3 ms·
Depending on the workload: does it need to? Most people I've seen use laptops near chargers, or at least within 2 hours of the nearest charging opportunity. So
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Depending on the workload: does it need to?
Most people I've seen use laptops near chargers, or at least within 2 hours of the nearest charging opportunity. Sometimes people travel and need more, but I don't think it's that common to need eight hours of charge at maximum performance.
Don't get me wrong, the M1 is an engineering marvel and as Apple's competitors move to a similar node size I hope they too will get these power usage benefits some way or another, but I don't think the average consumer needs all the features the M1 offers.
If Intel can come up with a laptop that's faster than the M1 at two thirds the price with the only downside being that you only get four hours of battery out of it with all cores clocked to their limit, then I don't see why most people who need the horsepower would pay extra for the M1, especially with its restrictions on what operating systems it can run comfortably. The impressive efficiency of the M1 simply isn't that pressing a matter for most people.
I hope Intel is right, and I hope they beat Apple. We've seen AMD overtake Intel and then saw their innovations slow to a crawl while they were ahead. Apple might end up doing the very same if there is no competition in this space. If Intel, AMD or Qualcom produce a chip even better than the M1, we can all only stand to gain from this.
- schappim 5y agoAgreed, but let's also not forget that Intel's #onejob is to build chips.
- ipqk 5y agoHeat & Fans matter too. 99% of my usage of my M1 macbook is in clam-shell mode, so I don't care about the battery life. But I do love that it doesn't dissipate much heat and that I never hear it.
- hamandcheese 5y agoI am always within 1 minutes of a charger. My i9 MacBook still dies on me all the time. Get to 5% and go to the bathroom? Oops, it died, and I can’t join my next meeting on time. Start a call at 10% battery? Will definitely have to interrupt to go plug in. I want performance and battery.
- nightfly 5y agoI like my work M1 macbook air, but when battery gets below 10% it seems to get very unhappy... Requires sitting on the charger for a while before it will even start up properly
- eyelidlessness 5y agoI may be wrong, but I suspect this is because macOS fibs at/about low power to accommodate hibernation. (I see similar behavior on my intel MBP, so I doubt it’s platform specific.)
- cassianoleal 5y agoInteresting. I usually get still 30min-1h out of my M1 MBA on a 10% charge. It usually only hibernates a few minutes after hitting the 1% mark.
- cassianoleal 5y agoCase in point: about 12 minutes ago my laptop informed me the battery is low. It was at 10%. It's now at 9% so I will probably still get over 1h with it. Edit: I went a total of 64 minutes after hitting 10%. Unfortunately the whole OS crashed at that point. I have been having issues with running 2 network extensions simultaneously, and I have a feeling the crash was more related to that than to running out of battery. It took 10s after I plugged it into the mains for it to respond to the power button. Had this been a regular hibernate instead of a crash, I would have expected to be back at a fully usable desktop in less than 30s total. Unfortunately it took about 1 minute to fully boot and reopen all apps, which all things considered is not bad at all.
- Tagbert 5y agoBattery charge is really an estimate, not an absolute measurement. It is based on , among other things, the drop in voltage as the battery charge gets low. If your battery management system is a little off in calibration, that 10% could be closer to 5%.
- 5y ago
- newlisp 5y agoIf Intel can come up with a laptop that's faster than the M1 at two thirds the price with the only downside being that you only get four hours of battery out of it with all cores clocked to their limit I don't see how Intel can come up with a macbook air equivalent at a price of $350.
- colinmhayes 5y agoMacbook air is $1250 unless you want to be stuck with 250 gigs of disk. 2/3 of that is $833 which seems completely within their ability.
- Gigachad 5y agoThis feels like a cope tbh. People work around poor battery life because that's the only option until recently. I used to feel similarly but since I got my M1 macbook, there have been several times where the excellent battery life have been great. Recently I was at an airport a few hours before my flight and I ended up just playing games on a food court table. No need to huddle around one of the few seats with power points. Also great to pick up and move to a different room if the current one is noisy without needing to grab your charger as well. And even in the office, sometimes there will be a multi hour session in a meeting room which is enough to drain everyone's intel macbooks flat.
- caconym_ 5y agoHeat seems just as big an issue as battery life, if not bigger. Can i9-12900HK-equipped laptops really exist in the same highly convenient size/weight bracket as the new MBPs and make use of all that power without extreme fan noise, extreme chassis heat, and/or extreme thermal throttling? My past experience with Intel mobile CPUs says no, absolutely not. Honestly, my past experience with Intel mobile CPUs versus my current experience with my new MBP says I will never buy one of the former again, ever, unless it's otherwise a truly special machine or I have no choice. I will admit that I'm not really the target market for the big, chunky laptops that can make a 75W+ TDP anything but miserable, because I have a desktop machine that still wipes the floor with anything in that segment. The truth about the M1 Pro/Max SoCs is that they won't give you the absolute hottest performance around in CPU or GPU, but they will give you legitimately great performance along with other attributes that are best-in-class taken together, mainly size, weight, battery endurance, and thermals. And those things do matter to a lot of people.
- rsynnott 5y ago> at two thirds the price I wouldn't necessarily bet on that. RRP for the chip they're talking about is $635; it's the top end. M1 Pro machines (the Max is a red herring; the cheaper Pros have the same CPU performance) start at $2k. Generally, laptops containing Intel's most expensive mobile chips cost more than that. Like, it's probably in principle possible to produce a laptop containing the offending chip for $1320, but I doubt you'll see many of them. Power use also has implications for the thermal envelope. Most laptops using Intel's current top-end chips can't sustain the top-end performance for long at all; they need to throttle to avoid melting.
- solarkraft 5y agoMost people you've seen use laptops near chargers, or at least within 2 hours of the nearest charging opportunity, because their battery life sucks. I used to do that, but with my new M1 Laptop I can finally move freely and even afford to leave the house without even taking a charger with me, which feels great.