some woman had her brain scanned, everyone was freaking out because it was radically different from all scans on record. Then they realized all brain scans on record were male and they had no meaningful baseline record for a female brain, so they had no idea what this meant and they calmed down. It maybe only meant that men and women have brain differences. It didn't necessarily mean there was something pathological going on.
- grammarnazzzi 5y ago
- DoreenMichele 5y agoThe submitted title: Female patients of male surgeons experience worse health outcomes The actual title of the article: Association of Surgeon-Patient Sex Concordance With Postoperative Outcomes The actual TLDR from the piece itself: This study found that sex discordance between surgeons and patients (particularly male surgeons and female patients) may contribute to worse surgical outcomes.
- igetspam 5y agoThe title is a whole lot of "no shit." Women aren't taken seriously. My wife's,(very short lived) PCP theorized that her intestinal problems were possibly due to her period syncing with our daughter. The concept of periods getting in sync is proven to be false and our daughter was two. When she pointed out the second thing his response was an exclamation that "it is a thing though!" She had a previous diagnosis (on record, with him) of diverticulosis and the thing he thought might be her period syncing was a diverticulitis flareup. This is not an uncommon problem she faces and it's not unique to her. There are lots of women to have to do their own triage because we think they're going through PMS or postpartum depression or their just hysterical (hysteria chairs are a wild thing that happened in medical history). I don't have time to get into the study but anecdotally, I can assure you that we do women a horrible disservice in the medical field. It's one of the reasons my wife tries hard to work only with women. Most of them believe her.