5 ms·
If someone writes a best seller and kicks the bucket, it'd sort of suck that someone like Disney could swoop in and make a bunch of movies without paying a dime
by cogman10 5y ago
If someone writes a best seller and kicks the bucket, it'd sort of suck that someone like Disney could swoop in and make a bunch of movies without paying a dime of royalties to the author's family. Or that a bunch of publishers can have a field day republishing the best seller diluting all the work of the original publisher.
But on the flip side, 90+ years is really WAY too long.
Cut it to 20 years. Long enough to capture the initial buzz, but not so long that we end up with shit staying under the mouse's thumb forever.
- dlp211 5y agoThis is exactly what Disney did do though; Snow White, Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast, Pinocchio; to become a massive corp. And now that they are a massive Corp that just can buy the rights to any copyrighted material locking out competitors. Imagine if others had the chance to compete.
- troupe 5y agoDisney doesn't own the rights to Pinocchio. You are free to make your own movie with book version of the the characters and the story. Carlo Collodi was dead by 1890 so Disney definitely didn't "swoop in" and benefit at his or his descendent's expense. I believe the other stories you mention are even older.
- superluserdo 5y ago>Disney doesn't own the rights to Pinocchio. You are free to make your own movie with book version of the the characters and the story. This is very much an "in principle" thing. In practice, many of these traditional stories have (sadly) become synonymous with the Disney version, so Disney's work is basically the canonical version. This gives Disney a very good sword of Damocles to hang over the heads of anyone else trying to adapt these folk stories: to my understanding if you include a single copyrightable adaptation or embellishment of the original that was written by Disney without "prior art", you're liable to be steamrollered by the lawyer army and be ruined.
- judge2020 5y agoPinocchio was just fine in the Shrek movies, and I imagine Eisner wasn't happy that Universal of all people used him (as, only a few years prior, Universal poached a bunch of imagineers and made The Lost Continent, which copied a lot of elements of 'Beastly Kingdom', the original name for Animal Kingdom), so it must have took a lot of lawyers saying "this is a bad idea" when Eisner surely suggested they sue over using Pinocchio.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Disney doesn't own the rights to Pinocchio. [...] Carlo Collodi was dead by 1890 so Disney definitely didn't "swoop in" and benefit at his or his descendent's expense. This illustrates (IMO, the evils of over-long) current copyright terms rather perfectly: Disney didn't swoop in and benefit at Collodi's or his descendent's expense under the copyright rules of the time. Had current -- heavily Disney-influenced, so presumably supported and wished-for by Disney -- terms been in force then, this would have been a case of Disney swooping in and benefitting at Collodi's or his descendent's expense. Dunno what exactly this means... Besides Disney possibly being quite hypocritical. And yes, most of Disney's older great hits about princesses and princes (Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, Cinderella...) are based on German folk tales collected by the brothers Grimm and first published in 1812.
- cogman10 5y agoCompanies can (and have) make their own versions of all those. What they can't use is disney's representation of those characters.
- judge2020 5y agoThey did that via public domain usage; the OP is making the point that extending it just to "death of author" will allow Disney to continue to do this. Nowadays, they surely can just buy the rights to stuff they want, but that's a completely separate issue and not one that copyright law is meant to address.
- tehjoker 5y agoI'd rather do away with it entirely, but under capitalism, I would reduce it to 7-10 years though initially it was 14 years. https://www.arl.org/copyright-timeline/ https://www.arl.org/copyright-timeline/
- commoner 5y ago20 years is a reasonable length for copyrights, since many patents in the U.S. also expire after 20 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Term_of_patent_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Term_of_patent_in_the_United_S...
- shagie 5y agoI have photographs that I took 20 years ago that I occasionally sell a print of. You are suggesting that that material now be part of the public domain? For that matter, you're suggesting GCC version 3.0.3, Emacs 21.2 and all prior versions be public domain and not have any copyright or copyleft protection on it? And thus, I could take the source code for them, modify it, close source it release my own version.
- tshaddox 5y ago> You are suggesting that that material now be part of the public domain? Yes. I could be wrong, but I feel comfortable guessing that you were sufficiently incentivized to take those photographs 20 years ago. Also, you could still sell prints!
- cogman10 5y agoAbsolutely. Would you not have taken the photo or sold it had you known the timeframe for it's value would be limited to 20 years? I suspect that, yes, you'd still take that photo. So long as the timespan is long enough to benefit the creator (and thus, encourage creativity) but not so long as to forever lock up the creation, then I see no harm in a much shorter copyright timeframe. Why should I care if a 20 year old compiler or text editor ends up having closed source versions? And, on the flip side, wouldn't it be neat if we had Windows XP source code in the public domain? Now consider the fact that with a 20 year lifespan on copyright every streaming service would have access to everything published in 2001 and earlier. 1 service could give you a bonkers amount of content.
- ejb999 5y agowhy limit it to books or other creative creations - if you buy a house, you get exclusive use for 20 years - after that, other people just get to move into the unused bedrooms - after all, your kids are probably grown by now and you don't need them anymore. How is this different - why should I be entitled to get, for free, something someone else created and owns.
- ejb999 5y ago>>90+ years is really WAY too long. Way too long for who? I don't own any copyrights - probably never will - but why am I supposedly owed the right to use something for free that someone else created after some arbitrary amount of time? You might be able to make a case that it is in the public's interest to only patent life-saving medicine for X number of years, but who is really harmed when the author of a book retains the rights in perpetuity?
- phlakaton 5y agoWho is harmed? Creators. Consumers. Anyone who ever pined for access to something out of print, or in a vault, or otherwise squatted on for no productive reason. Anyone who ever had to guess what they could sample or what they could not; what would be legally considered derivative of some decades-old musical expression (many of which resemble each other superficially) and what would not.
- anamax 5y ago> I don't own any copyrights - probably never will Actually, you do own lots of copyrights. For example, you own the copyright on almost every blog post that you made. (The exceptions are things like lists of facts.) You own the copyright on every picture that you've taken or drawn.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> why am I supposedly owed the right to use something for free that someone else created after some arbitrary amount of time That's the natural default. If two people don't interfere with each other's happiness, then there is no copyright. You don't need a right to copy, the owner needs a right to stop you from copying. Why are they owed the right to a government-enforced monopoly? Well, xyz there are good reasons but also those reasons make more sense with a time limit.
- cogman10 5y ago> who is really harmed when the author of a book retains the rights in perpetuity? Anyone that wants to make (or accidentally makes) derivative works based on that work. This is especially apparent in the music industry. Write a story about a prince waking a princess with a kiss an you run the very real risk of getting sued into oblivion by Disney. We, the public, lose out on creative works because creative folk have to be VERY careful with how they approach art to try and minimize their exposure to lawsuits. Very similar to the harm done by software patents.
- anothernewdude 5y agoThat's precisely how Disney started.