4 ms·
Miniaturized NMR? can you explain how that would work?
by dekhn 5y ago
Miniaturized NMR? can you explain how that would work?
- kragen 5y agoBenchtop NMR spectrometers already exist (for decades now), and some are already cryogen-free, permitting room-temperature measurements, eliminating the dewar and cryogens which account for a lot of the mass and volume of traditional NMR spectrometers. We now have room-temperature superconductors, which might work to eliminate the bulky, heavy permanent magnets in current benchtop devices, though the pressures required may turn out to be impractical. Beyond that I can handwave at improved electronics and SQUIDs, but I don't really know. Do you think there are some fundamental obstacles to miniaturizing NMR, and if so, what?
- dekhn 5y agobenchtop NMR doesn't solve this problem, it's not powerful enough. If you had improvements to NMR they would actually go first to other things than doing chemical analysis of anarchist drug batches. IE there are other industries that will buy all your machines if they existed. The real question is why would you EVER use NMR for just about anything? It's really high cost and the total value of the data is lower than just about any other technique. It really only makes sense in research situations.
- kragen 5y agoWhat are the companies, or at least the industries, that would buy all the machines? Ultimately what everyday people will end up using is whatever is cheap and works well enough. Right now NMR isn't cheap, and neither is FT-IR or XRD, but these things change over time. Benchtop NMR is already good enough for distinguishing between significant classes of contaminants that could be in your purported insulin. I'm typing this on a 50-gigaflops computer, which is faster than the Cray Y-MP Los Alamos had back in the 01990s, and people routinely buy teraflops video cards now, any one of which is faster than ASCI Option Red, if you remember that. I just drank a mass-produced soft drink out of a can made of aluminum, the metal Napoleon III preferred to gold to exhibit his wealth. Last year Chinese companies brought three covid vaccines to market within six months of the disease's discovery and started mass vaccinations, though most observers had predicted a minimum of 18 months. SpaceX is routinely landing reusable rockets on their tails now, and the world's energy infrastructure is rapidly shifting from fossil fuels to solar. Things change. Today's science fiction is tomorrow's old news.
- fabian2k 5y agoYou can't really escape the physics here, you need a very strong and very homogeneous magnetic field for NMR and very sensitive electronics to detect the signal. That's not something we can do for cheap right now. And even beyond that I don't think the area has enough volumen and is competitive enough to produce significantly lower prices. The high-field NMR area is almost a monopoly right now, the benchtops and lower field instruments are somewhat competitive. But even those are in price areas far beyond someone doing synthesis at home.
- kragen 5y agoAs I asked you above, how sensitive do the electronics need to be? How weak is the signal?
- dekhn 5y agoSome things change, but to make NMR cost effective would be cheating mother nature. The entire technique is based on producing a strong and homogenous magnetic field that can hold a lot of sample, only to probe the sample with weak RF and listen to its faint echoes. Industrial diamonds got "cheap" but large ones never did.
- kragen 5y agoYou could be right; certainly you know a great deal more about the subject than I do. What are the companies, or at least the industries, that would buy all the machines if you could make them much cheaper and/or better?
- fabian2k 5y agoBenchtops are at 60-90 MHz field strengths. That is not really enough to look at more complex molecules, the bigger routine NMR spectrometers are at 400-600 MHz (and there are even larger ones, but those are not used for small molecules that much). And even then those benchtops cost something close to 100k USD, that's quite far from affordable. The "room temperature" superconductors are not used at room temperature in these cases, they're still cooled down. And so far the only spectrometer I know of where they are used is the still extremely new 1.2 GHz Bruker. And that one is almost certainly somewhere between 10 and 20 million USD. The new superconductors are low temperature superconductors, not room temperature. And even then they still work better at lower temperatures. At best you can remove the liquid helium from the system and use liquid nitrogen only, which is an advantage but still really far from room temperature.
- kragen 5y agoThank you for explaining! Yes, I don't know if the current room-temperature superconductor material (which really is room temperature, 15°C) will ever be useful for this; it was only discovered in 02020, so it is very unlikely that anyone is using it in a product today, even if they find a way to apply the necessary pressure (267 GPa, thus requiring ultrahard anvils). You're probably thinking of something like YBCO, which is "high-temperature" in the sense you're describing, requiring only LN₂, not "room-temperature". Costs change over time. There was a time when solar panels cost 100k USD, too. A lot of the costs you're describing are NRE; others are costs that can be reduced.
- fabian2k 5y agoThe new spectrometers are using YBCO, and they are many years beyond schedule. That whole thing turned out to be a lot harder than many people seemed to expect. The magnets are not the only cost in NMR spectrometers, I think you're seriously understimating the amount of electronics in them. You need to detect very weak signals at several hundreds of MHz, that's not trivial.
- kragen 5y ago
- philipkglass 5y agoThey use rare earth permanent magnets and don't offer the resolution of superconducting magnet NMR, but they are much smaller and cheaper (tens of thousands of dollars, new) than superconducting units or the even older resistive electromagnet NMR units. The first one I saw was from picoSpin, which has since been acquired by Thermo Fisher Scientific. I think that there are multiple vendors now. Here's a current picoSpin unit: https://www.thermofisher.com/order/catalog/product/912A0913 https://www.thermofisher.com/order/catalog/product/912A0913
- dekhn 5y agoAn 80MHz desktop NMR in 2022 is hilarious. This owuld be great to put in a research lab or to teach students, but it's not something that could be used in a high volume, high quality pharma testing situation. (my phd in nmr is from 20 years ago... even then it was hard to justify the expense of nmr machines in structural biology...)