9 ms·
I don't like cryptocurrency. But charities are there to do a job, if someone wants to give them money, it seems silly to refuse. Accepting a bitcoin and immed
by bawolff 5y ago
I don't like cryptocurrency.
But charities are there to do a job, if someone wants to give them money, it seems silly to refuse.
Accepting a bitcoin and immediately turning it into USD does not mean you politically support cryptocurrency.
- jltsiren 5y agoAccepting money means whatever people perceive it to mean. Charities are unavoidably ideological, and their every action will be interpreted politically. If a charity accepts money from a source some people consider tainted, those people may now consider the charity tainted as well, and they may stop donating.
- roenxi 5y agoMozilla can't satisfy people who seriously see payment systems as an actionable political problem. Those people are too flighty to be courted.
- VectorLock 5y agoI think his objections is what the transactions to do this with the cryptocurrency consume a massive amount of energy and there by contribute to global warming.
- zagrebian 5y agoThe transactions? I thought it’s the mining that consumes all the energy.
- Gigachad 5y agoThe transactions add value to the network which incentivises mining.
- xigoi 5y agoThe purpose of mining is to confirm transactions.
- tsimionescu 5y ago"Mining" means adding transactions to the blockchain. Ad absurdum, if no one transacted bitcoin, there would be nothing to mine. And contrary to what some claim, given Bitcoin's fixed block size and a few other constrained parameters, there is a very clear (and enormous) electrical power cost per transaction (with some range given that transactions are not fixed size - the more participants in a single transaction, and the more metadata, the higher the power cost per transaction).
- incrudible 5y agoMining means finding the hash for the next block. Mining empty blocks if there are no transactions is perfectly fine. The expected size of a block makes no difference to power consumption. The only relevant parameter is the point at which it becomes unprofitable. You could argue that if less fees were spent, some barely profitable mining rigs would be turned off in anticipation. However, Bitcoin is not at the point were fees are decisive yet.
- cardanome 5y agoThis assumes that higher efficiency leads to lower total consumption of energy, the data says otherwise. [1] It is interesting that "saving energy" has been established as a dogma that does not even get questioned. I guess the propaganda by big energy monopolists about "carbon footprint" was very successful. Currently nearly the whole world is running a economic system that is based on economic growth and leads to maximizing resource consumption. Sure using resources efficiently does increase the value society can gain from them but not total consumption. If you stop Bitcoin, people will find other means to use the excess energy. The reasonable way to solve this is to make energy PRODUCTION stop using fossil fuels anymore. Simple as that. That is why we need to keep talking about our carbon footprints so we don't take any action that might go against the interest of certain corporations. [1] > The data and analyses presented here show that historically, over long time periods, improvements in efficiency have not succeeded in outpacing increases in the quantity of goods and services provided. https://web.mit.edu/2.813/www/readings/DahmusGutowskiEfficiency.pdf https://web.mit.edu/2.813/www/readings/DahmusGutowskiEfficie...
- VectorLock 5y agoAlthough reducing fossil fuel consumption is good, reducing energy consumption offsets the negative ecological effects from any kind of power production. Like when they say "Reduce, Reuse, Recycle; in that order" for recycling.
- mdoms 5y agoIf you accept PoW cryptocurrency you are complicit in the environmental impact of it. End of story.
- rasengan 5y ago
- mdoms 5y agoI don't follow?
- rasengan 5y agoYou’re complicit in global warming. Shame on you.
- dang 5y agoPosting like this will get you banned here, regardless of how right you are or feel you are. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules, we'd appreciate it.
- tapoxi 5y agoI don’t understand the comparison you’re trying to make. There’s no viable alternative to a computer that uses substantially less power. The alternative is there for crypto, and it’s called fiat currency.
- randomhodler84 5y ago
- rasengan 5y agoHow is fiat an alternative to cryptocurrency? Fiat is printed without transparency [1] whereas cryptocurrency is not for example. How are these the same? [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1 has been discontinued.
- klyrs 5y agoIf people pay me to (say) kill puppies, is Mozilla obliged to accept my money?
- MattGaiser 5y agoThey should. What good does it do to make puppy killers richer? People (incorrectly) think that a donation means that you are owed something in return.
- akiselev 5y agoWhat good does it do to launder puppy killers' money? See: Sacklers.
- MattGaiser 5y agoAnd taking Sackler money for some charitable cause will do a lot more good than them piling it up. Take some Sackler millions and you can feed a million hungry people, cure cancer, or expand our knowledge of the past. The person turning it down gets to brag on Twitter about turning it down.
- akiselev 5y ago> Take some Sackler millions and you can feed a million hungry people, cure cancer, or expand our knowledge of the past. At best you can feed a million people for a day (you certainly won't be curing cancer) but you will launder their reputation in the process. These kinds of charitable causes allow for people like the Sacklers to get the attention they crave from their fellow high society despite the awful things they have done, just because they flash their wallets around at a few galas. As long as nothing requires them to change their behavior, they won't.
- pryce 5y agoThis is an absurd view. Having your charity financially dependent on puppy killers or (say) weapons manufacturers undermines your ability to act ethically in various situations, which you may or may not see as important. Here you might picture Assange taking Russian money (indirectly) and the ethical swamp he finds himself in when he criticising behaviour that is an assault on journalism in the west while deciding whether or not to cover the astounding number of journalists in Russia that tend to fall out of windows. A bigger problem is that it swiftly undermines an important trait of a charity which is: that it ought to represent ethical action in at least some (palatable) framework that appeals to people who would consider donating toward that work. For example, I donated to Wikileaks years before Assange's choices made that work highly questionable, and like many other observers would now never consider donating to wikileaks again. The damage to Wikileaks' credibility has hit the organisation in both financial and cultural spheres. Their ability to advocate depends significantly on their reputation. Not every charities end up with a conundrum quite this dramatic, but it's not uncommon they face some. One example is LGBTQ charities, who are offered money by large organisations which those organisation in return use to portray themselves as more progressive. Those same orgs may still have discriminatory hiring practices or a troubled history with LGBTQ community, and where that occurs, the act of taking that money significantly undermines the charities' reputation among the LGBTQ community itself. This isn't hypothetical, I've seen this happen, both with large companies and with police, which for many decades persecuted LGBTQ people—and in some places still do.
- atoav 5y agoIf your organization cares about its carbon footprint it won't use a cryptocurrency. Just like most companies stopped to accept fax as a means of communications.
- miohtama 5y agoMore than 95% of cryptocurrencies are not energy sensitive. This is very misinformed. When people think cryptocurrencies they think Bitcoin which is rapidly falling in market share.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y ago95% is kind of misleading as there are so many shitcoins. I would be more concerned about the energy profile of the TOP X coins by market cap.
- miohtama 5y agoFrom top 10 blockchains by market cap eight are not energy sensitive. Ethereum will stop proof of work this year. So it will only leave Bitcoin to be the carbon monster. Also, by the usage and transaction volume Bitcoin is already behind Ethereum and others, so it is no longer even top 1 and has been falling against others for the last 4 years. https://twitter.com/evan_van_ness/status/1471643651608649728?t=cE3-8NrQyGAK8kIqICwvCA&s=19 https://twitter.com/evan_van_ness/status/1471643651608649728...
- NicoJuicy 5y agoThey aren't wasteful because they are hardly used. 95% of 10 k. Coins. 66% still buys mainly Bitcoin
- capableweb 5y agoIs that true? I don't doubt you, just haven't seen any numbers pointing towards that being true is all. If you have some resources I can check out, I'd be very grateful. In terms of "Total Market Capitalization", Bitcoin currently sits around ~39%[1], which feels unlikely if "66% still buys mainly Bitcoin". But again, you could be right. - [1] - https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/ https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/
- lottin 5y agoI disagree. I think accepting payments in cryptocurrency does send a message that you think the ideology behind cryptocurrencies is okay.
- nightski 5y agoThis could be said for any currency/form of payment.
- nosianu 5y agoNo. The difference is that at this point accepting a crypto currency is entirely optional for them, while using regular currency of their country is not or they could not be a company (since they have to pay taxes in that currency).
- systemvoltage 5y agoNot inclined to you but in general: Someone does X and then judge Y because they have some axe to grind about Y. I despise attitude like this. It's the kind of woke activism that has made the world so toxic.
- somedude895 5y agoHonestly curious, what about the ideology behind crypto is not okay? Apart from the high power usage of PoW, which is an unfortunate side-effect, not really part of the ideology.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoMozilla Foundation isn't a charity, it's a non-profit corporation. Mozilla Corporation however is a corp.
- odiroot 5y agoWould accepting blood money still be alright then? Where do we put the line?
- wdr1 5y agoThat might carry more water if Mozilla wasn't already earning $826.6 million a year. https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2019/mozilla-fdn-2019-short-form-0926.pdf https://assets.mozilla.net/annualreport/2019/mozilla-fdn-201...