3 ms·
Is there a name for the effect where there is a superior product X, everyone who uses it agrees that X is superior (to the point of acquiring their own personal
by aidenn0 5y ago
Is there a name for the effect where there is a superior product X, everyone who uses it agrees that X is superior (to the point of acquiring their own personal X's when they can), but when shown to those responsible for procurement, they say "I don't get it" and continue to order the same old thing?
I'm specifically thinking of cases where it's not corruption causing the purchases, but plain-old incompetence.
- AdamN 5y agoYou might be interested in the concept of 'satisficing'. A product needs to be significantly better to replace an existing product that is satisfactory. Your point is slightly different though and can be seen with M16 still being the assault rifle of choice in the US military even though it's not as good as other products by most measures. That's more the IBM effect where the agent deciding which option to buy has nothing to gain by challenging the status quo. If IBM fails, it's not your fault. If you choose something else and it fails, it's your fault. Success won't be recognized either way so the obvious choice for a purchase is IBM.
- aidenn0 5y agoIt's interesting because the difference between the jerrican and existing cans were lots of small affordances that add up: fewer tools needed and easier to move around. In the end, soldiers will find a way to put gas in vehicles, so there's never a problem from the strategic view even though several small efficiencies can add up to a big difference both for a single person gassing up a tank and then multiplied by the number of tanks that are involved in warfare. When OS X came out about 20 years ago, the UI was so much better than Linux desktop environments of the time. I think that is a relatively uncontroversial view, but try fitting the differences between them into a checkbox-style acquisition table and they both use the basic WIMP interface; the obvious differences (icon dock, global menu bar) are if anything something that people moving from Linux to Mac dislike about it, yet those same people will tell you that the overall experience is better.
- tomatotomato37 5y agoI'm imagine sunken costs fallacy applies too with the costs being tooling, supply lines, etc. Changing from smooth tin cans to stamped steel cans with internal liners does require a substantial investment in new tooling.
- chmod600 5y agoThat's called "central planning". Central planners simply can't collect the right information anywhere near quickly enough to make efficient decisions. Modern computing means it works for quantifiable things. But when it's something like inconvenience, it's hard to quantify and central planning will still fail.
- freemint 5y agoWhy are people so ignorant of the discipline of optimization? If you know it's within some interval you can just so robust optimization, if even that fact is unknown there is distributionally robust optimization. Central planners don't need perfect information either and infrastructure is more easily build to accommodate a central planner then a market of spatially distributed decision makers. If you find optimization to authoritarian try multi-objective optimization where people vote where on the Pareto front they want to go.
- chmod600 5y agoCan you provide an example of how that would have resulted in better gas cans for the allies earlier?
- freemint 5y agoCan you provide an explanation how getting better gas cans to the front line was not "Central planning" during a war time command economy? Or how more market forces on the German side lead to the right information being discovered quickly enough to make efficient decisions while it didn´t in the others countries?