4 ms·
There is an alternative explanation - "the West" set its standards high. The only permissible economic activity has to be perfectly safe, do no harm and priorit
by roenxi 5y ago
There is an alternative explanation - "the West" set its standards high. The only permissible economic activity has to be perfectly safe, do no harm and priority is given to loud groups who object to change.
China (and, indeed, the rest of Asia) set standards lower. Economic activity is permissible if it makes life better for someone. Damage is acceptable.
The economy acted exactly how a neutral observer might expect it to and is rerouting all the manufacturing activity into Asia. This is the outcome where everyone gets what they want - and although a lot of people complain loudly, nobody in the West is willing to put up with the conditions needed to change the situation. All the stuff China is doing to get ahead is illegal in the West (eg, the pollution, letting IP restrictions go without much fuss).
Reactionaries are trying to legalise the economy away with about as much success as all the other attempts of the law to overrule the economy. The only thing that can stop the Chinese economy is China - if they don't handicap themselves then 1.4 billion will have the worlds most impressive economy and it won't be close. The military implications of a competent China are scary for the Anglosphere, but avoiding their goods isn't going to change the situation.
- sumedh 5y ago> China (and, indeed, the rest of Asia) set standards lower. You are claiming that the West did not have lower standards in the past which is not true, even the West went though the lower standard phase. You cannot just jump to higher standards from the start.
- kiba 5y agoPollution are just costs unaccounted and unpaid for.
- yeetaccount4 5y agoYep. America wants environmental laws locally, but they don’t want to import them for convenience’s sake. Nobody wants to fundamentally change their lifestyle. Take timber for instance. We rape Canada and South America for their trees, but protect trees domestically. This is completely absurd if you accept that environmental problems are global problems. It’s stupid to save a Spotted Owl and the forest locally if you’re letting Canada, China, Brazil or whoever do something 1000x worse while paying them for it. America needs to dog food it. Don’t like it? Don’t consume so much wood and export your catastrophe.
- meristohm 5y agoYes and—-we in the USA carry on taking resources from other places as if the people there need it less, and we continue to do it domestically; there were people here before my European ancestors, and their descendants continue to be shut out of ancestral lands. Shortsighted logging practices mean less for future generations. There are better ways to harvest trees (look at the Menominee in Wisconsin, for one). Suzanne Simard is one logger-turned-researcher (they can also overlap) whose publications I find helpful for managing the forest on the land I live on. Collectively using less seems key. To that end, some combination of regulation and culture shift?
- yeetaccount4 5y agoMy personal opinion is that we need to supply ourselves domestically (dog food it) and adjust prices to reflect the true cost. As for American Indians, as far as I know, they practically can’t do anything productive on their lands without an Act of Congress, it’s a crime. Small- and medium-time loggers are hardly paying rent though. I don’t know where the money is going. I’ve worked in supply and demand. It’s all crooked. Millers are thieves, as are others, etc.
- nradov 5y agoThere really isn't much logging of old growth Canadian forests any more. Most timber production is from trees specifically farmed to be cut down. Complaining about consuming too much wood is like complaining about eating too much wheat.
- kiba 5y agoExcept of course, the damage is very real, insidious and difficult to see. If a million people who could be born were never born, would you see it in the economic stats? Not if you don't take a conscious effort to try to model it. Of course, China is strong in many ways, but we would be remiss not to note China's weakness.
- bobthepanda 5y agoChina arguably is doing a lot to do it already. Chinese citizens were certainly not really happy with the environment; air pollution is probably one of the few issues that have really galvanized the population and resulted in protests in China's political climate. There's certainly been efforts made on that front, not least because in a country with severe water and land shortages polluting what they have doesn't make sense. https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/23/china/china-air-pollution-mic-intl-hnk/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/23/china/china-air-pollution-mic...
- toss1 5y agoEven simpler version - While the West thought the manufacturing was a petty concern and thought it was exploiting cheap Chinese labor, China had a longer term vision and exploited the West's myopic focus on quarterly profits. The West has now lost manufacturing know-how, is now subject to military supply chain issues and trojan horse hardware, has exported it's middle-class creating greater divisions, and given away huge leads in many military and economic fields. This will go down as a strategic blunder of historic proportions. It may still be recoverable, but it is getting late...