3 ms·

Indian comedian jailed for joke he didn't even tell

12 points by hermitcrab 5y ago

mkjmkumar 5y ago
People here in India in panic on some related things. I think this is more of human right issue than a political.
raxxorrax 5y ago
It is time that fighting for civil liberties like free speech and others becomes a left wing topic again. No more protecting false sentimentality, no minority profits from exception to free speech, this is about enforcing opinions on others.
- hermitcrab 5y ago
  It is happening all over the world. In the UK the government have recently criminalised many forms of peaceful protest.
sigmaprimus 5y ago
So what was the joke? At the bare minimum a description of the joke seems like a crucial part to this story.
- whatever1 5y ago
  Why does the content matter? I should be able to shout anything and not be thrown to jail. (Btw they criticized a Supreme Court decision)
  - sigmaprimus 5y ago
    The story's headline is "Indian comedian jailed for joke he didn't even tell"...so it matters to the people reading the story, otherwise it is not a very good story. if it is not important, then why include it in the headline?
chakkepolja 5y ago
As a request, can we stop posting deeply political content to HN? Especially anything about India turns into a flamewar here.
- logifail 5y ago
  My wish for 2022 would be that more people would care about protecting civil liberties and free speech, and that fewer people would see issues such as those as "deeply political".
  - chakkepolja 5y ago
    Posting that to HN doesn't make it any better. Just brings the propaganda machine here too. If you don't believe it, look at the amount of propaganda in any India related threads, from both sides of politics.
- hermitcrab 5y ago
  Is wanting people all over the world to have basic freedoms "deeply political"? Personally, I think it is a lot more important than the latest tech trivia.
hulitu 5y ago
PILATE: I will not have my fwiends widiculed by the common soldiewy. Anybody else feel like a little... giggle... when I mention my fwiend... Biggus... GUARD #1: chuckling PILATE: ...Dickus? GUARD #1: chuckling PILATE: What about you? Do you find it... wisible... when I say the name... 'Biggus'... GUARD #3: chuckle PILATE: ...'Dickus'? GUARD #1 and GUARD #2: chuckling PILATE: He has a wife, you know. You know what she's called? She's called... 'Incontinentia'. 'Incontinentia Buttocks'. GUARDS: laughing PILATE: Stop! What is all this? GUARDS: Ha, ha ha ha ha ha... PILATE: I've had enough of this wowdy webel sniggewing behavior. Silence! Call yourselves Pwaetowian guards? You're not-- Seize him! Seize him! Blow your noses and seize him!

12 points by hermitcrab 5y ago

People here in India in panic on some related things. I think this is more of human right issue than a political.

It is time that fighting for civil liberties like free speech and others becomes a left wing topic again. No more protecting false sentimentality, no minority profits from exception to free speech, this is about enforcing opinions on others.

hermitcrab 5y ago
It is happening all over the world. In the UK the government have recently criminalised many forms of peaceful protest.

sigmaprimus 5y ago

So what was the joke? At the bare minimum a description of the joke seems like a crucial part to this story.

whatever1 5y ago
Why does the content matter? I should be able to shout anything and not be thrown to jail. (Btw they criticized a Supreme Court decision)
- sigmaprimus 5y ago
  The story's headline is "Indian comedian jailed for joke he didn't even tell"...so it matters to the people reading the story, otherwise it is not a very good story. if it is not important, then why include it in the headline?

chakkepolja 5y ago

As a request, can we stop posting deeply political content to HN? Especially anything about India turns into a flamewar here.

logifail 5y ago
My wish for 2022 would be that more people would care about protecting civil liberties and free speech, and that fewer people would see issues such as those as "deeply political".
- chakkepolja 5y ago
  Posting that to HN doesn't make it any better. Just brings the propaganda machine here too. If you don't believe it, look at the amount of propaganda in any India related threads, from both sides of politics.
hermitcrab 5y ago
Is wanting people all over the world to have basic freedoms "deeply political"? Personally, I think it is a lot more important than the latest tech trivia.

hulitu 5y ago

PILATE: I will not have my fwiends widiculed by the common soldiewy. Anybody else feel like a little... giggle... when I mention my fwiend... Biggus... GUARD #1: chuckling PILATE: ...Dickus? GUARD #1: chuckling PILATE: What about you? Do you find it... wisible... when I say the name... 'Biggus'... GUARD #3: chuckle PILATE: ...'Dickus'? GUARD #1 and GUARD #2: chuckling PILATE: He has a wife, you know. You know what she's called? She's called... 'Incontinentia'. 'Incontinentia Buttocks'. GUARDS: laughing PILATE: Stop! What is all this? GUARDS: Ha, ha ha ha ha ha... PILATE: I've had enough of this wowdy webel sniggewing behavior. Silence! Call yourselves Pwaetowian guards? You're not-- Seize him! Seize him! Blow your noses and seize him!