14 ms·
Airbnb's experiment in combatting rental bias means swapping names for initials
- thepangolino 5y ago
- londons_explore 5y agoYou don't get rid of racism by making it illegal... People will always find a way. You get rid of racism by educating.
- AdmiralAsshat 5y ago[flagged]
- throw1234651234 5y agoAmerica has this thing - "We are all sooo different. BUT we are all the same." It doesn't work. Growing up in the ex USSR race wasn't really a thing - though we had a number of races in our class. No one said anything, about it, ever. I didn't even realize racism is a common thing until some time into a US university. Just wasn't something I gave any thought to. This is my subjective opinion - I know a lot of ex-USSR countries are considered pretty racist. On the other hand, in that area, EVERYONE was an indentured servant at some point, so that helps equalize things as well. I would also argue that a lot of groups enjoy playing off of race on BOTH sides (anti and pro).
- bdcravens 5y agoThis really isn’t a matter of a law, but I’ll speak to your point anyways. Laws rarely ever eliminate a problem; they also serve the purpose of punishing those who perform bad behavior.
- lokar 5y agoAnd the (mostly) help set a social Norm for behavior
- Angostura 5y agoActually, making it illegal - while not a panacea - is actually quite useful.
- snarf21 5y agoWell, some places are making education illegal so that is problematic too. I think the way you get rid of racism is always just via exposure. It is easy to hate group X when you don't know any X or are never in contact with them. People are always afraid of the unknown and they fill in the blanks in the worst possible way when there is no data.
- kube-system 5y agoAnd experience is the best way to educate someone. Experiences that biased hosts might not have if they are able to select guests that meet their preconceived biases.
- klyrs 5y agoFunny, that. The US is all "law and order" for all manner of crime whose root cause is poverty, and stands as the #1 most authoritarian country in the world going by the number of prisoners per capita. But somehow, punishing racism is crossing a line.
- rajin444 5y agoRacism is pattern matching (and can be good or bad - selecting a good bone marrow transplant donor is racist) so I’m not sure how educating will resolve it. People correctly notice trends. I think making it illegal and socially unacceptable is the only way to get rid of it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aeternum 5y agoWhile you'll probably get downvoted for this because it's not super politically correct, this is really a key point. It's uncomfortable but sometimes the biases are rational. IE there are subgroups that are more or less likely to cause damage. It can be quite unfair to many members of the subgroup. One option other than making it illegal is to socialize the risk. Airbnb could offer some universal damage insurance. This would at least remove the potential rational economic incentive for the property owner to select against certain groups.
- showerrain 5y agoEducating people of the facts is what led to this outcome. Obscuring the facts is what Airbnb is trying to do.
- motoxpro 5y agoSo you want Airbnb to run racism education classes instead of making a small UI change? Who does the educating? Why is it such a big deal to only see peoples initials? Is it just a slippery slope argument? I am confused.
- vmception 5y ago> Now, the property rental company is trying an experiment to help rectify the problem, changing the way Oregon-based guest profile names appear during the booking process I cant take any of these corporations seriously when they only do the progressive thing in a single jurisdiction in response to a single jurisdictions progressive laws > This update is consistent with the voluntary settlement agreement we reached in 2019 with individuals in Oregon Then that should be the title of the article, instead of the pr puff piece
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI think you are overlooking the word "experiment." I would expect this to be rolled out more extensively if the experiment were successful.
- vmception 5y agoI’m overlooking it because it’s a dumb way to get ahead of the PR hit if the state or the plaintiffs had released an article featuring the same information.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI don't even get where you're coming from here. You seem determined to be hostile for the sake of being hostile.
- vmception 5y agoTry to think of it from the African American plaintiff view and anyone that has a confirmation they would encounter a worse experience for baseless reasons. The plaintiffs sued in Oregon, and got a settlement. They only going to travel to Oregon? Many jurisdictions, including the federal government have similar laws. The challenge of the law itself never reached a judicial conclusion, so if AirBnB was willing to settle there, it was either because they thought it was a pretty solid law, or they made a cost benefit analysis to settle. If the latter, then the same is true other places. But instead they are making a harder business decision to resist changing anything, just to spin it as being an ally to marginalized customers. This is a puff piece for a technology that AirBnB could roll out anywhere randomly across any population for the A/B test. Its harder for them to geofence this, harder for them to spin this, as opposed to just doing the normal software rollout strategy. So that’s why. Think about it from the affected plaintiff or customers perspective. Yes, sure, potentially roll it out after this “experiment”. But this is yet another example of why representation matters. This wouldn’t have even gotten greenlit this way if there were more decision makers familiar with this segment of the population by living it.
- howeyc 5y agoThis is an interesting idea. I've wondered myself about doing something similar for interview processes in an attempt to remove bias. Assigning every candidate a random number, address them by the number on all correspondence. Remove names from resumes, applications, replace experience on resumes with "random corp 1", random corp 2, random school 1 etc. All communication text based.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoYou'd lose an awful lot of signal by only using text communication. In particular, I don't see how you could get any sense of how this person might interact with teammates doing it this way.
- austincheney 5y agoAt the point of initial candidate filtration (competence, qualification) that doesn’t matter. Not at all. Save the signal bits for after qualification against a baseline is affirmed. That is the only way to move past bias and be objective.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoI don't think you're talking about the same thing the person I replied to is.
- bunfunton 5y agoAh yes hire your cog for the machine with no regard to team fit
- Angostura 5y agoThe problem is that 'team fit' can often be a synomymn for 'someone like me'. If there are particular attributes that you want to hire for, those should be in the job/person spec and candidates should be assessed against them.
- dijonman2 5y ago
- kerneloftruth 5y agoAs a business, a key metric to measure in the experiment should be how many hosts does Airbnb lose as a consequence.
- hooande 5y agoI don't use Airbnb much, but last time I tried to it was highly recommended to upload a profile photo and they required me to upload a pic of my id. The impression I got was that hosts were looking at the profile picture and choosing who to accept as a guest. Maybe my experience was rare or I misunderstood the situation. But this seemed way more conducive to racism than full names.
- Miner49er 5y agoIt looks like they made a change in 2018 that they don't show guest pictures until after accepting a booking: https://www.airbnb.com/resources/hosting-homes/a/airbnb-answers-guest-profile-photos-77 https://www.airbnb.com/resources/hosting-homes/a/airbnb-answ...
- jollybean 5y agoThis is a neat idea, but misapplied. You have 100% choice over who you want to let into your home. The law could apply to registered Bed and Breakfast businesses, and perhaps those where people are renting a professionally managed full home or flat - but not for people inviting others into their homes, and renting just a room. If a woman does not want to rent a room to the 6 foot 4 burly biker with tattoos it's 100% her prerogative. In fact, if a woman doesn't want to rent a room to men at all, that's perfectly fine as well. These are rooms in people's living spaces, which to me is distinct from regular business transactions. The initial premise of AirBnB was something absolutely more intimate than a 'business' and they consistently have touted it as such. I think that there's a distinction between what AirBnB has promoted - and a regular Bed and Breakfast, and even distinct from Uber/Cab, which is something much more transactional.
- KarlKemp 5y agoWhen did you last stay at an AirBnB? It might also differ by location. But the three or four bookings I had over the last four years were all apartments rented with the sole purpose to rent them out.
- Miner49er 5y agoThis is completely ignoring the Fair Housing Act of 1968. As soon as you start renting out your "home", you lose the right to choose who you let into it on the basis of the renter's race, gender, religion, or nationality.
- rootsudo 5y agoNope - you can discriminate legally if you cohabit your home. "are individual bedrooms within an apartment a “dwelling” protected by the Fair Housing Act? The court gave its answer on February 3rd, and the answer was no: the Act does not protect roommate searches." " The home is the center of our private lives. Roommates note our comings and goings, observe whom we bring back at night, hear what songs we sing in the shower, see us in various stages of undress and learn intimate details most of us prefer to keep private…. [two paragraphs omitted] “Liberty protects the person from unwarranted government intrusions into a dwelling or other private places. In our tradition the State is not omnipresent in the home.” Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558, 562 (2003). Holding that the FHA applies inside a home or apartment would allow the government to restrict our ability to choose roommates compatible with our lifestyles. This would be a serious invasion of privacy, autonomy and security. For example, women will often look for female roommates because of modesty or security concerns. As roommates often share bathrooms and common areas, a girl may not want to walk around in her towel in front of a boy. She might also worry about unwanted sexual advances or becoming romantically involved with someone she must count on to pay the rent. An orthodox Jew may want a roommate with similar beliefs and dietary restrictions, so he won’t have to worry about finding honey-baked ham in the refrigerator next to the potato latkes… Taking away the ability to choose roommates with similar dietary restrictions and religious convictions will substantially burden the observant Jew’s ability to live his life and practice his religion faithfully. The same is true of individuals of other faiths that call for dietary restrictions or rituals inside the home."
- roamerz 5y agoDoes Airbnb offer other alternative methods of identifying riffraff? I don’t use the service but I wouldn’t unless they offered a way for me to profile customers. Background checks and/or ratings would probably suffice. Name and picture are obviously very subjective but people use what is available and probably won’t participate unless they have a way to protect their business.
- alisonkisk 5y ago
- kyeb 5y agoAirbnb hosts rate their guests. Seems like a decent system to me.
- noogle 5y agoThis system creates a vicious cycle - cannot get a rental without history, and cannot accumulate history without rentals. It creates a gatekeeper that enables discriminative behaviors.
- roamerz 5y agoWelcome to a world where everyone is judged to be equal to the lowest common denominator unless proven otherwise. Do you have a lock on your front door? How do you determine who you invite into your home? Enabling discriminative behaviors does not mean using discriminative behaviors. It’s called freedom. Judge people by their actions not by what you think they are allowed to see by a gatekeeper.
- aldebran 5y agoThis is horribly gamed. Host/renter give each other good ratings. Or neither rates because neither is sure what the other person will do so they wait for the other in a stalemate.
- ilumanty 5y agoYou mean some sort of social score? Now that would be groundbreaking. /s
- kruxigt 5y ago
- imapeopleperson 5y agoIf we are going to do this, then the policy should extend to school and job applications.
- 3pt14159 5y agoThe problem of discrimination black people face is very real. Four or five years ago I was traveling to DC and booked a room in a home for a week near the outskirts. I'm white. The owner was black. He had a white wife, so they could have done things differently, but he wanted to make sure that anyone coming in his home was comfortable being around a black person. I found this out when he thanked me for coming to his home even though he was black. Basically thanking me for not being racist. So we got into a whole discussion about it. Super warm dude and one of the best hosts I've ever had. It boggles my mind how much race still matters in America.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe way to address it is not making racial discrimination illegal. Private discrimination is still ultimately within a person's legitimate moral rights. Using the force of the state to ban it, is unjustifiable, and deeply misguided.
- lokar 5y agoAirbnb is a "public accommodation", by law and the choice of Airbnb. If you don't want to rent out your property on that basis no one is forcing you to.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoYes I know the law. The law is ideocratic, in mandating that people act in their private (in the true sense of private) capacity in accordance with a set of ideological values. It assumes that the moral good of a person acting out a particular value justifies using force to control a person's actions. This attitude towards others is sanctimonious and irreverent to people's rights. It is not a legitimate use of the force of the state. Jim Crow laws were similarly ideocratic, in imposing pro-segregationist ideological values onto private citizens. We foolishly went from one form of sanctimonious/domineering ideocracy, to another.
- Blahah 5y ago
- literallyaduck 5y agoVrbo, HomeAway, Stayz, Booking.com or others may fill the gap, and some house loaners might attempt to use KYC to identify customers prior to doing business.
- Miner49er 5y agoUntil they are all sued as well.
- literallyaduck 5y agoKYC is an unescapable federal requirement, for the home owners who rent out their homes and a non-US based company has no obligation to follow US guidelines around discrimination unless a treaty forces their hand. I wouldn't rent my home out to anyone no matter the skin color, religion, or genders, and frankly it is a bit gross for hotels, hostels and BNBs to exist. If you can't avoid travel camping keeps you at arms length from mingling with other humans filth. Weather might prohibit your options, but I'm a firm believer that "Hell is other people."
- CryptoPunk 5y ago
- coolso 5y agoThere is no better way to scare away customers than to provide them with even less control over what is theirs, especially with something as personal as over who rents out their homes. It takes gall and hopefully this encourages more competitors to enter the market - seeing that AirBNB doesn’t have the greatest reputation as it is anyway. The more you hide information from someone, the more their red flags start going up. Many people are already wary of using AirBNB as a property owner, but now? “You will rent to who we say you rent to and you have little to no say in it even though it’s your own.” No thanks.
- FireBeyond 5y agoCool. So what? The free market will figure it out. You don't have a right to third parties providing you money making schemes for your home that meet your standards alone. They are free to interpose their own conditions, fees, etc. In many places AirBnB renters are openly flouting the law in listing their property in the first place. My sympathies for them not having sufficient platforms on which to do so without companies "gall" in trying to ensure non-discrimination is virtually zero.
- filed 5y agoReleasing stats on race of renters and which race has the most problem renters would help ease fears... if the stats show that all groups behave the same on the whole and there is no financial motivation to be biased. Or if there is a difference then Airbnb could say if anything bad happens to your home then we got you.. then you wouldn't be afraid of anything.
- aeternum 5y agoSome kind of damage insurance definitely seems like the right way to solve this. It's interesting that we are okay with discrimination in some cases but not in others, for example young males pay higher car insurance premiums (because they legitimately represent more risk). It's still pretty unfair for those young males that are very careful drivers.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> because they legitimately represent more risk Do they? Two equivalent ways of approaching the problem: Risk is the same for everyone and decreases with age OR risk stays the same for every member of the population throughout their lives. What's interesting with fatal car crashes is that they can happen only once in a driver's life (you can't die twice). So when looking at an age cohort, the young male who dies at 18 can't die again at 36 and is therefore going to be excluded from his age cohort. Now the question is how could we predict the individual risk level (parent income? Education? Zip Code? Race?). Doing it accurately would probably be illegal, so we accept that the young careful drivers will just foot the bill for everyone.
- aeternum 5y agoFatal crashes make up something like 0.27% of accidents so I doubt it even factors into the insurance cost. Almost all the insurance payouts are accidents that significantly damage the car or require expensive medical attention, but those can definitely happen more than once for a young male (or anyone).
- 5y ago
- Ntrails 5y agoWill they still be reporting sex to the hosts as a discriminatory factor? I can very much imagine single female hosts being wary of letting to male tennant.
- Gigachad 5y agoAirbnb at least used to explicitly permit gender bias for shared spaces.
- lucaspm98 5y agoAh, if still true why am I not surprised they’re only helping the protected classes that are politically/culturally advantageous at the moment.
- Gigachad 5y agoIt is interesting to think about it. It is perfectly logical for a woman to decide they want to rent a room out to only other females since they quite obviously lower their risk of sexual assault like this. But what if we found data showing that there were other groups which also had a higher risk of sexual assault or other negative dangers. Why would it only be appropriate to discriminate on gender when the reason for doing so would justify discrimination for other factors.
- lucaspm98 5y agoIt seems like a direct contradiction in my eyes. On a broad level, yes, male renters statistically commit more crimes of all kinds. However, if applying the same logic of preventing visual bias hosts should not be able to apply gender stereotypes to individual renters. I'd also imagine that statistically an older Asian woman would be a safer renter than a young white man with face tattoos. This data, particularly on race, would never be released or likely even analyzed internally, but I'd be surprised if there were not some visual indicators that correlate to host safety. Why would this group bias be prevented but bias on gender allowed? I suspect the obvious answer is true, they will only prevent bias when it's in fashion.
- paxys 5y agoThis would have been very welcome like 5-7 years ago when I would struggle to get a single booking accepted on Airbnb with my brown name, while asking a white female friend to do it for me would result in a response within minutes. Anecdotally it isn't too much of a problem now since most Airbnb listings I encounter these days are commercially managed and less prone to individual bias.
- lmilcin 5y agoWhile I agree with the move (your face or name should have nothing to do with whether you get service) I see one potential problem. If I was black I would probably prefer to be upfront denied than rent a place from somebody that is very racist and face possible problems from an unhinged owner. I don't see a better solution here but maybe somebody else does.