5 ms·
Nuclear is "bad" and scary... Plus you know nuclear weapons. And solar and wind produce plenty... Apart form times when they do not, like many times during wint
by Ekaros 5y ago
Nuclear is "bad" and scary... Plus you know nuclear weapons. And solar and wind produce plenty... Apart form times when they do not, like many times during winter.
- jacquesm 5y agoContinent sized landmasses can survive on wind and solar assuming HVDC interconnects. Some storage would be nice to have, preferably more than a weeks' worth.
- dijit 5y agoThis is an extremely naive assumption. Do you have any citations for such a theory? Everything I’ve read on the subject (admittedly not much) tells me that wind power is not only a disaster ecologically (kills too many birds, though not as many as domestic cats) but also unable to produce enough power to govern everything even with interconnects. Distribution of power is also difficult, but there was notably a “still” winter in Sweden which is driving up prices significantly due to hydro not being enough. (I live here, that’s how I know)
- jacquesm 5y agoI don't really understand the strong position you take while at the same time admitting to not having read much on the subject, and then to regurgitate a bunch of debunked nonsense. This is not a good basis for a discussion.
- dijit 5y ago“Citation please” “Everything I have read contradicts what you just stated.” Not sure how I could be clearer. Maybe I made a mistake by admitting my ignorance, but i would rather admit my ignorance than assume I know everything because I read 5 articles and watched a few YouTube videos.
- jacquesm 5y agoFor starters HVDC lines are being installed in many places and many are already operational, and the 'windmills kill too many birds' thing was a push by the fossil fuel industry and has been debunked. I don't know which five articles you have read but I suggest you read a couple more and more recent ones. As for 'citation please': that does presume that you have done your own homework, I really don't see why I should do it for you but as to those first two points of yours: https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-slayers-theyre-made-out-to-be-heres-why-79567 https://theconversation.com/wind-farms-are-hardly-the-bird-s... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HVDC_projects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_HVDC_projects Some of those links are well over 1000 km long.
- dijit 5y agoI appreciate the citations and I will read them. > I really don't see why I should do it for you Because the burden of proof rests with the person making the claim.
- nradov 5y agoWindmills do kill birds. That isn't seriously disputed. Some large wind farms have had a significant impact on threatened bird species. We might consider that an acceptable cost but the issue hasn't been debunked. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160929143808.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2016/09/160929143808.h...
- 5y ago
- jules 5y agoLet's approximate the cost of that. The energy consumption of my country (the Netherlands) was 3157 PJ in 2017. This was 980 kwh per person per week. Solar batteries cost a bit more than $1000 per kwh. So at these prices this plan costs approximately $1 million per person. Solar batteries last 5-15 years. If we say that they last 20 years, then the energy storage costs are $130 per person per day per week's worth of storage. This plan sounds feasible if costs come down by factor of 10.
- jacquesm 5y agoHow does it compare to the cost of a nuclear power plant? Storing a weeks worth of consumption on a 'per person' basis can be done for a fraction of $1m. But energy scarcity will lead to an increase in prices, which in turn will lead to a reduction in consumption. One big problem with energy is that it is still way too cheap. Another problem is that there are a lot of subsidies involved for large consumers as well as extra taxation on small consumers.
- jules 5y agoGenerating that amount of energy using nuclear would cost approximately $13.4 per person per day (IIRC ~3x what we're currently paying for it). Note that I have not included the cost to generate the energy in the $130 storage costs, but that cost is negligible compared to the $130 anyway. The environmental damage would probably also be much less with nuclear, versus a ton of solar + wind + batteries. But there would be disaster danger. It is unclear to me how the danger of nuclear disaster would compare to the danger of running out of stored energy in a winter month. > Storing a weeks worth of consumption on a 'per person' basis can be done for a fraction of $1m. How? Since the costs of storage are currently so huge, it seems to me that if you want to go the solar + wind route, it makes sense to overprovision energy generation. That would reduce the amount of storage you need, and the extra energy during summer would be somewhat useful. Note however that you would need massive amounts of wind+solar. For an average household to satisfy its electricity needs, it needs ~10 average size solar panels (assuming perfect storage). However, household electricity use is only 5% of our energy use. So to satisfy energy needs with solar, you need approximately 200 solar panels per household. Even if you round that down to 50 due to reduction in energy consumption and use of wind energy, it's still a lot. But the Netherlands is obviously not a very good country for solar. In countries like Australia, the numbers would look way better.