4 ms·
"Old LISPer that I am, I also looked at various current dialects of Lisp and Scheme—but, as is historically usual for Lisp, lots of clever design was rendered a
by jimbokun 18y ago
"Old LISPer that I am, I also looked at various current dialects of Lisp and Scheme—but, as is historically usual for Lisp, lots of clever design was rendered almost useless by scanty or nonexistent documentation, incomplete access to POSIX/UNIX facilities, and a small but nevertheless deeply fragmented user community."
I find this still a pretty accurate assessment of the world of Lisp, 8 years on. I'm keeping an eye on Clojure, though, as a potential break in this pattern.
- KirinDave 18y agoAs does MzScheme. This rift and indecision in lisp implementations only exists as long as we continue to allow it. If people just start hacking and using a system in larger numbers, it'll grow. The world is so ripe for the next big language to be Scheme.
- j2d2 18y agoIf people just start hacking and using a system in larger numbers, it'll grow. If being the magic word... The world is so ripe for the next big language to be Scheme. Why do you say that? Scheme is not new. Something radical would have to happen to make it popular out of nowhere.
- KirinDave 18y agoWhat's new is where a lot of independent programmers are. Tons of people are coming off of a Ruby and Python high and wondering where the cutting edge is going. Scheme is positioned to be that next edge to cut with. It's very much like Python and Ruby, with similar usage properties and library distribution practices. But at the same time it's got a simpler core and a more powerful syntax layer. If we can just get people to stop discriminating against parenthesis and maybe get a nice web framework and a good deployment tool, we could see an explosion of usage in the Scehme world that inflates the space much like what happens with Ruby. I yearn for the day when using Scheme professionally is No Big Deal.
- j2d2 18y agoWhat's new is where a lot of independent programmers are. What's necessary is for something very practical to require scheme. Ruby would still be a hobbyists language if Rails didn't come along. Perhaps arc could help here in the future but even the scheme community isn't totally amped on arc and therefore not rallying behind it. Erlang seems better suited to be the next big lang than scheme. It has already found it's way into some of the big names like facebook and amazon, demonstrating practical importance, while solving problems that are still hard in other languages. cough concurrency...
- SwellJoe 18y agoThe world is so ripe for the next big language to be Scheme. Would Scheme with C syntax do it for you? If so, we're already there with JavaScript.
- sage_joch 18y agoThe importance of good documentation cannot be overstated. Clean code is not enough. While it can simplify the process of understanding its behavior unambiguously, it is limited in conveying its intended behavior. If a certain set of inputs doesn't work correctly on a function, is that a bug, or a known/intentional limitation? Tests play an important role in this as well, since they can convey intent in an executable format. Anyway, for what it's worth, I've got my eye on Clojure also.