15 ms·
"rigid steel structure" Steel is springy. Tall steel-framed buildings and bridges routinely sway in wind, which is usually harmless to the structure but annoyi
by Animats 5y ago
"rigid steel structure"
Steel is springy. Tall steel-framed buildings and bridges routinely sway in wind, which is usually harmless to the structure but annoying to occupants. Unless you get harmonic oscillation, where the energy stored in the motion builds up, which can be a problem and
has destroyed bridges. Much of seismic design involves connections which raise the resonant frequency of the structure so it can't oscillate at a low frequency with high amplitude. That's what those triangular reinforcement beams one sees in San Francisco really do. It's also what all those rectangular trusses under the Golden Gate Bridge do. Those were a retrofit.
Wood's flexibility usually causes problems at joints. Nailed joints are not very strong in tension. Most construction today in areas with earthquakes or high winds involves metal reinforcement of joints. There's a collection of galvanized sheet metal parts for that at any Home Depot.
Tension joints for wood are seen in classic Japanese construction, in boats, and in cabinetry. Not so much in modern houses, partly because they work better in hardwood. I wonder if, in the next installment, the author will discuss those.
- rsync 5y agoI would agree that connections should be steel - I like the thick gauge, heavy duty simpson connectors, plates and column caps, etc., which allow you to lock in beams and columns with 3/4 machine bolts, etc.: https://www.strongtie.com/boltedcolumncaps_columncaps/cct_cap/p/cct https://www.strongtie.com/boltedcolumncaps_columncaps/cct_ca...
- clairity 5y ago> "Steel is springy. Tall steel-framed buildings and bridges routinely sway in wind, which is usually harmless to the structure but annoying to occupants." exactly, i recently mentioned my swaying-in-an-earthquake story[0], which was in a class A (steel+concrete) highrise office building. driving steel into the ground doesn't automatically mean it will rot and/or break in the first earthquake/windstorm that hits, even if that's a general possibility, given that engineers do think about that stuff when designing buildings. the gp comment is classic bullshit, plausible sounding but unconcerned with truth. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29665129 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29665129
- rsync 5y agoYou misunderstood my comment about steel in the ground ... I was trying to convince the OP that they don't need to worry about the corrosion since even in terrible circumstances the steel still lasts quite a while. With regard to your skyscraper experience: I'm not sure this is an apples-to-apples comparison. Skyscrapers are not made of skyscraper-height columns - they are a stack of elements that are connected every X height that has a well known flex per connection. It's also (hopefully) a uniform flex at every connection. But a smaller building would, indeed, have unbroken steel members (like a column) and you might "successfully" connect them to one another with an incredible amount of rigidity. It will either be tremendously strong throughout (good for you) or there will be some tiny piece of the chain that isn't as strong and can fail. I would be confident attempting this on a very small building. I would be hesitant to attempt this on a medium, two-story building. I would want wood framing. For aesthetic reasons, I would want that wood framing to be big timbers. I'd rather spend my money on those than on stainless steel roof framing :)
- clairity 5y agogotcha, my bad for misconstruing your point. joint strength relative to span strength is definitely a non-obvious issue to the average home owner-builder. i also vastly prefer wood/mass timber for aesthetic reasons. mass timber has better burn characteristics than steel, and i'd recently read that builders are actually starting to surround steel columns with cross-laminated timber (rather than concrete) for that reason[0], while providing greater strength/flexibility and better aesthetics. that's probably what i'd want if money were no object. [0]: mentioned in this article, but i'd read more about it elsewhere: https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2020/1/15/21058051/climate-change-building-materials-mass-timber-cross-laminated-clt https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2020/1/15/2105805... p.s. - i've also daydreamed about building warehouse style: a separate steel superstructure for the roof integrating solar panels and solar heating, with a simple stick-built house underneath.
- rsync 5y ago"... and i'd recently read that builders are actually starting to surround steel columns with cross-laminated timber ..." Somewhat relevant - might interest you: https://easternwhitepine.org/this-office-buildings-wooden-frame-was-built-without-fasteners-or-glue/ https://easternwhitepine.org/this-office-buildings-wooden-fr... TAMedia office building in Zurich.
- nashashmi 5y agoRigidity is actually a variable. rigid in the simplest of definition does mean no springy action. Rigid through various fixed connectors implies some spring like behaviors. This is my favorite topic and I could go on and on about this. Point: it is a matter of precise definition. How rigid are we talking?
- alex_sf 5y agoBut everything is a spring.
- archontes 5y agoLiterally everything. Harmonic oscillators all the way down.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoI'm Hooked. Tell me more.
- knicholes 5y agoCheck out de Broglie wavelength. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matter_wave https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matter_wave
- 867-5309 5y agoSpring Theory
- Koshkin 5y agoIn January
- MrsPeaches 5y agoThere’s a mass of theory out there. For some, that puts a spring in their step but others shouldn’t let their spirits be dampened.
- jahewson 5y ago> That's what those triangular reinforcement beams one sees in San Francisco really do. Interestingly enough that’s not quite right. They were added in response to the Tacoma Narrows collapse which was not, as is popularly misstated, destroyed by harmonic resonance but by aerostatic flutter. Certainly resonance due to cars or pedestrians can damage a bridge, but that’s a separate issue.
- Animats 5y agoRight. But you have to have a structure capable of long-period oscillation to be vulnerable to that particular problem. That's an inherent problem for long span bridges, but a building has to have a big unsupported span to be vulnerable to that problem. Sports stadium scale, though... All that potential lift.
- moogleii 5y ago> Tension joints for wood are seen in classic Japanese construction If you’re referring to the wood bracket system, that is true, but for posterity, it didn’t originate in Japan. Imported, very likely via Korea (which also uses it in their classic construction), from China.
- nihonde 5y ago> Tension joints for wood are seen in classic Japanese construction Japan also has several wooden buildings that purport to be 1,000+ years old—although these situations inevitably lead to Ship of Theseus debates.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoJapan basically rebuilds everything on a 20-30 year schedule. The temples are not an exception.
- teagoat 5y ago"... And then it burnt down" was probably the funniest thing I heard touring the "thousand" year old castles in Japan. Being completely levelled by a fire seemed to happen about once every 200 years.
- kjs3 5y agoSteel is springy. Unless it's not. Steel isn't one homogeneous thing. Depending on what trace elements you add, steel can have wildly different values of strength, rigidity & hardness.