8 ms·
You don't really have real cities in the US = there are a few exceptions but most of the time it's just a very tiny center and a lot of people living away from
by ekianjo 5y ago
You don't really have real cities in the US = there are a few exceptions but most of the time it's just a very tiny center and a lot of people living away from the center. That's not what a traditional city looks like.
- nine_k 5y agoExactly. The US has very few cities proper, and a lot of huge suburbs that sometimes feature a city-like downtown (L.A., Houston), and sometimes don't (most of the Silicon Valley). The real honest dense US cities, such as NYC, Boston, Philadelphia, Chicago, and a few others, were built large and dense before the advent of the car, and had entrenched public transportation system before 1930s. Those that were not as lucky got remade for cars in 1930-1960s, and cemented in that state by zoning regulations. Europe obviously had a large number of dense cities since medieval times. Even small cities in Europe often ended up dense due to land limitations, and the generally relatively high population density. Cities in the US very rarely faced this limitation early enough, with a few natural exceptions like Manhattan or San Francisco.
- monkeypawfan 5y agoI can't help but think that we're doing a repeat with building things around mobile phone use too
- ido 5y agoHow do mobile phones affect city planning?
- aurelianito 5y agoNo need for door bells. No need for street signs. No need for taxi stops. No need for privately owned cars (rent via phone app or use Uber like service). Those things affect urban planning a lot.
- pantalaimon 5y agoThat's silly. Phones can get damaged or stolen, looking at a sign is much faster than looking at a phony and signs hardly take up any space.
- tjr225 5y agoAre you suggesting that cars can't get damaged or stolen? lol
- zanny 5y agoIts still really convenient. It is really starting to pick up - I can use my phone to pay fares in a lot of metros now, have real time transit tracking, and use it for navigation even when walking. Its definitely, imo, to the point where it is becoming a responsibility of societies to provide its citizens access to these technologies because of their utility. That means subsidized / free phones and service, imo. Everyone really should have a baseline of digital access as a fundamental right, hopefully this decade. The COVID relief free cell service in the US I think has been an eye opener for me.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoI don't think we're ready for all those things to disappear. The only thing that really has gone since mobile phones are phone booths. But the thing is Street signs and door bells don't take up any space. There's no real benefit in removing them anyway. Private cars are a big issue but the problem is people commuting from outside the city and shared car schemes are too expensive for that.
- mymythisisthis 5y agoWalking around Toronto, Canada, I've noticed that it's getting harder to find street signs. Their placement is for drivers in cars, not for people walking.
- thakoppno 5y agoAll those phones require towers and some 5g bands need way more to blanket whole areas.
- ectopod 5y agoMany European cities were also constrained by city walls. Land may have been available but it wasn't necessarily defensible.
- vasilipupkin 5y agoL.A consists of many fairly dense walkable neighborhoods. You can live in these neighborhoods without a car.
- titzer 5y agoIf you mean Los Angeles then I can't disagree more. Maybe Westwood, maybe downtown. But "consisting many of fairly dense walkable neighborhoods" is not a description I would ever have been expected to be applied to Los Angeles.
- vasilipupkin 5y agoVenice, Santa Monica, West Hollywood, Silverlake ?
- titzer 5y agoThese are vanishingly small postage stamps compared the absolutely vast sprawl that is LA. I mean seriously. Get on the 10 and head east. Let me know when you get outside the sprawl. It'll be over an hour at highway speeds. It's that big. Just the city of LA itself is 503 square miles. Santa Monica is (nominally) 8 square miles--and most of that is not what you are referring to. 3rd street promenade, a few beachfront streets, a few blocks on Wilshire and Santa Monica blvd. I have a feeling you never really drove around LA and appreciated how absolutely massive it is. And here's a nice infographic comparing the density of LA and New York, if you're interested in more than anecdotes: https://www.its.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2014/05/0506OsgoodEtAL_LANYDensity_Poster.pdf https://www.its.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2014/05/... TLDR; no, LA is not mostly dense, walkable areas. Very far from it.
- vasilipupkin 5y agoI don’t live there, but I’ve driven around it. Just saying, it’s possible to get by without absolutely having to drive to get a cup of coffee or a bite to eat at least in some parts of LA. If that’s important to you, you can live in those parts. Most people actually don’t care about that at all. So, having to drive everywhere is not a problem for them.
- danielrpa 5y agoWhy does the US need to have traditional cities? I grew up in a high density city overseas and I can see the appeal of both types of city. I personally prefer low density, car centric cities (obviously we need to finish solving the emissions problem from cars, but that's separate).
- presentation 5y agoExcept that’s not separate by the fact that there isn’t a solution and the planet is being destroyed as a result.
- _8j50 5y agoIt means you are dependent on cars for one, which also means insurance companies, gas,car payment, etc... I am actively trying to ditch cars in a car city because of this. You wastr so much space for parking lots too. You interact with a lot less people because you are always at some destination with the journey barring you from interacting with the people of the city. Physical fitness and health is also affected. It is ridiculous. In order to have food and shelter you need to be dependent on not just a landlord and grocery store but also insurance companies, car dealers, oil and gas companies, DMV/DPS,mechanics,etc... and infractions against driving law can leave you unable to work, get food, go to the doctor (outside of ER),etc... a traditional city does not require a regulated license for teansporation and you don't spend almost as much as rent on transportation. Especially for low-income people, liquidity is important, it is the reason behind why it is expensive to be poor. Think if all the tragic social cost that can be avoided if people can instead spend money on their other needs instead of cars. I read somewhere how car makers bribed and played dirty to prevent things like rail cars from being adopted by cities. To me it relfects on how much corporate-run the city is.
- analog31 5y agoFrom what I can tell, depending on the "car lord" is getting worse and worse too. There may have been an era when cars got more affordable due to greater reliability and longevity. I'm concerned that the car makers have figured out how to defeat that idea by charging fees to use the electronics in your car, and that servicing the batteries is going to be a rent-seeker's heaven.