3 ms·
"Qualified" requires qualification. Domingos obviously feels he is the arbiter of qualification but a faculty is a delicate thing. I think CP Snow pointed out a
by ggm 5y ago
"Qualified" requires qualification. Domingos obviously feels he is the arbiter of qualification but a faculty is a delicate thing. I think CP Snow pointed out a college has to last beyond the life of the current senior encumbents and a dullard with few jokes, but who knows how to pass the salt quietly might be more important than a genius with temper tantrums sometimes. You need a fertile mix. Suitability, the idoneous candidate, is a non trivial question.
The important question is not "who is more highly qualified" it's contextual: at the payscale we hire for, and the roles we need filled, from the abundantly capable candidates who do we actually... WANT.
I don't have a role in hiring any more, but from qualified candidates I've hired for diversity and I'd do it again without question. I know of companies who hire alternating men and women to maintain equity. They're successful. Domingos appears to want to imply this cannot be true or equitable.
If it's measured solely by grant applications and peer review publishing, remember bad actors score highly in both. Perhaps Domingos forgets the pastoral quality of staff in a department? Does he think this has no importance? Women students need women faculty to become successful.
In the 1960s and 1970s the compsci field was not skewed as much as it has been since. Why is this?
I am told by Iranian friends, reliable ones, that 75% of students in engineering are women. What would Domingos expect faculty ratios to be, in Iran?
- robbedpeter 5y agoThat could trivially be the consequence of men's relative freedom to travel, while women's movements are rigidly controlled. Looking to Iran for any comparison regarding the equitable treatment of women is beyond absurd. Let us know when honor killings and genital mutilation and child marriages have been dealt with, and maybe then we can start including Iran in discussions about how to treat women. --- With regards to the rest - If I'm paying for an education, I don't give a flying rat's ass about how much sensitivity and care has been put into achieving the correct ratios of skin color, gender, sexuality, or really any other factor than the qualifications of the person from which in learning. I want the best teachers. Social justice issues are cultural. Trying to arbitrarily and artificially correct such problems with bureaucratic checklists is a tragic and infuriating response, often introducing whole new categories of harm. All they accomplish is the selection of one person over another based on their race, gender, or sexuality, regardless of the hard work and effort expended as an individual human being. No matter how you slice it, that is a deeply wrong and troubling mindset. Race and gender and sexuality aren't knowledge, competence, capability, or character. They aren't qualifications. Treating them as such is social justice theater.
- raxxorrax 5y ago> Trying to arbitrarily and artificially correct such problems with bureaucratic checklists is a tragic and infuriating response It isn't just an infuriating response, it is racism and sexism. There is institutional sexism because they implement it. Your motivation behind your deed is irrelevant.
- raxxorrax 5y agoIn Iran women try to get into these jobs because it promises them freedom and self-determination. They don't have to do that in freer countries and most decide against it.